If you love adding a bit of whimsical, romantic flair to your outfits, you're probably already a fan of Poppy and Peonies. Their beautifully crafted statement earrings, playful hair accessories, and charming jewelry have a special way of making any look feel fun and unique without trying too hard.
Their signature mix of boho-chic style and modern femininity is perfect for anyone who loves accessories with personality. For those looking to expand their collection with a similar vibe, here are 19 amazing brands that capture that same playful and chic spirit.
Anthropologie nails the eclectic, artsy aesthetic with its curated collection of jewelry and accessories. Think unique statement earrings, beaded hair clips, and layered necklaces that feel both vintage-inspired and totally modern. Their pieces often have a handcrafted, bohemian feel that fans of Poppy and Peonies will immediately love.
While the price point is a bit higher (around $40-$150), it’s a perfect option when you're searching for something with a bit more of an artisanal touch. If you want a piece that feels like a special, artistic find, Anthro is your go-to.
Shop now at anthropologie.com
For trend-driven accessories that won't break the bank, BaubleBar is king. The brand is known for its bold, colorful, and fun statement pieces, from chunky earrings to sparkly hair accessories. They are constantly dropping new styles, making it easy to grab the latest trends and add a pop of personality to your look.
With prices mostly falling between $15 and $80, it's an accessible way to get that playful, eye-catching style similar to Poppy and Peonies. It's the perfect brand for experimenting with fun trends without a huge commitment.
Shop now at baublebar.com
Kate Spade brings a signature dose of playful sophistication to everything it designs, and its accessories are no exception. Expect charming earrings with quirky motifs, brightly colored hair clips, and enamel-detailed pieces that feel both fun and polished. It’s like Poppy and Peonies' preppier, city-chic older sister.
Prices are higher, typically ranging from $50 to $150, but the quality and signature whimsical designs offer a timeless appeal that blends fun with classic style seamlessly.
Shop now at katespade.com
If you love the statement-making ethos of Poppy and Peonies but prefer an edgier, more modern vibe, meet Luv Aj. The brand is known for its bold, chain-link hoops, layered pavé necklaces, and general rock-chic aesthetic. It trades whimsical florals for cool-girl metallics and architectural shapes.
Ranging from $40 to $150, Luv Aj offers high-quality, fashion-forward pieces that make a statement in a different way - perfect for adding a bit of contemporary edge to your accessory collection.
Shop now at luvaj.com
London-based Missoma is the must-know brand for chic, layerable gold jewelry that feels effortlessly cool. While Poppy and Peonies leans into colorful charm, Missoma masters the art of delicate, modern pieces meant for everyday wear. Their collection is full of fan-favorite chain necklaces, charm hoops, and stackable rings.
With a price range of $50-$200, Missoma focuses on high-quality materials like gold vermeil, offering a more refined, minimalist alternative for curating a cohesive and versatile jewelry wardrobe.
Shop now at missoma.com
J.Crew has long been a go-to for timeless, polished accessories that have a playful pop of color or a slight vintage twist. A great alternative to Poppy and Peonies, their collection often features crystal statement earrings, tortoise shell hair clips, and cute charm necklaces that feel classic and fun at the same time.
Priced around $20-$100, their pieces are great quality and incredibly wearable, whether you're dressing for work or a weekend brunch. It's a reliable source for accessories that effortlessly elevate any look.
Shop now at jcrew.com
Olivia Burton is your dream brand if you're captivated by the romantic, nature-inspired side of Poppy and Peonies. Known for watches and jewelry featuring intricate floral motifs, bees, and other whimsical woodland designs, their pieces feel delicate and utterly charming. It's femininity with an elegant, English-garden feel.
Their accessories usually range from $50 to $150, offering a slightly more subdued and detailed elegance compared to some of Poppy and Peonies' bolder pieces.
Shop now at oliviaburton.com
If your favorite part of Poppy and Peonies is their vibrant and playful hair accessories, you'll feel right at home with Stella &, Bow. The brand specializes in creating colorful, fun pieces like oversized hair bows, bright claw clips, and playful statement earrings. Their aesthetic takes the whimsy up a notch with a slightly retro twist.
It sits in a similar price range of $20 to $70, making it an excellent alternative for adding bold, conversation-starting accents to your look.
Shop now at stellaandbow.com
For those who value unique, handcrafted accessories, Kate's Paperie is a hidden gem. While its roots are in stationery, its accessory collection has a wonderfully artisanal, boho-chic feel. You'll find intricate beadwork, natural elements, and creative designs that feel truly special and one-of-a-kind. It shares that spirit of thoughtful design found at Poppy and Peonies.
With prices from $30 to $100, it's for the shopper who wants an accessory that tells a story and feels personal.
Shop now at katespaperie.com
A global favorite for a reason, Accessorize offers a massive selection of trendy, budget-friendly jewelry, hair accessories, and bags. It has a youthful, fun energy similar to Poppy and Peonies, with a great mix of bohemian, sparkly, and minimalist styles to choose from. Whether you want beaded hoops or a cute claw clip, you'll likely find it there.
Prices are very affordable, typically falling between $10 and $50, making it an amazing place to stock up on fun, seasonal pieces.
Shop now at accessorize.com
Based in California, Gorjana is celebrated for its lightweight, layerable jewelry perfect for everyday wear. Think delicate gold necklaces, stackable rings, and classy hoops that are understated yet chic. It’s great for people who love the quality of Poppy and Peonies but are looking for simpler, more minimalist staple pieces.
Priced from $40 to $150, Gorjana offers timeless designs that are great for building a beautifully polished and highly versatile accessory collection.
Shop now at gorjana.com
Drawing on French romanticism, Lily and Rose creates stunning vintage-inspired jewelry with incredible sparkle. Many of their pieces incorporate floral motifs, delicate shapes, and high-quality crystals, echoing the feminine and romantic vibe of Poppy and Peonies. However, Lily and Rose often feels a bit more refined and luxe.
With a price range from $60 to $200, an accessory here would be great for dressing up for weddings or special occasions when you want a piece that feels extra special and elegant.
Shop now at lilyandrose.com
If you're intrigued by BaubleBar's trendy designs but find their main collection a bit too bold, BaubleBar Petite is the answer. This line offers smaller, more delicate versions of their popular styles. You'll find dainty earrings, minimalist hair clips, and subtle necklaces ideal for a touch of everyday sparkle.
It's similar to Poppy and Peonies' playful aesthetic but focuses on lightweight pieces that won't overwhelm your look. Prices range from a super-accessible $15 to $60.
Shop now at baublebar.com
For unmatched sparkle and glamour, Swarovski is an iconic choice. Using their signature precision-cut crystals, their earrings, necklaces, and hair accessories are designed to catch the light beautifully. While the brand feels more luxurious than Poppy and Peonies, both share a love for high-impact, eye-catching accessories.
Priced from $50 to $300, Swarovski is a perfect choice when you want to invest in a dazzling piece for special occasions or to add a touch of high-shine elegance to your everyday style.
Shop now at swarovski.com
Take whimsy to a whole new level with Erstwilder. This Australian brand is known for its quirky, collectible brooches, earrings, and scarves that feature fun illustrations of animals, plants, and characters. Their pieces are bold, colorful, and guaranteed conversation starters.
It shares Poppy and Peonies' creative, playful spirit but with a more eccentric, art-forward twist. Priced between $40 to $150, their accessories are for those who aren't afraid to let their personality shine through their style.
Shop now at erstwilder.com
Get that classic, preppy polish of J.Crew at a more affordable price. J.Crew Factory delivers colorful crystal earrings, classic pearl accessories, and versatile pieces that share the same playful-yet-put-together DNA as Poppy and Peonies. It’s an easy and budget-friendly way to stock up on essentials.
Their pieces, priced from $15 to $50, are perfect for adding the finishing touch to your everyday outfits and look more expensive than they are.
Shop now at factory.jcrew.com
Known for its chic shoes and bags, Loeffler Randall brings that same modern, sophisticated touch to its accessories. Expect sculptural earrings, elegant hair clips, and thoughtfully designed pieces with a clean, minimalist slant. It appeals to a similar customer who appreciates elevated design details.
With prices ranging from $50 to $200, it's a great option for those who admire the understated side of Poppy and Peonies and want modern, investment-worthy accessories.
Shop now at loefflerrandall.com
Urban Outfitters is a great one-stop-shop for on-trend, youthful, and affordable accessories. Their collection is a chaotic but fun mix of everything - from boho jewelry and '90s-inspired claw clips to edgy hoop packs. It’s the slightly younger, more streetwear-adjacent counterpart to Poppy and Peonies' polished whimsy.
With everything from $10 to $50, you can easily load up on fun, of-the-moment pieces without feeling guilty.
Shop now at urbanoutfitters.com
Sophie &, Toi is for the die-hard romantics. This boutique brand specializes in delicate, feminine jewelry with a strong focus on floral and nature inspiration. Sound familiar? Their collection is filled with dainty earrings, darling charms, and pretty hair accessories that feel incredibly similar to Poppy and Peonies' core aesthetic.
Priced from $30 to $120, it’s a spot-on alternative for those who love Poppy and Peonies’ romantic vibe but may be looking for slightly more refined and subtle versions of those beloved designs.
Shop now at sophieandtoi.com
At Apart Style, we're obsessed with curating the best in fashion, beauty, and jewelry to help you discover new brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, style, and uniqueness. When you make a purchase through our links, Apart Style may earn a commission - which helps support our small team, and allows us to continue bringing you the best in online style brands.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our full brand directory or check out our curated brand guides to find your new favorite thing.
