Louis Vuitton All In vs. Neverfull: Which one is better?

The Louis Vuitton Neverfull is the brand's iconic, flexible tote known for its timeless style and spacious, open-top design. By contrast, the Louis Vuitton All In is a newer, more contemporary tote defined by its structured, boxy silhouette and organized interior, offering a more polished and professional aesthetic.

Here's everything you need to know to decide between these two excellent luxury totes.

Louis Vuitton Neverfull

Launched in 2007, the Neverfull quickly became one of Louis Vuitton's most recognizable and successful bags. It's celebrated for its simple brilliance - a durable, reversible, and incredibly spacious tote with side laces that allow you to cinch the bag for a more compact look. Its unstructured nature makes it perfect for everything from a daily carry-all to a travel companion.

• What it is: A large, open-top tote bag made from coated canvas, with thin leather handles, side laces, and a removable zippered pouch.
• Key features: Extremely spacious main compartment, iconic Monogram or Damier prints, slim but strong leather straps, and an included pouch that can be used as a small clutch.
• Price: Approximately $1,500 - $2,000, depending on size and specific material.
• Materials/Construction: Made from durable coated canvas with Vachetta leather trim that develops a unique patina over time.
• Sizing/Fit: Available in three popular sizes: PM (small, "petit modele"), MM (medium, "moyen modele"), and GM (large, "grand modele"). The MM is the most popular choice for everyday use.
• Pros: Timeless and iconic design, incredibly versatile for work or travel, comes in multiple sizes, lightweight for its capacity, and includes a useful separate pouch.
• Cons: The open top offers minimal security, the unstructured design can feel slouchy and may sag without a base shaper, and the Vachetta leather requires careful maintenance.

This is the perfect choice for anyone seeking a classic, do-it-all luxury tote that prioritizes maximum space and timeless style over built-in structure.

Shop this product: louisvuitton.com

Louis Vuitton All In

The All In tote is a more modern interpretation of the classic carry-all, designed for someone who appreciates clean lines and a structured shape. Unlike the Neverfull's soft form, the All In is more rigid, with a distinct boxy silhouette that holds its shape whether empty or full. It’s crafted to blend contemporary design with functional features for a sophisticated, professional look.

• What it is: A structured, rectangular tote with a flat base, leather accents, and more built-in interior organization than the Neverfull.
• Key features: Polished, boxy silhouette that won't collapse, interior pockets for organization, and a more defined, modern aesthetic.
• Price: Around $2,000, placing it at the premium end of the Louis Vuitton tote offerings.
• Materials/Construction: Crafted from the same durable coated canvas as the Neverfull, but with reinforced sides and construction to maintain its rigid structure.
• Sizing/Fit: Typically offered in a single size comparable to the Neverfull MM, but with different proportions due to its structured nature.
• Pros: Maintains a polished, upright shape. Interior pockets improve organization. The structured base adds stability. Offers a more contemporary and less common alternative to the Neverfull.
• Cons: The rigid structure makes it less packable or flexible. Generally only available in one size, limiting options. It is priced higher than the most popular Neverfull models.

This tote is an excellent fit for professionals who need a polished bag that stands up on its own and provides better interior organization for daily essentials.

Shop this product: louisvuitton.com

Louis Vuitton All In vs. Neverfull Comparison

Style & Aesthetic

The core difference between these two bags is their look and feel. The Neverfull champions a timeless, relaxed aesthetic. It's approachable, classic, and has a soft form that molds to your body. Its slouchy vibe makes it incredibly versatile, suitable for casual weekends, office commutes, and as an airplane carry-on.

The All In, on the other hand, is all about sophisticated structure. Its clean, boxy lines and rigid construction convey a modern, polished look. It appears more formal and intentional - less of a "throw-it-all-in" bag and more of a composed statement piece well-suited for professional environments or chic city outings.

Structure & Practicality

Practicality is where these two bags really diverge. The Neverfull’s one large, open compartment is its biggest pro and con. It can hold a huge amount but lacks any built-in organization, which can sometimes lead to a frustrating search for keys or a wallet. Many owners purchase a third-party organizer insert to solve this. Its soft sides mean it doesn’t stand up on its own unless very full.

The All In was designed to solve these issues. Its structured base and sides mean it stands upright perfectly, making it easy to access. The addition of interior pockets provides designated spots for smaller items, keeping everything neat and tidy. The trade-off is a loss of flexibility - you can’t overstuff the All In or flatten it for packing in the same way you can with a Neverfull.

Sizing & Capacity

When it comes to options, the Neverfull has a clear advantage with its three distinct sizes: PM, MM, and GM. This range allows you to fine-tune your choice based on your daily needs, from a smaller day bag (PM) to a massive carry-all capable of holding a weekend's worth of items (GM). The MM is often considered the "just right" size for daily use.

The All In is typically available in one size that is dimensionally similar to the Neverfull MM. However, its rigid shape means its capacity is fixed. The softer Neverfull can often accommodate bulky or awkwardly shaped items more easily, even if the on-paper measurements are close.

Price & Value

The Neverfull line offers a more accessible entry into the world of Louis Vuitton totes, with the PM size starting around $1,500. The All In is positioned at a higher price point, closer to $2,000, aligning it with the larger Neverfull models.

In terms of value, the Neverfull is an iconic piece with decades of proven demand and excellent resale value. It is a very safe investment for a luxury bag. The All In, while beautifully crafted, does not have the same iconic status. Its value is tied more to its functional modern design rather than its history, which may appeal more to a buyer focused on current aesthetics.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both are fantastic bags crafted with Louis Vuitton's signature quality, but they cater to very different preferences and lifestyles.

Choose the Neverfull if:

• You want a timeless, iconic tote that will remain a classic for years to come.
• You need maximum, unfussy space for everything from laptops to travel necessities.
• You prefer a versatile bag that works for casual weekends, office days, and travel.
• You like having options and want to choose the perfect size (PM, MM, or GM) for your frame.

Choose the All In if:

• You prefer a structured bag that stands on its own and always looks polished.
• You value built-in organization and want dedicated internal pockets.
• Your primary need is a professional work tote that maintains its shape.
• You appreciate modern design and want a less common style than the wildly popular Neverfull.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the main difference between the Louis Vuitton Neverfull and All In?

The main difference is structure and style. The Neverfull is a soft, unstructured, and timeless tote with a relaxed feel. The All In is a modern, structured bag with a rigid, boxy shape that stands up on its own and offers better interior organization.

Which is bigger, the Neverfull or the All In?

The Louis Vuitton Neverfull GM is the largest bag overall. The All In is typically sized similarly to the Neverfull MM. However, because the Neverfull is unstructured, it can often feel more spacious and accommodate bulkier items than the more rigid All In.

Is the Louis Vuitton All In discontinued?

Louis Vuitton frequently updates its collections, and some models like the All In may be phased out or become harder to find. It's always best to check the official website or a boutique for the most current availability. Pre-owned luxury sites are also an excellent place to find it.

Which bag is better for work?

The All In is often considered better for a formal or corporate work environment because its structured, polished look appears more professional. The Neverfull is also a popular work bag, especially for those who need to carry a lot, but its slouchier look can feel more casual.

Which one holds its value better?

The Neverfull is an iconic, classic bag with exceptionally strong resale value. It has been a bestseller for over a decade and is consistently in high demand. The All In holds its value well as a Louis Vuitton product, but it does not have the same proven long-term investment profile as the Neverfull.

Does the Neverfull sag?

Yes, due to its unstructured design and thin base, the Neverfull will sag when filled with heavy items. Many owners use a "base shaper" or a purse organizer insert to give it more structure and keep its bottom flat.

Does the Louis Vuitton All In hold its shape?

Yes, its key design feature is its structure. The All In has a reinforced base and side panels that allow it to maintain its boxy, upright shape even when it's not full.

Which bag is more durable?

Both bags are made from Louis Vuitton's extremely durable coated canvas, which is known for its resistance to scratches and water. Durability of the main body is comparable on both. The handles and trim on both are made of Vachetta leather, which requires care but is also very strong.