Rolex Smurf vs. Bluesy: Here's how they compare

The Rolex Submariner 'Smurf' and 'Bluesy' are two of the most coveted blue-themed divers from Rolex, but they appeal to vastly different tastes. The key distinction lies in their materials and aesthetic: the 'Smurf' (Ref. 116619LB) is crafted from solid 18k white gold for a subtle, weighty luxury, while the 'Bluesy' (Ref. 126613LB) features a bold two-tone combination of Oystersteel and 18k yellow gold. This material choice deeply influences not only their look - understated vs. flashy - but also their price point and exclusivity.

Here’s a detailed comparison to help you decide which iconic blue Submariner is the right choice for you.

Rolex Submariner 'Smurf' (Ref. 116619LB)

The Rolex Submariner 'Smurf' occupies a unique space as a full precious metal version of the brand's legendary tool watch. Introduced in 2008, it earned its nickname from its solid blue bezel and flat blue dial, a rare combination that gives it an unmistakable look. Being discontinued makes it a prime target for serious watch collectors seeking something exclusive.

• What it is: A now-discontinued Submariner Date crafted entirely from solid 18k white gold, featuring a unique flat blue, non-sunray dial and matching blue Cerachrom bezel.
• Key features: 40mm solid 18k white gold case and Oyster bracelet, unidirectional blue Cerachrom bezel, "Glidelock" extension system, and a robust Calibre 3135 movement.
• Price: Originally retailed around $38,000. On the secondary market today, prices typically range from $40,000 to over $50,000 depending on condition.
• Materials/Construction: The entire case and bracelet are made from Rolex's proprietary 18k white gold, giving it significant heft and a cool, muted luster compared to steel.
• Pros: Embodies "stealth wealth" as it can be mistaken for stainless steel by the untrained eye, offers the substantial feel of a precious metal watch, the flat blue dial is unique and prized by collectors, its discontinued status adds to its exclusivity.
• Cons: Extremely expensive, very heavy on the wrist which may be a comfort issue for some, white gold is softer than steel and more susceptible to scuffs and scratches.

This is the choice for a dedicated collector who prioritizes rarity, precious materials, and understated luxury over overt recognition.

Explore this collection: rolex.com/watches/submariner

Rolex Submariner 'Bluesy' (Ref. 126613LB)

The 'Bluesy' is arguably one of the most recognizable Rolex models ever made. Its vibrant pairing of resilient Oystersteel with lustrous 18k yellow gold makes it an icon of sport-luxury. The latest reference stands out with its dynamic royal blue sunray dial that brilliantly catches the light, delivering a look that is both elegant and unapologetically bold.

• What it is: A "Rolesor" (two-tone) Submariner Date combining stainless steel and 18k yellow gold, featuring a striking royal blue sunray dial and a blue Cerachrom bezel with gold numerals.
• Key features: Updated 41mm case, modern Calibre 3235 movement with a 70-hour power reserve, brilliant sunray dial finish, and yellow gold accents on the bezel, crown, and center bracelet links.
• Price: Retails for $15,600, with secondary market prices currently ranging from $18,000 to $22,000+.
• Materials/Construction: Fuses the durability of Oystersteel on the outer links and case with the prestige of 18k yellow gold on the bezel, crown, and center bracelet links.
• Pros: Iconic and instantly recognizable design, gorgeous sunray dial offers incredible visual depth, relatively more accessible price point for a precious metal Rolex, offers modern movement technology and a longer power reserve.
• Cons: The two-tone look is bold and may not suit all personal styles, less exclusive compared to a solid gold model, the gold components are less scratch-resistant than their steel counterparts.

This is the watch for someone who wants a luxurious and eye-catching daily timepiece that makes a confident statement.

Shop this product: rolex.com/watches/submariner/m126613lb-0002

Rolex Smurf vs. Bluesy Comparison

Materials & Aesthetic

This is the most significant point of difference. The 'Smurf' is the epitome of subtle, high-end luxury. Its solid 18k white gold construction is heavy and luxurious but can fly under the radar. Its appeal is in what it lacks: the flash of yellow gold. Combined with its consistent, flat blue dial, the overall look is monochromatic and reserved.

The 'Bluesy' is the opposite, it's designed to be noticed. The strong contrast between yellow gold and stainless steel creates an immediate visual impact. This is boosted by its royal blue sunray dial, which shifts in color from deep navy to brilliant azure depending on the light. While the Smurf whispers luxury, the Bluesy announces it.

Exclusivity & Value

As a discontinued solid white gold piece, the Smurf holds the edge in rarity and exclusivity. It was produced in fewer numbers than the two-tone Bluesy and is now only available on the pre-owned market, driving its price and collector demand higher. It is a genuine investment-grade collector's item.

The Bluesy, while still incredibly popular and retaining its value exceptionally well, is a current production model and therefore more attainable. It holds strong value and is a great asset, but it doesn't have the same scarcity factor as the Smurf.

Wearability & Comfort

The Smurf's 40mm case combined with its solid white gold construction makes it noticeably heavier on the wrist. For some, this weight feels supremely luxurious, for others, it can be cumbersome for all-day wear. The newer Bluesy has a slightly larger 41mm case, but its mixture of steel and gold makes it considerably lighter and, for many, more comfortable as a daily watch.

Movement & Technology

The original Smurf (Ref. 116619LB) housed the time-tested Calibre 3135 movement with a solid 48-hour power reserve. However, the current Bluesy (Ref. 126613LB) is equipped with the new-generation Calibre 3235. This movement offers superior performance, including anti-magnetism, an improved Chronergy escapement, and a modern power reserve of approximately 70 hours - a clear technical advantage.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both watches offer prestige and legendary Rolex engineering, but they serve different buyers.

Choose the 'Smurf' if:

• You prefer "stealth wealth" and appreciate luxury that isn't openly announced.
• You are a serious collector focused on rarity and the investment potential of discontinued models.
• You love the significant, substantial feel of a solid precious metal watch on your wrist.
• Your budget is higher, and you view your watch as a long-term collector asset.

Choose the 'Bluesy' if:

• You want a visually stunning and iconic watch that is instantly recognizable as a Rolex.
• You appreciate a bold, high-contrast aesthetic that pairs well with many styles.
• You want a durable and technically modern daily luxury watch with a longer power reserve.
• You prefer a watch with a dynamic sunray dial that constantly changes its character.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the main difference between the Rolex Smurf and Bluesy?

The primary difference is material and appearance. The Smurf is crafted from solid 18k white gold for an understated, monochrome look. The Bluesy is a two-tone mix of stainless steel and 18k yellow gold for a much bolder, higher-contrast look. This also affects the dial, the Smurf has a flat blue, while the Bluesy has a reflective sunray blue.

Is the Rolex Smurf still in production?

No, the original 'Smurf' (Ref. 116619LB with the blue dial) was discontinued in 2020. Rolex now makes a different white gold Submariner (Ref. 126619LB) that features a blue bezel but a black dial, often nicknamed the 'Cookie Monster'.

Why is the Rolex Smurf so expensive?

Its price is driven by two factors: its construction from solid 18k white gold, a precious and expensive metal, and its status as a highly sought-after, discontinued collector's piece.

Is the Rolex Bluesy a good investment?

Yes, the Rolex Bluesy has historically been an excellent store of value. It is one of Rolex's most popular models and consistently commands prices well above its retail value on the secondary market.

Which is heavier, the Smurf or the Bluesy?

The Smurf is significantly heavier. White gold is much denser than stainless steel, so the solid white gold case and bracelet of the Smurf give it substantially more weight than the steel-and-gold mix of the Bluesy.

What's the difference in watch movements?

The original Smurf used the Calibre 3135 movement, which has about a 48-hour power reserve. The current-generation Bluesy uses the Calibre 3235 movement, which is technologically more advanced and offers a 70-hour power reserve.

Which watch is more versatile?

For daily wear, the Bluesy is often considered more versatile. It is lighter, its steel components offer better scratch resistance, and its iconic look fits in settings from casual to business dress. The Smurf's extreme value and weight make it more of a special occasion or collector's piece.