Hermès P18 vs. P22: Which size is right for you?

The Hermès Picotin 18 and the Picotin 22 share the same effortlessly chic, slouchy bucket bag design, but their key difference is in size and practicality. The Picotin 18 is a compact, minimalist bag for essentials only, ideal for quick outings or evening events, while the Picotin 22 offers more generous space, making it a more versatile and practical choice for daily use.

Here’s everything you need to know to choose the right Hermès Picotin size for your lifestyle.

Hermès Picotin 18

The Picotin 18 (P18) is the smaller of the two popular sizes, embodying the minimalist, 'mini-bag' trend while retaining a timeless appeal. Its compact, structured-yet-slouchy design makes it an elegant choice for carrying just the essentials, perfect for those who prefer to travel light and appreciate understated French luxury.

• What it is: A small, open-top bucket bag crafted from supple Togo leather, designed for hand or forearm carry.
• Key features: Measures 7" H x 9" W x 4" D (17.8 x 22.9 x 10.2 cm), with a single unlined main compartment and comfortable rolled leather handles.
• Price: Approximately $3,200 USD
• Materials/Construction: Made from Hermès' iconic Togo leather, a grainy and highly durable calfskin that is resistant to scratches and maintains its shape well over time.
• Pros: Lightweight and incredibly chic size. Perfect for evenings, events, or quick errands. Holds its value exceptionally well. Its small footprint forces you to carry only what you need.
• Cons: Limited capacity - can only fit essentials like a phone, cardholder, keys, and lipstick. Open-top design offers less security. No internal pockets for organization.

This size is perfect for the minimalist who values form and elegance, needing a sophisticated bag just for the bare necessities.

Shop this product: hermes.com/us/en/product/picotin-18-handbag-SS19/

Hermès Picotin 22

The Picotin 22 (P22) offers a noticeable increase in space and practicality without sacrificing the graceful design of the Picotin family. It serves as a true everyday bag, accommodating more than just the basics, making it a reliable and stylish companion for daily errands, casual workdays, and everything in between.

• What it is: A medium-sized, lightweight open-top bucket bag that balances practicality with the signature Hermès elegance.
• Key features: Measures 8.7" H x 9.4" W x 4.7" D (22.1 x 23.9 x 12 cm), featuring the same unlined interior and comfortable rolled handles as its smaller sibling.
• Price: Approximately $3,500 USD
• Materials/Construction: Handcrafted in France from durable and scratch-resistant Togo calfskin leather with a rich, grainy texture.
• Pros: More versatile due to its larger capacity. Can hold daily essentials plus items like a small water bottle, sunglasses case, or even a small book. Excellent for daily use. Still lightweight and easy to carry.
• Cons: Like the P18, the open top can be a security concern for some. The lack of internal pockets can lead to a disorganized interior without a bag organizer.

Ideal for those who need a versatile, functional daily driver that offers a touch of understated luxury without being bulky.

Shop this product: hermes.com/us/en/product/picotin-22-handbag-SS19/

Hermès Picotin 18 vs. Hermès Picotin 22 Comparison

Size & Capacity

The most significant difference lies here. The Picotin 18 is distinctly a small bag, it will comfortably hold your smartphone, a compact wallet or cardholder, keys, and a lip balm. It’s perfect for the occasions when you don't want to be weighed down.

The Picotin 22, while not a large tote, offers substantially more room. In addition to the basics, it can accommodate a sunglasses case, a small pouch for cosmetics, a compact e-reader or book, and perhaps a small snack or reusable water bottle. This extra capacity is what transitions it from a specialty "going out" bag to a viable everyday bag.

Price & Value

With only about a $300 USD difference at retail, price is not a major differentiating factor. Both Picotins are considered excellent investments in the luxury world. They hold their value extremely well on the resale market and, depending on the color and condition, can often sell for more than their original retail price. The choice, therefore, comes down to functionality rather than cost-benefit analysis.

Design & Usability

Both models share the exact same aesthetic: an unlined interior, a simple leather "lock" strap, sturdy rolled handles, and four protective feet on the base. Their usability, however, is shaped by their size. The P18 feels more delicate and is typically carried in hand or in the crook of the elbow as a chic accessory.

The P22 is used in the same manner but feels more substantial. Its slightly larger size makes it a comfortable forearm-carry tote that works as your primary bag for the day. Neither is designed to be a shoulder bag, as the handle drop is too short.

Versatility

The Picotin 22 is the clear winner in terms of versatility. Its ability to hold more items makes it suitable for a wider range of activities, from running errands to a casual day at the office to weekend brunch. It easily functions as an all-in-one daily bag.

The Picotin 18 is more of a specialist. It shines during events, dinners, or any situation where a large bag would be cumbersome. It’s the perfect companion when all you need are your keys, cards, and phone and want to look polished and unencumbered.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both bags are beautiful examples of Hermès craftsmanship, but they serve different needs and lifestyles.

Choose the Picotin 18 if:

• You are a minimalist and only carry your absolute essentials.
• You want a small, lightweight bag for evening use, events, or quick trips.
• You love the 'mini bag' aesthetic and prefer smaller proportions.
• You already have a larger daily bag and need something for special, lighter occasions.

Choose the Picotin 22 if:

• You need a practical, functional bag for everyday use.
• You want to carry more than just your phone, keys, and wallet.
• You value versatility and want a bag that can transition from errands to lunch.
• This will be your primary luxury bag and you need it to be as useful as possible.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the main difference between the Picotin 18 and 22?

The primary difference is size and carrying capacity. The P18 is a mini bag for essentials, while the P22 is a medium-sized bag suitable for everyday use with its more generous interior.

Can the Picotin 18 fit a phone?

Yes, the Picotin 18 can comfortably fit all modern smartphones, along with a small cardholder, keys, and a few small cosmetic items.

Can you wear the Hermès Picotin on your shoulder?

No, neither size is designed to be a shoulder bag. The handle drop is short, making them suitable only for hand-carry or carrying in the crook of your arm.

Is the Hermès Picotin a good investment?

Yes, Picotins are an excellent investment. They are highly sought after and tend to hold or even increase their value over time on the secondary market, especially in popular, neutral, or seasonal colors.

What is Togo leather?

Togo is a popular type of calfskin leather used by Hermès. It is known for its visible grain, soft feel, and excellent resistance to scratching and wear, making it perfect for an everyday bag.

Which Picotin size is more popular?

Popularity fluctuates with trends. The P18 has been very popular due to the 'mini-bag' trend, while the P22 remains a functional classic for those seeking a practical, daily luxury bag.

Does the Picotin come with a lock?

The Picotin comes with a small padlock and a set of keys, which can be used to secure the leather strap that weaves through the top openings of the bag. However, many owners wear it open for easier access.

Are there any pockets inside the Picotin?

No, the Picotin has a completely unlined and open interior with no pockets. Many users purchase third-party bag organizers to add structure and compartmentalization.