If you're looking for classic men's shoes that look sharp without an eye-watering price tag, chances are you're already familiar with Stacy Adams. Their polished dress shoes, loafers, and boots are go-tos for guys who appreciate a timeless, sophisticated look that blends vintage inspiration with everyday comfort.
But when you're ready to expand your footwear collection, you'll find plenty of other brands that hit that same sweet spot of style, quality, and value. Whether you want an upgrade, a more modern twist, or a budget-friendly alternative, here are 17 brands like Stacy Adams worth checking out for your next pair.
For those ready to invest in a pair of shoes that will last a lifetime, Allen Edmonds is the top choice. These handcrafted, American-made shoes are built with premium leathers and Goodyear welt construction, which means they can be re-soled again and again. Their styles are timelessly elegant, focusing on classic oxfords, loafers, and boots.
While definitely a step up in price (typically $300-$500), think of them as an investment piece. If you love the traditional aesthetic of Stacy Adams but want superior craftsmanship and longevity, Allen Edmonds delivers.
Shop now at www.allenedmonds.com
Johnston & Murphy perfectly balances classic design with modern comfort. Offering everything from dress shoes to boots, they cater to men who want versatile footwear that works for both the office and the weekend. Their shoes often feature sleeker silhouettes and innovative comfort features without straying too far from their traditional roots.
Priced between $150 and $300, they offer a meaningful upgrade in quality from Stacy Adams without entering the luxury price tier. It's a great middle ground for refined style and solid construction.
Shop now at www.johnstonmurphy.com
As another heritage footwear brand, Florsheim is perhaps one of the closest direct competitors to Stacy Adams. They're known for producing stylish and dependable men's dress shoes and loafers at a very accessible price point, usually an affordable $80 to $150.
Florsheim focuses on classic styles made with comfortable insoles and durable leather, making them perfect for everyday office wear. If you're looking for the Stacy Adams vibe - sometimes at a slightly lower price - Florsheim is a must-see.
Shop now at www.florsheim.com
If comfort is your top priority, but you refuse to sacrifice style, Cole Haan is your brand. They masterfully blend traditional shoemaking with sneaker-like technology, like their famous Grand.OS cushioning. This means you can get the look of a classic Oxford or loafer with all-day, walk-anywhere comfort.
With most styles in the $150-$300 range, their aesthetic is a bit more contemporary and sleek than Stacy Adams. It's the ideal choice for the modern professional who wants a polished look that feels incredibly lightweight and supportive.
Shop now at www.colehaan.com
Home of the original penny loafer, G.H. Bass & Co. (creator of the Weejuns) is the authority on preppy, timeless style. While they offer other shoe styles, their loafers are legendary for a reason. They embody a polished yet relaxed aesthetic that's been a staple in menswear for decades.
Falling in the $100-$200 price range, Bass Weejuns capture a specific kind of classic cool. If your style leans into vintage-inspired charm and you live in loafers, this is the perfect brand to explore.
Shop now at www.bass.com
For a dose of luxury and high-impact style, Mezlan is the answer. This brand specializes in beautifully crafted men’s shoes made from high-end leathers and exotic skins like crocodile and lizard. Intricate detailing, rich textures, and elegant designs set them apart.
Positioned as a premium brand, prices typically start around $400. While Stacy Adams offers timeless appeal, Mezlan delivers a much more opulent and distinctive look - perfect for making a statement at special events or in an upscale corporate setting.
Shop now at www.mezlan.com
Clarks has built a stellar reputation for creating some of the most comfortable and practical men's shoes on the market. From their iconic Desert Boot to classic dress loafers, they put a strong emphasis on wearable, everyday styles that don't compromise on comfort.
Priced affordably between $80 and $150, Clarks shoes often have a more relaxed and casual vibe than Stacy Adams, but their dressier styles are still perfect for smart-casual offices and semi-formal events. It's the go-to for foolproof comfort and effortless style.
Shop now at www.clarksusa.com
Handcrafted in Spain, Magnanni creates sleek, sophisticated footwear with a distinct European flair. Known for their hand-finished leathers and elegant silhouettes, these shoes are both modern and timeless. They achieve a level of refinement through techniques like beautiful patinas and Bologna construction, which makes for a flexible, glove-like fit.
As a luxury brand, Magnanni prices start around $400. They share a passion for formal style with Stacy Adams but elevate it with a sleeker, more fashion-forward look rooted in Italian design principles.
Shop now at www.magnanni.com
Hugo Boss delivers footwear with a sharp, contemporary, and minimalist edge. Their dress shoes and loafers are perfect for men who prefer a clean, tailored aesthetic. Made with high-quality materials, their designs are often striking in their simplicity.
With a price range of $200 to $400, Hugo Boss offers a modern alternative to the vintage-inspired feel of Stacy Adams. If your wardrobe is more trend-focused and professional, these shoes will fit right in.
Shop now at www.hugoboss.com
Embodying classic Italian elegance, Bruno Magli has been crafting luxury footwear for decades. Their shoes are known for fine leathers, sophisticated lines, and a relentlessly polished finish. It's the kind of timeless style that looks effortlessly good with a suit.
Priced from $350 to $600, Bruno Magli operates in the luxury space. It's an excellent step up for someone who appreciates the classic vibe of Stacy Adams but wants to invest in premium European craftsmanship and materials.
Shop now at www.brunomagli.com
Best known for creating the world's first boat shoe, Sperry is the undisputed king of preppy, nautical style. While their iconic boat shoes are a must-have for laid-back weekends, the brand also offers a solid range of casual loafers and oxfords that carry that same relaxed, classic spirit.
At a very accessible price point of $50-$150, Sperry provides a casual counterpoint to Stacy Adams' dressier focus. Perfect for smart-casual looks, they're the ultimate shoe for effortless off-duty style.
Shop now at www.sperry.com
Handcrafted in Italy, To Boot New York shoes mix timeless cobbling techniques with a modern, metropolitan sensibility. Their styles are refined and sleek, using incredibly supple leathers to create silhouettes that are both sophisticated and comfortable right out of the box.
As a high-end brand, expect prices between $400 and $700. Like Stacy Adams, they have a deep respect for classic footwear, but To Boot New York pushes a more fashion-conscious design for guys who love quality and current style.
Shop now at toboot.com
Santoni represents the pinnacle of Italian luxury shoemaking. Every pair is an exercise in exquisite craftsmanship, made from the finest leathers and painstakingly hand-finished to achieve rich, nuanced colors. Their designs are sleek, elegant, and absolutely stunning.
This is a true ultra-luxury brand, with prices often ranging from $500 to over $1,000. For a milestone event or the discerning collector, Santoni offers a statement piece that takes the formal elegance of Stacy Adams to an artisanal level.
Shop now at www.santonishoes.com
Kenneth Cole offers sharp, contemporary footwear that's perfect for the modern man's lifestyle. Their shoes are versatile, easily transitioning from the boardroom to a night out. The aesthetic is clean and minimalist, offering a sleek look without being overly trendy.
With prices generally sitting in the $100-$200 range, it provides a fashionable yet affordable alternative. Where Stacy Adams leans vintage, Kenneth Cole leans modern, making it a great choice for a streamlined, professional wardrobe.
Shop now at www.kennethcole.com
Built on a foundation of Scandinavian minimalism and ergonomic design, Ecco is all about all-day comfort. Their shoes use innovative technology and fluid-form construction to create footwear that moves naturally with your foot. The styles are simple, clean, and incredibly functional.
Priced from $150 to $250, Ecco offers a comfort-first philosophy. If you appreciate the polished look of classic shoes but prioritize well-being and practicality above all else, Ecco is an unbeatable alternative.
Shop now at us.ecco.com
Jo Ghost is an Italian brand for the man who isn't afraid to stand out. Known for its artful designs, use of unique leathers, and eye-catching details like burnishing and weaving, their shoes are conversation starters. They mix classic silhouettes with a bold, artistic flair.
You can expect to find their handcrafted shoes in the $300-$600 range. While Stacy Adams is rooted in American tradition, Jo Ghost brings a rock-and-roll sensibility combined with Italian craftsmanship, perfect for elevating a creative wardrobe.
Shop now at lanecrawford.com
Another New England classic, Sebago is famous for its durable boat shoes (the Docksides) and beefroll penny loafers. Their aesthetic is rugged yet refined, perfectly capturing the spirit of classic American style. The construction is solid, built for comfort and longevity.
Ranging from $80 to $150, Sebago is an excellent value. Similar to Sperry, it offers a more casual-prep alternative to Stacy Adams' focus on dress shoes. It's the ideal brand for stylish loafers you can live in all weekend.
Shop now at www.sebago.com
At Apart Style, we're obsessed with curating the best in fashion, beauty, and jewelry to help you discover new brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, style, and uniqueness. When you make a purchase through our links, Apart Style may earn a commission - which helps support our small team, and allows us to continue bringing you the best in online style brands.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our full brand directory or check out our curated brand guides to find your new favorite thing.
