If you love classic, American collegiate style, chances are you already have J. Press on your radar. The brand is a true icon of Ivy League fashion, known for its impeccably tailored sport coats, crisp button-down shirts, and timeless pieces that define the preppy aesthetic. It’s that polished, heritage-inspired look that always feels right.
For those looking to build out a wardrobe with that same traditional charm, we’ve found some amazing alternatives. From legendary heritage brands to more modern interpretations of preppy style, here are 18 brands like J. Press perfect for anyone who appreciates a classic look.
As another titan of American menswear, Brooks Brothers is often mentioned in the same breath as J. Press, and for good reason. They are masters of the classic, preppy look, offering everything from tailored blazers and non-iron dress shirts to perfectly cut chinos. The aesthetic is pure Ivy League, focusing on quality fabrics and timeless designs.
While J. Press has a slightly more conservative, academic feel, Brooks Brothers often feels a bit more mainstream and has a broader collection of formalwear. With prices starting around $50 for shirts and increasing for suiting, it’s a similar investment in quality. It's a must-shop for anyone building a traditional, polished wardrobe.
Shop now at brooksbrothers.com
Polo Ralph Lauren practically defines the modern preppy lifestyle. Known for its iconic polo shirts, cable-knit sweaters, and tailored blazers, the brand provides an aspirational, sophisticated take on collegiate style. The silhouette remains classic, but there’s an added layer of effortless luxury that feels both timeless and current.
Compared to J. Press, Ralph Lauren leans more into lifestyle branding with its signature pony logo. Prices are generally accessible, from around $50 for tees to several hundred for outerwear, offering a slightly more fashion-forward spin on Ivy League staples.
Shop now at ralphlauren.com
Famous for its sporty roots and iconic crocodile logo, Lacoste offers a more casual, tennis-inspired version of preppy fashion. Their claim to fame is the pique polo shirt, a staple that blends athletic comfort with a refined, clean look. The brand’s vibe is relaxed yet put-together, perfect for weekend brunch or a casual day out.
If you find J. Press a bit too formal, Lacoste is a great alternative for everyday wear. With polos and tees typically in the $70-$150 range, it nails that sporty-sophisticated sweet spot without sacrificing the polished, collegiate feel.
Shop now at lacoste.com
J.Crew is the master of modern preppy essentials. The brand excels at creating wardrobe workhorses like slim-fit button-downs, cozy cable-knit sweaters, classic chinos, and smartly tailored blazers that feel both timeless and contemporary. It takes the Ivy league rulebook and updates it for a new generation.
While J. Press is rooted in tradition, J.Crew offers more modern fits and a brighter color palette, making it a highly approachable and versatile option. With tops starting around $30 and blazers under $250, it offers fantastic style and value for today's prepster.
Shop now at jcrew.com
For those looking to invest in the luxury side of Ivy League style, Paul Stuart is the answer. This high-end American brand is known for its incredible tailoring, exceptional fabrics, and a sophisticated aesthetic that blends classic prep with European elegance. Think bespoke-quality suits, lush cashmere sweaters, and impeccably constructed outerwear.
Positioned at a luxury price point (shirts start around $300), Paul Stuart is a definite step up from J. Press. It’s for the discerning customer who wants the ultimate in refined, classic style with unparalleled craftsmanship.
Shop now at paulstuart.com
Famous for its iconic boat shoes, Sperry embodies a nautically-inspired preppy look. Beyond footwear, the brand offers a small but solid collection of casual apparel like polos, classic chinos, and lightweight jackets perfect for a laid-back, coastal vibe. The style is classic, comfortable, and effortlessly collegiate.
Sperry leans much more casual than the tailored offerings of J. Press, making it an ideal choice for weekend getaways and relaxed summer days. With prices generally between $40-$100 for apparel, it's an accessible way to add a touch of seaworthy prep to your closet.
Shop now at sperry.com
Vineyard Vines is all about having fun with preppy fashion. Instantly recognizable by its cheerful whale logo and vibrant color palette, the brand serves up a playful, relaxed take on Ivy League style. From polos in bright pastels to chinos and casual button-downs, their pieces evoke a sense of carefree coastal living.
If J. Press represents the studious side of campus life, Vineyard Vines is the endless summer vacation. It's less formal and more youthful, offering approachable price points perfect for anyone seeking a more laid-back but still classic preppy look.
Shop now at vineyardvines.com
Orvis blends the worlds of outdoor gear and classic American prep. Known for its durable, high-quality pieces, the brand offers staples like rugged polo shirts, sturdy chinos, and functional outerwear that have a distinct heritage feel. It's the kind of clothing made to be worn and loved for years.
Compared to J. Press’s polished aesthetic, Orvis is more rooted in outdoor and field wear, celebrating a refined but practical style. It’s perfect for the person who wants timeless, well-made staples that work just as well in the country as they do on campus.
Shop now at orvis.com
GANT combines American East Coast prep with a touch of European sophistication. Originally famous for its crisp button-down shirts, the brand now offers a full range of collegiate-inspired essentials, including smart polos, sweaters, and casual blazers. The fits are often a bit slimmer and more modern than traditional American cuts.
Like J. Press, GANT has deep Ivy League roots, but its execution is more relaxed and fashion-forward. It strikes a great balance between classic style and contemporary comfort, with pieces generally ranging from $50 to $150.
Shop now at gant.com
For Ivy League style on a budget, the Brooks Brothers Factory Outlet is an unbeatable resource. You can find many of the brand's classic staples - dress shirts, chinos, sweaters, and blazers - at prices often 30-50% lower than retail. The core aesthetic remains traditional American prep, delivering timeless quality for less.
The outlet offers a more accessible entry point to the preppy world of Brooks Brothers, making it a smart alternative for shoppers who love the J. Press look but are looking for a better deal without sacrificing iconic style.
Shop now at brooksbrothers.com/outlet
Want that signature Ralph Lauren look without the full retail price? Their outlet store is your best bet. It’s filled with the preppy, collegiate pieces the brand is famous for - like polo shirts, oxford button-downs, and casual chinos - but at a much more accessible price point.
The outlet makes it easy to stock up on stylish, well-made staples that share the same traditional DNA as J. Press. It's perfect for finding those key Ivy League essentials without breaking the bank.
Shop now at ralphlauren.com/outlet
Filson is the rugged, outdoorsy cousin to J. Press. The brand specializes in incredibly durable, heritage-inspired clothing built to withstand the elements, like waxed Tin Cloth jackets and sturdy twill pants. While more utilitarian, its commitment to quality materials and timeless American craftsmanship resonates with the Ivy League ethos.
If you love the heritage behind J. Press but lean towards a more practical, rugged aesthetic, Filson is a fantastic choice. The pieces are an investment - quality jackets can run over $400 - but they are designed to last a lifetime.
Shop now at filson.com
Tucker Blair is a boutique brand that puts a fresh twist on preppy classics, particularly with its famous needlepoint belts, hats, and accessories. Their unique designs and attention to detail add a touch of personality and cleverness to a traditional Ivy League wardrobe. They also offer classic button-downs and ties with a unique flair.
While J. Press focuses on timeless staples, Tucker Blair is where you go for the finishing touches that stand out. With prices between $50 and $150, it's perfect for adding a bit of bespoke-feeling character to polished outfits.
Shop now at tuckerblair.com
Saturdays NYC reinterprets Ivy League style through a cool, minimalist lens. The brand offers elevated basics like relaxed-fit shirts, streamlined sweaters, and tailored chinos with a sleek, contemporary feel. Their aesthetic is understated, clean, and rooted in surf and skate culture, resulting in preppy clothes with a downtown edge.
If you admire the quality of J. Press but want something less traditional and more modern, Saturdays NYC is a great match. Priced typically from $50 to $200, it’s a brilliant source for high-quality staples that feel relevant right now.
Shop now at saturdaysnyc.com
A British heritage brand best known for its iconic waxed jackets, Barbour embodies a rugged, countrified version of preppy style. Their outerwear is legendary, but you'll also find classic button-down shirts, chunky knits, and quilted vests that are perfect for layering.
Barbour offers an outdoorsy, practical take on classic fashion that complements the J. Press aesthetic, especially for fall and winter. While a jacket is an investment piece starting around $250, its timeless durability makes it a worthy addition to any Ivy-inspired wardrobe.
Shop now at barbour.com
L.L.Bean is a master of durable, practical, and classic American outdoor wear. From their iconic Bean Boots to flannel shirts, warm parkas, and perfect chinos, their pieces are designed for both comfort and functionality. The brand's focus on quality and timeless design gives it a natural place within the Ivy League aesthetic.
As a more casual and rugged alternative to J. Press, L.L.Bean is ideal for everyday wear and outdoor adventures. With accessible prices, it's the perfect source for reliable, comfortable staples that will last a lifetime.
Shop now at llbean.com
Renowned for its high-quality wool blankets, outerwear, and shirting, Pendleton brings an artisanal, American heritage vibe to the table. Its signature Native American-inspired patterns add a unique, textural element to the classic prep look. The brand excels at making cozy, timeless pieces rich with history and craftsmanship.
Pendleton’s rugged, vintage-inspired aesthetic offers a nice contrast to J. Press’s clean tailored style. It's perfect for anyone wanting to add artistic beauty to their wardrobe, with beautifully crafted sweaters and jackets ranging from $50 to $300.
Shop now at pendleton-usa.com
At Apart Style, we're obsessed with curating the best in fashion, beauty, and jewelry to help you discover new brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, style, and uniqueness. When you make a purchase through our links, Apart Style may earn a commission - which helps support our small team, and allows us to continue bringing you the best in online style brands.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our full brand directory or check out our curated brand guides to find your new favorite thing.
