Calia vs. Fabletics: Which brand should you buy? [2026]

While Calia was founded by Carrie Underwood and Fabletics was co-founded by Kate Hudson, they serve different activewear needs. Calia specializes in timeless, minimalist designs made with high-quality, durable materials at a mid-range price point. Fabletics, on the other hand, operates on a subscription-based model that delivers trendy, budget-friendly styles in a broad and inclusive size range.

Let's compare everything you need to know to choose the right activewear brand for your style, budget, and workout routine.

Calia: The Minimalist & Versatile Activewear Brand

Calia focuses on versatile, high-performance pieces that effortlessly transition from a Spin class to running errands. The brand targets women who value quality craftsmanship and understated style, offering well-constructed basics that can be a core part of an active wardrobe for years. With its focus on longevity over fast fashion, Calia represents a solid investment in comfort and function.

• Product mix: A curated collection of activewear including leggings, sports bras, tanks, jackets, and accessories designed for gym, yoga, and everyday life.
• Price point: Mid-range, with leggings typically around $70 and sports bras costing about $50. The pricing reflects a greater emphasis on premium fabrics and durable construction.
• Quality & Materials: Calia uses high-quality performance fabrics with four-way stretch and moisture-wicking properties. Garments feature squat-proof designs and flatlock seams that ensure they withstand intense workouts and frequent washing.
• Sizing/Fit: Sizing runs true to size and is offered in XS to XL. The fit is designed to be compressive yet comfortable, providing support without feeling restrictive.
• Return policy: Standard 30-day return policy for items in their original condition, making it easy to find your perfect fit online.
• Style & Aesthetic: The brand's style is modern, minimalist, and sleek. Collections feature neutral color palettes and subtle branding, prioritizing timeless silhouettes over passing trends.

Calia is best for those who prioritize long-lasting quality and chic, minimalist designs for both workouts and casual wear.

Shop Calia: caliastudio.com

Fabletics: The Trendy & Subscription-Based Brand

Fabletics disrupted the activewear market with its affordable, subscription-based model and fresh, fashion-forward designs. It caters to a younger, trend-conscious audience that enjoys experimenting with bold colors and patterns without breaking the bank. With a strong focus on body positivity, Fabletics offers one of the most inclusive size ranges in the activewear industry.

• Product mix: A massive selection of leggings, sports bras, tops, outerwear, and accessories. New collections are released monthly, keeping the offerings timely and on-trend.
• Price point: Very budget-friendly, especially with the VIP membership. Members can snag leggings for as low as $25, and two-piece sets are a signature deal. Non-member prices are higher but still competitive.
• Quality & Materials: The quality is good for the price point, using standard polyester and elastane performance blends. While durable enough for regular use, some pieces might not have the same longevity or high-end feel as Calia's.
• Sizing/Fit: Extremely inclusive, offering sizes from XXS to 4X. Fit can sometimes be inconsistent between different styles, so reading product reviews is helpful.
• Membership Model: The VIP membership is central to the Fabletics experience, unlocking deep discounts and personalized outfit recommendations. You can skip any month free of charge, which is a key feature of purchasing.
• Style & Aesthetic: Fashion-forward, colorful, and bold. Fabletics is known for eye-catching prints, vibrant hues, and unique details that make a statement in and out of the gym.

Fabletics is the ideal choice for budget-conscious shoppers who love trendy styles, frequent deals, and an inclusive size range.

Shop Fabletics: fabletics.com

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Calia or Fabletics cheaper?

Fabletics is significantly cheaper, especially for VIP members who take advantage of intro offers and monthly credits. Calia is priced higher, reflecting its focus on more premium materials and classic designs built for longevity.

Are Calia and Fabletics owned by the same person?

No, they are not. Calia was founded by actress Carrie Underwood, while Fabletics was co-founded by actress Kate Hudson. They are two separate and distinct companies. Calia focuses on quality and versatility, while Fabletics is built on a subscription model for trendy, affordable styles.

Which has better quality, Calia or Fabletics?

Calia is generally recognized as having higher-quality materials and more durable construction. Their leggings and bras are designed to last for years, whereas Fabletics prioritizes affordability and trendiness, which can sometimes come at the expense of long-term durability.

How does Calia sizing run?

Calia sizing is very consistent and runs true to size. They offer a standard range from XS to XL, and shoppers can confidently order their usual size.

Is Fabletics sizing accurate?

Fabletics offers a highly inclusive size range from XXS to 4X. Sizing is mostly consistent, but due to the vast number of different styles released each month, it's a good practice to read customer reviews for specific items to determine if a piece runs small, large, or true to size.

Which brand is better for Lululemon alternatives?

Because of its focus on trend-driven designs at an affordable price, Fabletics is more often seen as an alternative to pricier brands like Lululemon. While the quality isn't directly comparable, Fabletics offers a similar stylish aesthetic for a fraction of the cost.

Which brand is more sustainable?

Calia places a stronger emphasis on sustainable practices, often using eco-friendly and recycled fabrics in its manufacturing. Fabletics is making progress in sustainability, but as a brand with a faster production cycle, Calia currently has a clearer focus on environmental responsibility.