If your closet is full of perfectly tailored blazers, crisp button-downs, and classic shift dresses, you probably already love J McLaughlin. The brand has mastered the art of polished, timeless American style, offering preppy-chic pieces that feel both modern and sophisticated without ever trying too hard.
But when you're looking to expand your wardrobe with that same easy elegance, it helps to have a few other names on your radar. For those who love J McLaughlin's blend of quality, fit, and classic design, here are 19 similar brands worth checking out.
Talbots is a master of updated American classics, offering timeless styles from smart cardigans to perfectly tailored trousers and feminine blouses. Everything is designed with quality fabrics and flattering fits in mind, making it a go-to for women seeking polished, versatile pieces for work and weekend alike. If J McLaughlin masters modern prep, Talbots leans into a more traditional, vintage-inspired take on the same aesthetic.
Shop now at www.talbots.com
For a brighter, more playful take on preppy style, look no further than Lilly Pulitzer. This iconic resort wear brand is famous for its vibrant floral and novelty prints, splashed across everything from its signature shift dresses to swimwear and accessories. While J McLaughlin sticks to more subdued, classic palettes, Lilly Pulitzer is an explosion of confident color - perfect for vacations, sunny days, and anyone who isn't afraid to make a statement.
Shop now at www.lillypulitzer.com
As a cornerstone of American style, Brooks Brothers delivers high-quality, impeccably tailored clothing. The brand is known for perfecting wardrobe staples like non-iron dress shirts, classic blazers, and chinos for both men and women. If J McLaughlin offers a modern, lifestyle-focused version of prep, Brooks Brothers embodies its more formal, business-ready counterpart, making it an excellent source for polished essentials rooted in heritage.
Shop now at www.brooksbrothers.com
Founded on Martha's Vineyard, Vineyard Vines captures the feeling of a permanent vacation with its laid-back, coastal preppy aesthetic. Famous for its pink whale logo, the brand sells everything you need for a weekend by the water, from casual polo shirts and Shep Shirts to printed swim trunks. While J McLaughlin's look is more structured and refined, Vineyard Vines is a perfect alternative for relaxed, fun, and effortless off-duty style.
Shop now at www.vineyardvines.com
No list of preppy brands is complete without Ralph Lauren, the designer who arguably defined the entire aesthetic for a global audience. From the iconic polo shirt to luxurious cable-knit sweaters and tailored sportswear, the brand represents timeless American elegance. Ralph Lauren often carries a higher price point and a more aspirational, cinematic quality than J McLaughlin, but both brands share a deep commitment to classic, sophisticated style.
Shop now at www.ralphlauren.com
J. Crew is the go-to for preppy style with a modern, trend-aware twist. The brand excels at making the classics feel fresh, whether it's through a playfully printed blouse, perfectly cut chinos in a new seasonal color, or collaborations with other cool brands. Like J McLaughlin, it builds wardrobes on a foundation of quality staples, but J. Crew isn't afraid to experiment with brighter colors and bolder patterns, making it feel effortlessly current.
Shop now at www.jcrew.com
Embodying a relaxed coastal lifestyle, Southern Tide offers comfortable and stylish clothing designed for outdoor adventures and casual days. The collection is built on great-fitting polos, shorts, and performance knitwear in classic, easy-to-wear designs. Where J McLaughlin provides smart, polished pieces, Southern Tide brings a laid-back, Southern charm that's perfect for weekend getaways and effortless everyday looks.
Shop now at www.southerntide.com
L.L.Bean defined the rugged, outdoor side of preppy style. The brand is built on durability and comfort, famous for its Bean Boots, quality flannels, cozy fleece, and other outdoor essentials. While J McLaughlin is polished and town-ready, L.L.Bean is perfect for those who lean into the practical, outdoorsy elements of the preppy aesthetic, offering timeless pieces that are made to last a lifetime.
Shop now at www.llbean.com
While primarily a footwear brand, Sperry is essential to completing any classic preppy look. Best known for inventing the boat shoe, Sperry creates nautical-inspired footwear and accessories that instantly signal classic seaside style. It’s the perfect complement to a J McLaughlin outfit, grounding a polished look with a touch of authentic, coastal charm from the feet up.
Shop now at www.sperry.com
Pendleton specializes in high-quality wool pieces that bring a touch of rugged, American heritage to preppy style. Its iconic patterned blankets, flannel shirts, and warm outerwear are perfect for layering during cooler months. Contrasted with J McLaughlin’s sleek East Coast polish, Pendleton offers a more heritage-driven, Western-prep vibe that is centered on craftsmanship, warmth, and durability.
Shop now at www.pendleton-usa.com
Madewell masterfully blends casual classics with a preppy twist, making it a favorite for a slightly younger crowd. Known primarily for its fantastic denim, the brand also offers effortless button-down shirts, simple dresses, and leather totes that feel both timeless and cool. While J McLaughlin's look is more traditionally put-together, Madewell excels at an easygoing, laid-back version of polished style.
Shop now at www.madewell.com
Banana Republic strikes a perfect balance between versatile professional wear and modern sophistication. Its collection is centered on clean, high-quality pieces, including tailored suits, silk blouses, and timeless trenches that make for a strong office-ready wardrobe. Both brands value timelessness, but Banana Republic often uses a more minimalist, contemporary lens than J McLaughlin's classic, print- and texture-forward aesthetic.
Shop now at bananarepublic.gap.com
Everlane is all about minimalist design, transparent pricing, and ethical manufacturing. The brand creates high-quality basics like cashmere sweaters, tailored trousers, silk blouses, and loafers that form the backbone of a sophisticated wardrobe. Its clean, sleek aesthetic appeals to fans of preppy style who are looking for a more modern, less-is-more approach, standing in contrast to J McLaughlin's love for vibrant pattern and color.
Shop now at www.everlane.com
Cutter & Buck offers high-performance sportswear with a classic preppy sensibility. The brand specializes in golf-course-ready gear like brightly colored polo shirts, technical quarter-zips, and tailored chinos designed for an active lifestyle. While J McLaughlin’s pieces are geared more toward everyday polished wear, Cutter & Buck fills the gap for functional activewear that maintains a sharp, classic aesthetic.
Shop now at www.cutterbuck.com
At Apart Style, we're obsessed with curating the best in fashion, beauty, and jewelry to help you discover new brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, style, and uniqueness. When you make a purchase through our links, Apart Style may earn a commission - which helps support our small team, and allows us to continue bringing you the best in online style brands.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our full brand directory or check out our curated brand guides to find your new favorite thing.
