There's a reason so many of us have a pair of Naturalizer shoes in our closet. They absolutely nailed the sweet spot where all-day comfort meets classic style, making them the perfect go-to for work-to-weekend footwear that actually feels good on your feet.
If you're looking to expand your collection of comfortable shoes without sacrificing style, you're in the right place. We've rounded up 19 brands that share Naturalizer's dedication to making great-looking shoes designed for real life.
Think of Vionic as the expert in stylish, supportive footwear. The brand specializes in creating podiatrist-designed shoes with built-in orthotic arch support, making them a dream for anyone who spends a lot of time on their feet or deals with foot pain. You'll find everything from sleek sandals and flats to sneakers and boots in their collection.
While Naturalizer focuses on overall comfort, Vionic takes it a step further with a deep emphasis on medical-grade support and foot health. If you wish your favorite shoes had better arch support, Vionic is the first place you should look. Shop now at vionicshoes.com.
Clarks is a true heritage brand known for its durable, timeless, and, most importantly, comfortable shoes. Their legendary desert boots, loafers, and ankle boots are crafted from high-quality materials and feature soft, cushioned insoles for everyday wear.
Compared to Naturalizer, Clarks often leans into more traditional and sometimes slightly rugged designs, but the core promise is the same: reliable comfort that lasts. They are masters of blending classic British style with modern comfort technology. Shop now at clarksusa.com.
Sofft delivers on its name by offering buttery-soft shoes made with premium materials and a focus on foot-friendly design. The brand excels at crafting comfortable flats, pretty loafers, and wearable low-heeled shoes that often incorporate trend-forward details and contemporary silhouettes.
Similar to Naturalizer, Sofft is a hit with women who need all-day comfort, especially thanks to their generous padded footbeds and availability of wide widths. Where they differ slightly is that Sofft often has a bit more fashion-forward flair in its designs. Shop now at softtshoes.com.
If your style leans a little more bohemian and laid-back, you'll love Earth Brands. They specialize in super comfortable sandals, boots, and flats with a relaxed, earthy vibe. Known for their deeply cushioned footbeds and sustainability efforts, this brand is all about feeling grounded and supported.
While Naturalizer's aesthetic is generally more classic and polished, Earth appeals to those who want a more organic, eco-friendly feel in their comfortable footwear choices. Shop now at earthbrandsthatfit.com.
For comfortable footwear that's also easy on the wallet, Easy Street is a fantastic option. The brand provides affordable and versatile styles, including flats, wedges, and boots, all designed with cushioning and flexibility in mind. They're particularly known for offering an extensive range of sizes and widths.
Think of Easy Street as a more budget-friendly and often more casual alternative to Naturalizer. You get the same focus on all-day wearability without the higher price tag. Shop now at easystreetshoes.com.
Born stands out with its dedication to handcrafted quality and artisanal details. The brand's leather flats, clogs, and boots feature flexible, hand-sewn construction and cushioned insoles that feel amazing from the very first wear. They have a slightly rugged, vintage-inspired look that's incredibly timeless.
Where Naturalizer offers clean, mass-market appeal, Born has a more unique, crafted feel. The comfort is top-tier, but the aesthetic is for someone who appreciates rich leathers and artisanal touches. Shop now at bornshoes.com.
Mephisto is a luxury European comfort brand for those who are serious about their footwear. Renowned for their incredible shock absorption, superior arch support, and handmade quality, Mephisto shoes are an investment in foot health. Their casual shoes, walking sneakers, and sandals are built to last a lifetime.
Compared to Naturalizer's accessible price point, Mephisto is significantly more expensive. However, you're paying for unparalleled craftsmanship and ergonomic technology that delivers long-lasting, premium comfort. Shop now at mephisto.com.
Rockport strikes a brilliant balance between athletic shoe technology and everyday style. They're famous for incorporating sporty comfort features, like shock-absorbing soles and lightweight cushioning, into loafers, boots, and walking shoes you can wear to the office.
If you love Naturalizer's comfort but have a more active lifestyle or just prefer a slightly more casual, athletic vibe, Rockport is your brand. It's the perfect commuter shoe that doesn't scream "commuter shoe." Shop now at rockport.com.
While primarily known for their travel-friendly clothing, Clara Sunwoo extends its comfort-driven ethos to a line of chic, modern footwear. Their selection includes easy-to-wear slip-ons, flats, and low heels made from soft, flexible materials and supportive cushioned insoles.
Like Naturalizer, Clara Sunwoo believes you shouldn't have to choose between looking stylish and feeling comfortable. The key difference is Clara Sunwoo's more contemporary and fashion-forward aesthetic. Shop now at clarasunwoo.com.
Famous for their iconic, pull-on Chelsea boots, Blundstone offers rugged durability and surprising comfort. These boots are lightweight, slip-resistant, and feature excellent shock absorption, which is why people who wear them swear by them for all-day adventures.
While the utilitarian style is a definite departure from Naturalizer’s more classic offerings, both brands are loved by people who are on the move and value long-lasting comfort and quality construction in their footwear. Shop now at blundstone.com.
Vaneli delivers sophisticated, elegant shoes that masterfully hide their comfort features. They create beautiful loafers, pumps, and flats from high-quality leathers that feature pillowy insoles and supportive construction, making them a secret weapon for the boardroom.
Think of Vaneli as Naturalizer's more refined, polished older sister. They share a deep commitment to comfort, but Vaneli's styles often have a more professional and upscale feel. Shop now at vaneli.com.
Ecco blends clean Scandinavian design with innovative comfort technology. Known for their anatomically shaped footbeds and flexible, shock-absorbing outsoles, Ecco's sneakers, flats, and boots offer fantastic support in a sleek, minimalist package.
Both brands prioritize foot health and all-day wear, but Ecco’s aesthetic is distinctly more modern, sporty, and minimalistic than Naturalizer's classic, sometimes more decorative, designs. Shop now at us.ecco.com.
Trotters is another excellent brand that seamlessly combines professional style with true comfort. Offering a fantastic size range (from narrow to extra wide), their collection of leather loafers, casual shoes, and pumps feature cushioned insoles and flexible soles for busy workdays.
In many ways, Trotters is a direct peer to Naturalizer, appealing to the same woman who needs versatile, comfortable, and classic shoes that can take her from morning meetings to evening errands. Shop now at trotters.com.
For those who love comfort but crave contemporary design, Naya is a great find. Focusing largely on trendy flats and everyday sneakers, their shoes are built with soft linings, cushioned footbeds, and flexible materials that are perfect for modern life.
Naya shares Naturalizer's comfort-first mission but spins it with a younger, trendier perspective. If you find Naturalizer a bit too traditional at times, Naya's modern silhouettes might be exactly what you're looking for. Shop now at nayashoes.com.
Aerosoles is built around the idea that flexible soles and cushioned footbeds are non-negotiable. They are famous for their diamond-patterned rubber soles that bend with your foot's movement and offer great traction, paired with memory foam insoles for a soft landing.
Aerosoles and Naturalizer cater to a similar audience, offering reasonably priced flats, loafers, and boots. Aerosoles places a huge emphasis on its highly flexible outsoles as its key comfort technology. Shop now at aerosoles.com.
Hush Puppies brings a bright, optimistic, and relaxed vibe to comfortable footwear. Their iconic casual shoes, loafers, and sneakers focus on lightweight construction, flexible soles, and supportive footbeds, all wrapped up in a laid-back, effortlessly cool package.
Compared to Naturalizer's often professional look, Hush Puppies is decidedly more casual and relaxed. It's the perfect brand for comfortable, colorful weekend shoes. Shop now at hushpuppies.com.
Leaning heavily into eco-conscious design, Natural Step creates comfortable footwear using sustainable and recycled materials. Their lineup of casual flats, sandals, and sneakers provides great cushioning and a feel-good component for environmentally minded shoppers.
While both brands have "natural" in their names and commitment to comfort, Natural Step stands apart from Naturalizer with its strong focus on a green manufacturing process and vegan materials. Shop now at naturalstepshoes.com.
Dr. Scholl's has evolved far beyond the drugstore aisle, offering a remarkably stylish lineup of modern sneakers, sandals, and boots. Their secret weapon is their deep understanding of foot anatomy, which they use to pack comfort technology - like anatomical cushioning and incredible support - into every pair.
Like Naturalizer, comfort is the non-negotiable backbone of the brand. But Dr. Scholl's aesthetic often leans younger and trendier, with a major focus on sustainability and casual, sporty silhouettes perfect for a modern wardrobe. Shop now at drschollsshoes.com.
A true icon in the world of comfort, Birkenstock is famous for its magical contoured cork footbed that molds to your unique foot shape over time. While best known for their sandals, the brand also makes ridiculously comfortable clogs, shoes, and boots using the same supportive principles.
While Naturalizer provides comfort in more structured, classic silhouettes, Birkenstock is the master of casual, effortlessly cool support. For a more laid-back look without compromising on world-class ergonomic design, Birkenstock is unmatched. Shop now at birkenstock.com.
At Apart Style, we're obsessed with curating the best in fashion, beauty, and jewelry to help you discover new brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, style, and uniqueness. When you make a purchase through our links, Apart Style may earn a commission - which helps support our small team, and allows us to continue bringing you the best in online style brands.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our full brand directory or check out our curated brand guides to find your new favorite thing.
