Rolex Datejust vs. Datejust II: What's the difference?

The classic Rolex Datejust and the now-discontinued Datejust II primarily differ in size and wrist presence. The classic Datejust maintains its traditional 36mm case, offering a timeless and understated elegance, while the Datejust II, produced from 2009 to 2016, features a larger, bolder 41mm case with thicker lugs and a wider bezel for a more contemporary look.

Here’s a detailed comparison to help you decide which iconic Rolex model is the right new or pre-owned investment for you.

Rolex Datejust

Introduced in 1945, the Rolex Datejust was the world's first self-winding chronometer wristwatch to display the date in a window on the dial. It serves as the archetype of the classic watch, celebrated for its enduring design, functional precision, and incredible versatility that makes it suitable for virtually any occasion.

• What it is: An iconic luxury timepiece known for its timeless style, featuring an automatically changing date display magnified by a singular Cyclops lens.
• Key features: A 36mm Oyster case (though other sizes exist), waterproofness to 100 meters, a Perpetual self-winding movement, and the signature Cyclops lens over the date. Offered with either an Oyster or Jubilee bracelet.
• Price: New models typically start around $7,000 for stainless steel versions and increase based on materials and dial configurations.
• Materials/Construction: Crafted from robust Oystersteel (904L steel), Rolesor (a combination of steel and gold), or full precious metals like 18k yellow or Everose gold, and topped with a scratch-resistant sapphire crystal.
• Sizing/Fit: The classic 36mm case provides a comfortable and balanced fit for a wide range of wrist sizes, creating a traditional and elegant profile.
• Pros: Timeless and iconic design that never goes out of style. Extremely versatile for both formal and casual wear. Comfortable sizing for all-day wear. Holds its value exceptionally well due to enduring demand.
• Cons: A 36mm case might feel too small for individuals accustomed to larger, modern watch sizes. Its traditional aesthetic may not appeal to those seeking a bolder statement piece.

The Rolex Datejust is perfect for those who want a classic, foundational luxury watch that exudes timeless elegance and proven versatility.

Shop this product: rolex.com/watches/datejust

Rolex Datejust II

Launched in 2009, the Datejust II was Rolex's answer to the growing trend of larger watches. It offered the familiar DNA of the classic Datejust in a larger, more masculine 41mm case. Though it was only produced for a few years before being replaced by the more proportionally refined Datejust 41, it remains a popular choice on the pre-owned market for its bold presence.

• What it is: A larger, contemporary version of the classic Rolex Datejust, designed for a more modern wrist presence.
• Key features: A 41mm Oyster case, waterproof to 100 meters, Cyclops lens, and Perpetual movement. Features noticeably thicker lugs and a wider bezel compared to its classic counterpart.
• Price: Initially retailed around $9,000 for steel models. As a discontinued model, pricing is now determined by the pre-owned market and varies based on condition and configuration.
• Materials/Construction: Built with the same exceptional Rolex standards, available in durable Oystersteel and two-tone Rolesor combinations with a scratch-resistant sapphire crystal.
• Sizing/Fit: The 41mm case and robust proportions give this watch a substantial and very modern feel on the wrist, which works best for average to larger wrist sizes.
• Pros: A bold, modern aesthetic that aligns with contemporary watch trends. Excellent wrist presence makes it a true statement piece. Retains the iconic and functional design of the original Datejust.
• Cons: Has been discontinued, so it's only available on the secondary market. Its proportions (thicker lugs and wider bezel) are considered less refined by some collectors compared to the classic Datejust or the newer Datejust 41. The large size can be uncomfortable on smaller wrists.

This model is the ideal choice for watch enthusiasts who love the Datejust identity but strongly prefer a larger, contemporary timepiece with a powerful wrist presence.

Shop this product: Available on the pre-owned market.

Rolex Datejust vs. Rolex Datejust II Comparison

Size & Proportions

The most immediate difference is case diameter - the classic Datejust is traditionally 36mm, while the Datejust II is a commanding 41mm. This 5mm gap creates a significant contrast on the wrist. Beyond diameter, the proportions are distinct.

The Datejust II has thicker lugs and a wider, flatter bezel relative to its case size. This gives it a sportier, more substantial look and feel. In contrast, the 36mm Datejust maintains its classic, elegant proportions, appearing more balanced and refined. The choice between them comes down to whether you prefer a watch that wears in a traditional, understated manner or one that makes a bolder, more modern statement.

Style & Aesthetic

While sharing the same foundational design, the two watches serve different stylistic preferences. The Rolex Datejust embodies timeless elegance. Its modest size allows it to slip easily under a shirt cuff, making it a perfect dress watch that is still robust enough for daily wear. It is the definition of a versatile, do-everything luxury timepiece.

The Rolex Datejust II leans more toward a modern, sporty-dress watch hybrid. Its larger size gives it a more casual and assertive feel, appealing to those who favor modern horological trends. While it can still be worn with formal attire, its sheer presence makes it less of a classic dress watch and more of a contemporary statement piece.

Price & Value

When new, the Datejust II commanded a higher retail price than the standard Datejust, reflecting its larger size and positioning as a modern alternative. Today, the classic 36mm Datejust is still in production and provides a more accessible entry price into the Rolex collection. As the Datejust II is now only available on the secondary market, its price can fluctuate based on condition, rarity, and demand.

Both models hold their value exceptionally well, as expected from Rolex. However, the 36mm Datejust is a market cornerstone with enduring, universal appeal, ensuring its value remains strong and stable. The Datejust II appeals to a specific market segment that favors larger watches, giving it solid, albeit more niche, demand.

Who Each One Works Best For

Your choice should be guided by your wrist size and style. The 36mm Datejust is a universally flattering option suitable for nearly all wrist sizes and occasions. It is the definitive choice for those who value classic design, subtlety, and versatility in a luxury watch.

The 41mm Datejust II is better suited for individuals with average-to-larger wrists or anyone who simply prefers the look and feel of a substantial timepiece. It is for the modern buyer who wants the heritage of the Datejust name in a package that reflects current size trends.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both models represent Rolex's commitment to quality and timeless function, but they are tailored to different sensibilities.

Choose the Rolex Datejust if:

• You appreciate timeless design and proportions over modern trends.
• You have a small to average-sized wrist or prefer a classic fit.
• You want an incredibly versatile watch that is perfect for any setting, from formal to casual.
• You value understatement and elegance in your timepiece.

Choose the Rolex Datejust II if:

• You prefer a larger watch with a bold and contemporary presence.
• You have a larger wrist or simply enjoy the feel of a more substantial watch.
• Your personal style is more modern and you want a sports-dress hybrid.
• You are shopping on the pre-owned market for a discontinued statement piece.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between the Rolex Datejust and Datejust II?

The main difference is the case size and proportions. The classic Datejust most commonly comes in a 36mm case with traditional, refined proportions. The Datejust II has a larger 41mm case with thicker lugs and a wider bezel, giving it a much bolder and more modern appearance.

Why was the Rolex Datejust II discontinued?

Rolex discontinued the Datejust II in 2016 and replaced it with the Datejust 41. While also 41mm, the new Datejust 41 features slimmer lugs, a thinner bezel, and an updated movement, giving it proportions that are considered more aesthetically refined and closer to the original Datejust design ethos.

Which one holds its value better?

Both watches have a strong reputation for retaining value. The classic 36mm Rolex Datejust is an industry icon with evergreen demand, making it a very safe investment. The Datejust II also performs well on the secondary market, especially among buyers looking specifically for its unique, bolder proportions.

Is the 36mm Rolex Datejust too small for a man?

Absolutely not. 36mm has been the traditional standard for a men's dress watch for decades and remains a popular and stylish choice. It is considered a timeless, elegant size that flatters most wrists without being overpowering.

Can I still buy a new Rolex Datejust II?

No, the Rolex Datejust II is no longer in production. It can only be purchased from secondary sources such as trusted pre-owned watch dealers and private sellers.

Which is better for a smaller wrist?

The classic 36mm Datejust is unequivocally the better choice for a smaller wrist. Its balanced proportions and modest diameter provide a much more comfortable and aesthetically pleasing fit than the large and bulky 41mm Datejust II.

Is the build quality the same for both models?

Yes. Both the Datejust and the Datejust II were built to Rolex's exacting standards of quality, precision, and durability. They use the same high-quality materials, such as 904L steel and scratch-resistant sapphire crystals, and both feature the robust, waterproof Oyster case.

Which watch is considered more versatile?

The classic 36mm Datejust is generally considered more versatile. Its timeless size and understated elegance allow it to transition seamlessly between formal, professional, and casual occasions, whereas the large presence of the Datejust II makes it feel more casual and modern.