It’s hard to imagine personal jewelry without thinking of Pandora. For years, the brand has been the go-to for building custom charm bracelets that tell a story, one tiny sterling silver memory at a time. Their appeal is in the mix-and-match fun, letting you create a piece that’s completely unique to you without a massive price tag.
If you love the self-expression Pandora offers but are looking to explore new styles, price points, and aesthetics, you're in the right place. From heirloom luxury brands to minimalist indie designers, here are 21 other jewelry brands perfect for creating personalized pieces.
For those who love Pandora's customizable elements but crave a more luxurious and timeless feel, Tiffany & Co. delivers. Known for heirloom-quality pieces, they offer elegant engraved charms, lockets, and initial pendants that elevate personalization to a true luxury level. Think sterling silver, gold, and diamonds with that iconic Tiffany blue box experience.
While prices start around $200 for a simple charm, making it a splurge compared to Pandora, Tiffany's sophisticated designs are investment pieces you'll wear for life. It’s the perfect choice for commemorating major milestones with a classic, refined touch.
Shop now at tiffany.com
If Pandora’s a classic charm bracelet, Alex and Ani is its free-spirited, boho-chic cousin. Specializing in stackable bangles adorned with symbolic charms and infused with positive energy, the brand makes personalization feel meaningful and motivational. Their lightweight, adjustable bangles are perfect for creating an effortless arm party that tells your story.
With prices mostly in the $20-$50 range, Alex and Ani offers a highly affordable way to build a personal collection. While Pandora focuses on more traditional bead-style charms, Alex and Ani is all about spiritual symbols and a casual, earthy vibe. It’s perfect for adding a touch of soulfulness to your stack.
Shop now at alexandani.com
As a classic mall jeweler, KAY brings a more traditional and sentimental approach to customizable pieces. They offer a huge selection of options like engraved pendants, rings, birthstone jewelry, and charm bracelets that share Pandora's accessible, mid-range pricing ($50-$200).
KAY shines with classic gifts for special occasions - think timeless lockets and initial necklaces. If you love Pandora for its sentimentality but prefer designs that feel a bit more formal and traditional, KAY Jewelers is a fantastic alternative for creating heartfelt custom pieces.
Shop now at kay.com
Rooted in craftsmanship and meaningful design, James Avery offers artisanal jewelry with a timeless, handcrafted feel. You'll find a wide range of beautifully detailed charms, pendants, and rings that often feature spiritual and cultural symbols, making them deeply personal gifts.
Their pieces, generally priced from $30-$150, have a substantial, high-quality weight to them that sets them apart. While Pandora’s aesthetic is polished and modern, James Avery’s vibe is more rustic and soulful, appealing to anyone who values the art and meaning behind their jewelry collection.
Shop now at jamesavery.com
For the lovers of personalization who have a minimalist "less is more" style, Mejuri is the answer. As a direct-to-consumer favorite, they offer high-quality fine jewelry for daily wear at fair prices (around $50-$300). Their selection includes sleek initial necklaces, engravable rings, and pendants that feel modern and understated.
Mejuri stands out by using ethically sourced materials for pieces designed to be stacked and layered. It has the customizable heart of Pandora but with a sophisticated, contemporary filter, making it perfect for the fashion-forward crowd who want personal pieces that whisper instead of shout.
Shop now at mejuri.com
BaubleBar injects a dose of fun, color, and trend-driven energy into personalized jewelry. If you love customizing your pieces but want something bold and eye-catching, this brand delivers. They’re famous for custom-beaded bracelets, playful charm necklaces, and statement-making initial pieces that won’t break the bank, typically falling in the $20-$80 range.
Unlike Pandora’s classic elegance, BaubleBar is all about vibrant, playful accessorizing. It’s the perfect place to create a fun "poolside" name bracelet or a chunky initial necklace that instantly updates your outfit.
Shop now at baublebar.com
Swarovski offers all the sparkle you could want, combined with personalization options that feel glamorous and luxurious. Known for their brilliant-cut crystals, they offer customizable charms, birthstone pendants, and rings that catch the light from every angle. It's the perfect way to add some high-wattage shine to your jewelry box.
With prices ranging from $50-$200, Swarovski provides an accessible touch of luxury. They share Pandora's focus on building a collectible, customizable set, but their signature is that unmistakable sparkle and elevated, elegant finish.
Shop now at swarovski.com
Etsy isn't a single brand but a global marketplace brimming with independent artisans creating truly one-of-a-kind personalized jewelry. Whether you want a custom name necklace in a unique font, a ring engraved with your handwriting, or charms modeled after your pet, you can find a seller on Etsy to make it happen at any price point.
The beauty of Etsy is the endless variety and the connection to the creator. It’s the ultimate alternative to Pandora for anyone seeking something highly specific or a piece that feels 100% handmade and unique.
Shop now at etsy.com
Kate Spade’s jewelry collection embodies the brand's playfully sophisticated spirit. Their personalization options, like charm bracelets and witty initial necklaces, carry a dose of whimsical, preppy fun. Expect bright colors, clever designs, and an overall polished yet cheerful vibe.
Generally priced between $40-$150, Kate Spade jewelry offers a great alternative to Pandora for those who identify with a more colorful and lighthearted style. Where Pandora leans into sentimentality, Kate Spade is about showcasing your vibrant personality.
Shop now at katespade.com
Monica Vinader offers a refined take on personalization, focusing on sleek, modern designs perfect for everyday luxury. The brand is known for its beautiful engraving services on signature pieces like linear bracelets, friendship bracelets, and coin pendants made with sustainable materials. It’s favored by celebrities and fashion editors for its understated elegance.
As a more premium brand ($100-$500), Monica Vinader is a step up from Pandora in both price and style. If your taste leans more contemporary and you love diamond-finished details, this is the brand for you.
Shop now at monicavinader.com
For the ultimate minimalist, Loren Stewart creates delicate, refined jewelry that feels personal yet incredibly chic. They specialize in super-subtle initial necklaces, engravable rings, and tiny charms perfect for layering without feeling overdone. All their pieces are crafted in Los Angeles from high-quality and recycled metals.
Priced mostly between $50 and $200, this brand contrasts with Pandora's more-is-more charm aesthetic. It’s the ideal choice if you want your personalization to be a quiet little secret - a tiny initial visible only to you.
Shop now at lorenstewart.com
A favorite among fashion influencers, Missoma hits the sweet spot between trendy and timeless design. The brand excels at creating the perfect layered look, offering tons of initial charms, zodiac pendants, and engravable pieces made with high-quality gold vermeil. It’s perfect for building a personalized necklace stack.
With prices in the $50-$300 range, Missoma is more fashion-forward than Pandora. If you love experimenting with chain textures and stacking different charms to create a trendy "neck mess," Missoma is your go-to.
Shop now at missoma.com
With its laid-back Southern California vibe, Gorjana offers simple, versatile jewelry that’s made for everyday wear. Their personalization options include easy-to-stack initial necklaces, birthstone studs, and engravable bangles that feel effortlessly chic. The designs are lightweight and perfect for wearing from the office to the beach.
Gorjana's approachable price point ($40-$150) and focus on delicate layering make it a great alternative to Pandora for anyone with a relaxed, minimalist style who still wants meaningful, customizable pieces.
Shop now at gorjana.com
Brooklyn-based Catbird has a cult following for its delicate, almost weightless, handcrafted jewelry. The brand championed the "stacking ring" trend and offers a stunning variety of tiny, personal pieces - think whisper-thin engraved rings and sweetly minuscule charms. Everything is made in their studio with recycled materials and ethically sourced gems.
While still affordable (starting around $50), Catbird's artisanal quality gives it a special feel. It's the antithesis of Pandora's bolder charm style, perfect for those who find beauty in the most delicate and subtle details.
Shop now at catbirdnyc.com
Though best known for shoes and bags, Brother Vellies by Aurora James offers jewelry that reflects the brand's commitment to artisanal craftsmanship and cultural storytelling. Their offerings include beautiful charms and pendants rooted in tradition that can be mixed to create a deeply personal and unique statement piece.
With prices around $50-$300, the pieces stand out for their one-of-a-kind, handmade quality. Unlike Pandora’s polished charms, Brother Vellies' jewelry feels like possessing a small piece of wearable art with a rich narrative.
Shop now at brothervellies.com
Vrai merges tech and luxury with its focus on sustainably created, lab-grown diamonds. For those looking for eco-conscious fine jewelry, Vrai offers customizable engagement rings, initial pendants, and diamond charms that are both beautiful and ethical. Their modern designs let the brilliant diamonds do all the talking.
Prices start at around $200 for simpler pieces, positioning Vrai as a high-end alternative to Pandora. It’s for the discerning customer who wants their personalized jewelry to not only be meaningful but also forward-thinking and sustainable.
Shop now at vrai.com
Much like Etsy, JewelStreet is a curated online marketplace connecting you with over 500 independent jewelry designers from around the world. The platform offers a highly diverse range of customizable jewelry, from classic initial necklaces to bespoke birthstone rings, all with a distinct, non-mass-produced feel.
With prices ranging from affordable ($30) to high luxury ($500+), its strength lies in discovery. It's a fantastic alternative to Pandora for finding unique, handcrafted personalized jewelry from a global community of artisans.
Shop now at jewelstreet.com
If your personal style is more edgy and bold, Luv Aj offers statement-making jewelry that’s anything but shy. The brand excels at chunky chains, oversized hardware, and layering pieces with a rebellious, modern spirit. Their personalized options, including striking initial charms and pendants, fit right in with this aesthetic.
Priced accessibly from $50 to $200, Luv Aj gives jewelry lovers a way to embrace personalization with a fashion-forward, confident edge that sets it apart from Pandora's more classic and sweet appeal.
Shop now at luvaj.com
As a fast-fashion powerhouse, Missguided offers ultra-affordable, on-trend jewelry perfect for experimenting with personalized styles. You'll find of-the-moment initial necklaces, cheap and cheerful charm bracelets, and customizable rings that let you try out a look without a big investment. Almost everything is under $50.
While Pandora focuses on long-lasting sterling silver, Missguided is all about having fun with current fads. It’s an easy, low-commitment way to play with personalized trends.
Shop now at missguided.com
Sophie B.’s specialty is delicate, feminine jewelry that celebrates personal milestones with understated grace. Her collection includes pretty initial pendants, dainty birthstone rings, and petite charms perfect for adding a subtle dash of meaning to your everyday look. Each piece is designed for layering and has a timeless, gentle feel.
Pricing typically falls between $30 and $150. If you love the idea of Pandora’s customizable spirit but prefer a more subtle, refined aesthetic, Sophie B. Jewelry is a perfect match.
Shop now at sophiebjewelry.com
Ana Luisa has gained popularity for mixing stylish, minimalist designs with a commitment to sustainability. They craft their pieces from recycled materials and release them in small batches to reduce waste. Their offerings include chic initial necklaces and modern, stackable rings that feel perfect for the eco-conscious consumer.
With a moderate price point ($40-$200), Ana Luisa shares Pandora's accessibility but brings a clean, contemporary aesthetic. It's an excellent choice for those wanting personalized jewelry with a modern look and an ethical backstory.
Shop now at analuisa.com
At Apart Style, we're obsessed with curating the best in fashion, beauty, and jewelry to help you discover new brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, style, and uniqueness. When you make a purchase through our links, Apart Style may earn a commission - which helps support our small team, and allows us to continue bringing you the best in online style brands.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our full brand directory or check out our curated brand guides to find your new favorite thing.
