If your closet is a happy collection of chic stripes, timeless tunics, and classic pieces that feel perfect for a weekend by the coast, you're likely a big fan of Tuckernuck. The brand has absolutely nailed that effortless preppy style that’s both polished and perfectly wearable.
For those looking to expand their collection of coastal-inspired classics, you’re in the right place. We've gathered 19 other brands that deliver a similar blend of preppy charm and modern style for you to add to your rotation.
An icon in the world of American prep, J.Crew is the go-to for quality, polished staples. The brand is known for its classic button-downs, tailored blazers, cashmere sweaters, and playful-yet-preppy prints. With prices sitting slightly more affordably than Tuckernuck, especially during one of their frequent sales, it’s a great place to stock up on wardrobe essentials.
While Tuckernuck often feels like a curated boutique of preppy finds, J.Crew is the foundational source for those pieces. It’s a bit more versatile, easily shifting from office-ready looks to weekend casual, making it an essential stop for building a classic, preppy wardrobe. Shop now at www.jcrew.com
If you love Tuckernuck's preppy bones but crave a bit more sizzle, Lilly Pulitzer is your brand. Famous for its unapologetically bright, tropical prints and cheerful resort wear, Lilly is all about celebrating sunny days. You'll find a sea of vibrant shift dresses, swimsuits, and accessories perfect for vacation or a summer cocktail party.
Think of Lilly as Tuckernuck's Palm Beach-bound best friend. The underlying preppy formula is the same, but the volume is turned way up with bold patterns and electric colors. Pricing is similar, ranging from about $50 to $300 for statement pieces that are designed to be noticed. Shop now at www.lillypulitzer.com
Ralph Lauren is the gold standard of classic American style, epitomizing the polished, heritage-driven feel that preppy fashion is built on. While it leans towards a more luxurious price point - with polos starting around $100 and dresses reaching $500+ - it delivers timeless quality and quintessential preppy silhouettes, from crisp Oxford shirts to elegant cable-knit sweaters.
Compared to Tuckernuck’s more modern boutique curation, Ralph Lauren is pure, undistilled heritage. It offers a more formal, elevated take on the coastal-preppy aesthetic, making it an ideal choice for investment pieces that will never go out of style. Shop now at www.ralphlauren.com
Born from a love for the coastal lifestyle, Southern Tide offers a laid-back, Southern take on preppy fashion. It’s known for high-quality polos, shorts, and casual dresses that are effortlessly stylish and built for comfort, whether you’re on the water or at a tailgate. Prices are generally in the $40 to $150 range.
Like Tuckernuck, the brand is deeply rooted in a coastal aesthetic, but with a sportier, more relaxed vibe. Southern Tide is less about Nantucket chic and more centered on Southern charm and everyday comfort, making it a great pick for casual, preppy staples. Shop now at www.southerntide.com
With its iconic smiling whale logo, Vineyard Vines is synonymous with the fun, youthful side of East Coast prep. The brand offers a wide range of colorful polos, shep shirts, printed shorts, and dresses that embody a carefree, weekend state of mind. Price points typically fall between $40 and $150.
While both brands celebrate coastal living, Vineyard Vines is Tuckernuck's more playful younger sibling. It champions vibrant colors and whimsical branding, focusing on relaxed staples for casual Fridays, boating trips, and beach bonfires. Shop now at www.vineyardvines.com
J.McLaughlin excels at creating classic American sportswear with a modern, colorful twist. Their collections are full of chic dresses, well-cut pants, and stylish tops, often featuring bold geometric or paisley prints in unique color combinations. With items mainly in the $50 to $200 range, it hits a similar sweet spot as Tuckernuck.
If you love Tuckernuck's curated feel, you'll appreciate J.McLaughlin's distinctive point of view. It’s for the woman who loves preppy silhouettes but isn't afraid of a standout pattern. The brand offers a pop of personality while keeping things polished and sophisticated. Shop now at www.jmclaughlin.com
As one of America's oldest clothing retailers, Brooks Brothers is the foundation of traditional preppy style. The brand is the authority on classics like non-iron button-down shirts, sharp blazers, and chinos. Prices for core items generally sit between $50 and $300.
Where Tuckernuck curates a trendy, boutique version of prep, Brooks Brothers offers the timeless, original formula. The vibe is more heritage and can lean more professional or formal, making it the perfect source for building out the more classic, "business casual" side of your preppy wardrobe. Shop now at www.brooksbrothers.com
Gant fuses American East Coast prep with a touch of European sophistication. It started as a shirtmaker and continues to be known for its crisp, impeccable button-downs, along with classic chinos, pique polos, and sweaters. The brand offers a clean, streamlined aesthetic at a price point of around $60 to $200.
Gant is a slightly more minimalist and modern alternative to Tuckernuck. Its take on preppy is less about bold prints and more about sharp silhouettes, excellent tailoring, and understated colors. It's perfect if you're looking for clean lines and effortless, everyday polish. Shop now at gant.com
For a dose of elevated, bohemian-prep, look no further than Tory Burch. The brand is famous for its iconic Reva flats, chic tunics, and luxe accessories that often feature its signature double-T logo. Tory Burch operates at a higher, designer price point but is the epitome of polished, sophisticated style.
Think of Tory Burch as the luxury version of the Tuckernuck aesthetic. It takes the same preppy, travel-inspired DNA - like printed caftans and crisp blouses - and elevates it with high-end fabrics and impeccable design. It’s a splurge-worthy alternative for special pieces. Shop now at www.toryburch.com
Founded by Reese Witherspoon, Draper James is a love letter to Southern charm and timeless style. The brand offers a delightful collection of dresses in classic silhouettes like florals and gingham, alongside sweet cardigans and accessories. It focuses on pretty, feminine pieces that feel both sophisticated and welcoming.
If you enjoy the upbeat, polished nature of Tuckernuck's selection, Draper James dials up the Southern hospitality. It's unapologetically feminine and classic, making it the perfect destination for pretty daytime dresses and polished ensembles for everything from brunch to a garden party. Shop now at draperjames.com
Tommy Hilfiger is a pillar of American preppy style, mastering the art of classic, cool, and collegiate-inspired fashion. Renowned for its iconic red, white, and blue color palette, the brand delivers timeless polos, chino shorts, striped sweaters, and dresses with a distinctive, sporty edge.
Tommy offers a vibe that's often a bit more casual and logo-forward than Tuckernuck, harkening back to its classic '90s Americana roots. It's a fantastic brand for foundational preppy basics that feel both nostalgic and completely current. Shop now at usa.tommy.com
This British brand brings a cheerful, fun-loving energy to preppy dressing. Boden is beloved for its vibrant colors, quirky prints, and quality craftsmanship on everyday classics like Breton striped tops, flattering midi dresses, and practical-yet-stylish swimwear. The price is comparable to Tuckernuck, with a focus on family-friendly options.
If you like Tuckernuck's curated patterns and bright colors, you'll love Boden's playful British take. The vibe is a little less coastal and a little more countryside whimsy, but the commitment to well-made, joy-sparking pieces is exactly the same. Shop now at www.bodenusa.com
Sail to Sable specializes in classic coastal womenswear with a contemporary twist. The brand is famous for its signature tunic dresses, often trimmed with chic tassels or ric-rac details, making them instant show-stoppers. Their collections are filled with effortless resort-ready dresses and stylish separates perfect for any seaside occasion.
This brand is perhaps one of the most direct style parallels to Tuckernuck. Both celebrate a polished, preppy, and feminine aesthetic. Sail to Sable leans a little more heavily into resort and special-occasion wear, perfect for finding that stunning dress for a summer wedding or vacation dinner. Shop now at www.sailtosable.com
Known primarily for its amazing denim, Madewell also offers a full range of chic, effortless basics that act as a perfect foundation for a preppy look. Think simple sweaters, perfect-fit tees, easy dresses, and timeless leather bags and shoes. The overall vibe is relaxed, contemporary, and cool, at a very accessible price point.
While Madewell isn't "preppy" in the traditional sense, it's where you go to get the modern building blocks for a preppy-inspired outfit. Pair their amazing jeans with a Tuckernuck striped top or one of their loafers with a classic dress, and you have that perfect blend of classic and cool. Shop now at www.madewell.com
Faherty is all about a relaxed, laid-back coastal vibe with a focus on supreme comfort and sustainable fabrics. The brand offers sun-faded hoodies, incredibly soft flannel shirts, and bohemian-inspired dresses that feel like you've owned them for years in the best way possible. Quality and sustainability are key, with prices reflecting that commitment.
If Tuckernuck represents the polished, Nantucket side of coastal style, Faherty is its casual, a bit-more-West-Coast alter ego. The styles are more relaxed and rustic, perfect for anyone who wants their preppy look to feel a little more lived-in and comfortable. Shop now at fahertybrand.com
A heritage outdoor brand based in Maine, L.L.Bean is the source for indestructible classics. Famous for their iconic Bean Boots, tote bags, and cozy flannels, the brand delivers practical, durable pieces that are inherently preppy. Pricing is very approachable, emphasizing value and longevity.
L.L.Bean provides the rugged, practical backbone to a preppy wardrobe. While Tuckernuck focuses on the fashionable side of the aesthetic, L.L.Bean delivers the functional weekend essentials you need for a trip to the mountains or a fall apple orchard. Shop now at www.llbean.com
Orvis blends country-sports functionality with classic preppy style. The brand specializes in high-quality apparel perfect for outdoor pursuits like fly-fishing and hiking, but their pieces - like quilted jackets, performance button-downs, and durable knitwear - are stylish enough for everyday wear.
Orvis is similar to Tuckernuck in its appeal to a classic, active lifestyle, but with a much stronger emphasis on rugged, outdoor performance. It’s the perfect place to shop for stylish yet functional pieces that seamlessly transition from a country walk to a casual pub lunch. Shop now at www.orvis.com
Pendleton is renowned for its high-quality wool blankets and shirts featuring vibrant, Native American-inspired patterns. The brand embodies a rustic, heritage Americana style. Their clothing collections include cozy sweaters, durable outerwear, and plaid shirts that have a timeless, outdoorsy feel.
While the aesthetic is more rustic "Western-prep" than East Coast coastal, Pendleton shares Tuckernuck’s commitment to quality and timeless design. It’s an ideal choice for anyone who loves a preppy look infused with a sense of cozy Americana history and craftsmanship. Shop now at www.pendleton-usa.com
Although not a clothing brand, Sea Bags is the perfect accessory-focused counterpart to Tuckernuck's style. They handcraft durable, endlessly charming totes, duffels, and wristlets from recycled sailcloth right in Maine. Each bag has a unique, nautical story and is designed for a life on the water.
If you love the entire Tuckernuck lifestyle, a Sea Bag is the perfect finishing touch. Their products share the same coastal, preppy DNA and are built on quality American craftsmanship. It's the ideal tote for beach days, farmers' market runs, or just carrying your daily essentials. Shop now at seabags.com
At Apart Style, we're obsessed with curating the best in fashion, beauty, and jewelry to help you discover new brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, style, and uniqueness. When you make a purchase through our links, Apart Style may earn a commission - which helps support our small team, and allows us to continue bringing you the best in online style brands.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our full brand directory or check out our curated brand guides to find your new favorite thing.
