If you're a fan of tailored shirts, perfect chinos, and that timeless American style, you're probably already familiar with Sid Mashburn. The brand has perfected a mix of preppy essentials and sophisticated staples that just work, making it a go-to for guys who want to look sharp without trying too hard.
But when you've got your core Mashburn pieces, it's always fun to discover other brands with a similar commitment to quality and classic style. Whether you're looking for something slightly more rugged, minimalist, or affordable, we've got you covered. Here are 19 brands that capture that same spirit of effortless menswear.
As one of the original American heritage brands, Brooks Brothers practically wrote the book on classic menswear. They offer everything from impeccably tailored suits to iconic dress shirts and preppy staples. While Sid Mashburn has a more modern, approachable vibe, Brooks Brothers leans toward a more traditional and formal aesthetic.
It's the perfect brand if you appreciate timeless craftsmanship and need to build a polished, professional wardrobe. Think of it as Sid Mashburn's slightly more conservative older brother. Prices are comparable, with a focus on investment pieces that are made to last for decades.
Shop now at brooksbrothers.com
For those who love the classic J.Crew look but at a more accessible price point, J.Crew Factory is the answer. You'll find timeless menswear staples like chinos, button-downs, and casual blazers, usually retailing between $30 and $100. It captures that preppy and polished, yet comfortable vibe that Sid Mashburn is known for.
While the fabrics and construction aren't at the bespoke level of Mashburn, it's a fantastic choice for building out your everyday wardrobe with versatile, stylish basics that won't break the bank.
Shop now at factory.jcrew.com
No list about American prep would be complete without Ralph Lauren Polo. It’s an icon for a reason, offering everything from its signature polos and chinos to smart outerwear. The aesthetic is aspirational and polished, embodying that luxurious but laid-back American lifestyle.
Like Sid Mashburn, the brand is centered on timeless style. However, Polo often feels a bit more preppy and focused on leisurewear, while Mashburn hones in on refined tailoring. If you love classic pieces with an instantly recognizable stamp of quality, Polo Ralph Lauren is a sure bet.
Shop now at ralphlauren.com
Bonobos built its reputation on one thing: getting the fit right. The brand changed the game with its perfectly tailored chinos, but now offers a full range of menswear from dress shirts to suits. They share Sid Mashburn’s passion for quality fits but take a more modern and streamlined approach to online shopping, with an easy-to-use fit guide.
Their style is contemporary and casual, making tailored menswear feel approachable instead of stuffy. With most items landing in the $70-$200 range, it’s a direct competitor for guys who want comfortable, high-quality essentials without any fuss.
Shop now at bonobos.com
Todd Snyder seamlessly blends classic American sportswear with a cool, urban edge. Think heritage-inspired pieces reimagined with modern tailoring and a dash of downtown cool. Similar to Sid Mashburn, there’s a serious focus on high-quality fabrics and sharp craftsmanship.
The key difference is Todd Snyder’s slightly more fashion-forward perspective. It’s for the guy who appreciates timeless style but wants pieces that feel current and a little bit edgy. You'll find everything from tailored trousers and unique knits to awesome brand collabs, with shirts starting around $100.
Shop now at toddsnyder.com
While Sid Mashburn channels a polished, city-ready style, L.L.Bean offers the rugged, outdoor-inspired version. Known for durable flannels, field coats, and of course, the iconic Bean Boot, L.L.Bean focuses on practical, long-lasting menswear that can handle anything.
Though more laid-back, the brand shares Mashburn’s commitment to quality and longevity. With most items priced affordably between $20 and $100, it's the perfect choice for classic, comfortable pieces that effortlessly transition from a weekend in the country to a casual day in the city.
Shop now at llbean.com
While primarily a footwear brand, Clarks' iconic shoes are the perfect foundation for a Sid Mashburn-inspired wardrobe. Famous for their Desert Boots and Wallabees, Clarks offers timeless, comfortable, and versatile styles that work with everything from chinos and shorts to casual suits.
Their focus on understated style and quality craftsmanship aligns perfectly with the Mashburn aesthetic. With prices generally in the $80-$200 range, their shoes are a smart investment for a well-rounded and put-together look.
Shop now at clarksusa.com
Hailing from the UK, Barbour is legendary for its waxed cotton jackets and rugged, country-inspired style. While Sid Mashburn’s roots lie in American tailoring, Barbour offers a complementary focus on timeless, functional outerwear that every well-dressed man should own.
The brand brings a touch of British heritage charm, perfect for layering over knits and button-downs. Its iconic waxed jackets are an investment piece, typically ranging from $200-$500, designed to last a lifetime and only get better with age.
Shop now at barbour.com
If you love Sid Mashburn’s shirting, you need to check out Gitman Vintage. This American brand specializes in high-quality shirts made from authentic heritage fabrics. Known for their classic designs and impeccable construction in their Pennsylvania factory, their pieces feel both timeless and unique.
Compared to Mashburn, Gitman Vintage has a slightly more nostalgic, artisanal feel. It’s perfect for men who nerd out over great fabrics and want a well-made shirt with a story. Shirts typically run from $150-$300.
Shop now at gitmanvintage.com
A.P.C. (Atelier de Production et de Creation) is a French brand that brings a minimalist European perspective to classic menswear. They are celebrated for their clean designs, high-quality essentials, and especially their raw selvedge denim, which is a favorite among style aficionados.
Like Sid Mashburn, A.P.C. champions an understated and timeless approach to style. However, their aesthetic is more pared-down and modern. If you want refined, simple pieces that can be endlessly remixed, from perfect-fit jeans to subtle sweaters, A.P.C. is an excellent choice.
Shop now at apc.fr
Filson is an American heritage brand that equips you for the Great Outdoors with incredibly durable, workwear-inspired apparel. Think heavy-duty tin cloth jackets, rugged twill bags, and tough-as-nails flannels. Established in 1897, their gear is built to last through anything.
While Sid Mashburn is more tailored and refined, Filson shares a core philosophy of uncompromising quality and longevity. For guys who love the rustic side of classic American style, Filson delivers pieces that look just as good in the field as they do on a city street, with jackets generally in the $200-$400 range.
Shop now at filson.com
London-based Reiss offers modern, sharply tailored menswear with a sleek European flair. If you're looking for slim-fit suits, polished knits, and smart outerwear, this brand delivers both quality and contemporary style. It resonates with Sid Mashburn’s appreciation for good tailoring, but with a cleaner, more minimal silhouette.
Reiss is an ideal stop for building a polished work wardrobe or grabbing an outfit for a dressy-casual event. Expect prices from $100 for shirts up to $400 for outerwear, making it a solid mid-range option for sophisticated pieces.
Shop now at reiss.com
Frank And Oak delivers stylish, modern menswear with a strong focus on sustainability. Their collections are filled with versatile basics designed with eco-friendly fabrics, making it easy to create a polished wardrobe that's also kind to the planet. You’ll find great-fitting shirts, organic cotton tees, and recycled outerwear.
They share Sid Mashburn’s commitment to quality essentials, but adopt a more contemporary and minimalist aesthetic. With prices typically in the $50-$200 range, it's an accessible way to shop consciously without sacrificing style.
Shop now at frankandoak.com
Infused with a Southern charm, Billy Reid offers beautifully crafted menswear that feels both luxurious and lived-in. Known for its impeccable details, artisanal fabrics, and signature fits, the brand creates sophisticated pieces that are effortlessly wearable. It's relaxed luxury at its best.
Like Sid Mashburn, Billy Reid has a deep appreciation for craftsmanship. The aesthetic here is a bit more refined and romantic, blending classic silhouettes with unique textural elements. It's for the man who appreciates the subtle details that make a garment special, with shirts starting around $150.
Shop now at billyreid.com
Known for its fun-loving, East Coast prep vibe, Vineyard Vines is all about classic styles for a life lived well. Think smiley whale logos, colorful chinos, and comfortable performance polos. The overall feel is much more casual and laid-back than Sid Mashburn's tailored aesthetic.
However, both brands share roots in classic American style. If you love Mashburn for weekday polish, Vineyard Vines is your go-to for relaxed weekend wear, vacation outfits, and perfectly broken-in essentials. The pricing is also more budget-friendly, typically between $40 and $100.
Shop now at vineyardvines.com
J.Crew has long been a destination for approachable, classic American style with a modern twist. From their Ludlow suits to their garment-dyed tees and chinos, they offer a massive range of menswear that just feels right for almost any occasion. It's reliable, stylish, and consistently good.
Compared to Sid Mashburn’s bespoke focus, J.Crew offers a broader and more trend-aware collection while still being grounded in timeless prep. They provide excellent quality for the price, making it easy to build a versatile and stylish wardrobe season after season.
Shop now at jcrew.com
Orvis is another iconic American brand rooted in outdoor and fly-fishing traditions. Their clothing is designed for durability and function, featuring timeless pieces like Dri-release shirts, rugged outerwear, and comfortable flannels. Their vibe is classic, practical, and a little bit rustic.
While their focus is on performance in the outdoors, their commitment to high-quality, long-lasting gear is something any Sid Mashburn fan can appreciate. If you're looking for functional, handsome pieces that excel outside of the office, Orvis is a fantastic choice.
Shop now at orvis.com
Everlane champions "Radical Transparency," offering modern, minimalist basics without traditional retail markups. Their collections are filled with high-quality essentials like merino sweaters, slim-fit performance chinos, and organic cotton tees that are designed to be wardrobe mainstays.
They share Sid Mashburn's focus on foundational pieces but with a cleaner, more contemporary aesthetic. If you're drawn to simple, ethically made clothing with an affordable luxury feel, Everlane's approach to minimalist menswear is perfect. Most items are priced accessibly under $150.
Shop now at everlane.com
At Apart Style, we're obsessed with curating the best in fashion, beauty, and jewelry to help you discover new brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, style, and uniqueness. When you make a purchase through our links, Apart Style may earn a commission - which helps support our small team, and allows us to continue bringing you the best in online style brands.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our full brand directory or check out our curated brand guides to find your new favorite thing.
