Everlane Cheeky Straight vs. 90s Cheeky Straight: Which one is better?
The Everlane 90s Cheeky Straight and the original Everlane Cheeky Straight Jean both offer a versatile, straight-leg silhouette, but they serve two very different style preferences. The 90s Cheeky has a much higher rise and a distinctly relaxed, vintage-inspired fit through the hip and thigh, creating a laid-back 90s look. In contrast, the original Cheeky Straight offers a more modern, streamlined fit that's slimmer through the hip and thigh for a cleaner, more contemporary appearance.
Here’s everything you need to know to decide which of these Everlane jeans belongs in your wardrobe.
Everlane ‘90s Cheeky Straight Jean
The ‘90s Cheeky Straight Jean is a nod to the iconic denim styles of the 1990s, built with a flattering high rise and an easier, more relaxed fit. Made from premium, non-stretch Japanese denim, this style is designed to hold you in at the waist while providing comfortable room through the hip and thigh, finished with a classic straight leg that channels a vintage aesthetic.
- What it is: A '90s-inspired jean featuring a high rise, a relaxed fit through the hip and thigh, and a straight leg.
- Key features: High-rise waist, straight-leg cut from hip to ankle, relaxed vintage silhouette, made from sustainable materials.
- Price: Around $98.
- Materials/Construction: Crafted from a slightly thicker, vintage-inspired sustainable denim that has a softer feel, often using organic cotton and eco-friendly dyes.
- Sizing/Fit: Fits true to size for a relaxed look. Its forgiving cut offers comfortable coverage and is flattering on many body types who enjoy a looser silhouette.
- Pros: A comfortable, relaxed fit that doesn't feel restrictive. The high rise is flattering and provides great coverage. Channels a popular vintage, retro aesthetic. Made with sustainable, high-quality materials.
- Cons: The relaxed fit might feel too casual or baggy for those who prefer a more tailored look. Thicker denim may feel heavy in warmer weather.
This jean is ideal for those who love a laid-back, retro-inspired look and prioritize comfort and a forgiving fit without sacrificing style.
Shop this product: everlane.com/products/90s-cheeky-straight-jeans
Everlane Cheeky Straight Jean
The original Cheeky Straight Jean is Everlane's modern take on the classic straight-leg silhouette, designed with a universally flattering high rise and a slim-straight fit. Engineered for a figure-hugging effect, it features a raised back hook seam that lifts and sculpts, plus a cut that's more fitted through the hip and thigh before tapering into a classic straight leg. It feels more polished and contemporary than its '90s counterpart.
- What it is: A modern high-rise straight-leg jean with a contoured fit that lifts and sculpts.
- Key features: Slim-straight fit, subtle taper, modern clean aesthetic, and "Happy Pockets" that are set high and close for a flattering rear view.
- Price: $68 – $128, depending on the specific wash and fabric.
- Materials/Construction: Made from sustainable denim with a slightly more structured feel than the 90s version, sometimes with a touch of stretch for comfort.
- Sizing/Fit: Fits true to size for a sleek, modern straight-leg look. The fit is intentionally closer through the hips and thighs compared to the '90s version.
- Pros: Versatile enough for both casual outings and smart-casual office settings. The modern, minimalist style pairs well with almost anything. Its tailored fit through the hips offers a more sculpting feel. Great value for the quality.
- Cons: A more fitted silhouette isn’t as forgiving as the 90s relaxed cut. Price can vary significantly between different washes.
Perfect for anyone seeking a versatile, modern, and sleek straight-leg jean that can easily be dressed up or down.
Shop this product: everlane.com/products/womens-cheeky-straight-jean-bone
Everlane 90s Cheeky Straight vs. Cheeky Straight Comparison
Fit & Style Aesthetic
The most significant difference lies here. The 90s Cheeky Straight is all about nostalgia and ease. It has an extra-high rise (often 11" or more) and is cut with more room through the hips and thighs, resulting in a relaxed, straight silhouette that feels borrowed from the 90s. This creates a casual, effortless vibe.
The original Cheeky Straight, on the other hand, is designed for a modern, sleek look. While still a high rise, its fit is much closer to the body around the hips and thighs. The goal isn't baggy comfort, but rather a clean, elongating line that hugs your curves before falling into a perfect straight leg. It feels more polished and structured.
Materials & Feel
Both styles use high-quality, sustainable denim, aligning with Everlane’s commitment to ethical production. The denim on the 90s Cheeky often feels slightly thicker and more rigid initially to mimic authentic vintage jeans, though it softens beautifully with wear. It's meant to feel like a timeless, durable workhorse jean.
The classic Cheeky Straight comes in various fabrications, some with a small amount of stretch for added comfort and movement. The material generally feels a bit more refined and less vintage, with a focus on delivering a smooth, structured silhouette right away. Both denim styles are designed for longevity and are covered by Everlane’s one-year denim guarantee.
Price & Value
Both jeans are competitively priced for premium sustainable denim. The 90s Cheeky Straight typically sits at a consistent price point around $98. The original Cheeky Straight has a broader price range, usually from $68 to $128, varying based on the fabric, wash, and whether it’s a sale item.
Neither is a "better" value, they simply serve different looks. Given the quality, sustainable materials, and ethical manufacturing, both options offer excellent value in the premium denim market. Your choice should come down to which fit and style you'll wear more often.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both jeans are great, but they shine for different people and occasions.
Choose the 90s Cheeky Straight if:
- You love a retro, vintage-inspired aesthetic.
- You prioritize a comfortable, relaxed, and easygoing fit.
- You want a jean that's more forgiving through the hips and thighs.
- Your style leans more casual and you want a jean with more personality.
Choose the original Cheeky Straight if:
- You prefer a sleek, modern, and polished silhouette.
- You want a versatile jean that can easily transition from weekend to a casual office.
- You like your jeans to be more fitted and sculpted around the hips and rear.
- You favor a timeless, minimalist look over trend-focused pieces.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the main difference between the 90s Cheeky and the regular Cheeky Straight Jean?
The main difference is the fit and silhouette. The 90s Cheeky is a relaxed, vintage-inspired jean with a high-rise and a looser cut through the hip and thigh. The regular Cheeky Straight Jean is a modern, sleek jean that is more fitted through the hip and thigh for a cleaner, more sculpted look.
Do Cheeky jeans run true to size?
Yes, both styles generally run true to size, but their fit is different by design. Order your usual size in the 90s Cheeky Straight for its intended relaxed look. The classic Cheeky Straight will have a slimmer fit in your normal size.
Which style is more comfortable?
Comfort is subjective, but if you define it as having more room and less restriction, the 90s Cheeky Straight is more comfortable due to its relaxed cut. The original Cheeky Straight is still very wearable, and versions with added stretch can be equally comfortable while providing a more held-in feel.
Which version is better for curvier body types?
The 90s Cheeky Straight's relaxed fit through the hip and thigh can be more forgiving and comfortable for curvier body types, often eliminating worries about tightness in those areas.
Are Everlane jeans sustainable?
Yes, Everlane is committed to sustainability. Their denim is made in LEED-certified facilities that recycle water, use renewable energy, and utilize organic cotton, recycled fibers, and eco-friendly dyes to reduce their environmental impact.
Do vintage Everlane jeans stretch out?
The brand's non-stretch denim is designed to hold its shape well. While denim will always break in and mold to your body over time, neither of these styles should stretch out excessively with proper care. Wash them cold and hang them to dry to preserve their fit.
What is Everlane's return policy?
Everlane generally offers a 30-day return window for unworn items with tags attached. They often provide credits or refunds, making the shopping experience low-risk.
Which is more timeless: the 90s Cheeky or regular Cheeky?
Both are based on timeless straight-leg silhouettes. However, the original Cheeky Straight has a more classic, modern simplicity that isn't tied to a specific decade. The 90s Cheeky leans into a distinct retro trend which, while currently very popular, has a more specific aesthetic.