Old Navy Compression Pants vs. Lululemon: Which one is better?

The core difference between Old Navy compression pants and Lululemon leggings comes down to price versus performance. Old Navy offers a highly affordable option, typically priced under $30, perfect for casual wear and light workouts, while Lululemon represents a premium investment, with pants costing around $100-$130, engineered with advanced technical fabrics for serious athletic performance and durability.

Here’s a detailed look at both brands to help you decide which one best fits your budget and lifestyle.

Old Navy Compression Pants

Old Navy, part of Gap Inc., brings its signature affordability and accessibility to the activewear market. Their compression pants are designed as a functional, comfortable, and budget-friendly option for everyday consumers who want versatile activewear without a high price tag.

• What it is: Entry-level compression pants from an affordable family-focused retailer, geared toward casual wear, errands, and light exercise.
• Key features: Breathable, stretchy fabric, basic color selections, and frequent inclusion in a wide range of sales promotions.
• Price: $20 - $30, often available for less during sales.
• Materials/Construction: Typically made from a blend of polyester and elastane, focusing on comfort and stretch over high-tech performance features.
• Sizing/Fit: Sizing runs from XS to XXL and is generally true to size, though some customers note occasional inconsistencies between different styles. Expect a standard, comfortable fit rather than a highly technical, contoured one.
• Pros: Extremely affordable and a great value option. Comfortable for everyday activities and low-impact fitness. Widely available online and in stores. Easy and flexible return policy.
• Cons: Lower durability compared to premium brands, may not hold up to intense workouts or years of frequent washing. Compression is generally lighter and less supportive. Sizing can sometimes be inconsistent.

These are a solid choice for budget-conscious shoppers needing comfortable pants for casual activities or for those just starting their fitness journey.

Shop this product: oldnavy.gap.com/browse/category.do?cid=5517

Lululemon Compression Pants

Lululemon is a premium athletic apparel brand that has become synonymous with high-performance, stylish activewear. Their compression pants are famous for their innovative technical fabrics, flattering fit, and superb durability, making them a favorite among fitness enthusiasts and athletes.

• What it is: High-end, performance-oriented compression pants designed for activities like yoga, running, and high-intensity training.
• Key features: Proprietary fabrics like Nulu (buttery soft) and Everlux (fast-drying) that offer excellent moisture-wicking, four-way stretch, and shape retention.
• Price: $98 - $128.
• Materials/Construction: Engineered with advanced materials that feel incredible, manage sweat effectively, and are built to last through countless workouts and washes.
• Sizing/Fit: Offers precise sizing from 0 to 14 (with some styles offering extended sizes) for a consistent, body-contouring fit. Known for a 'hugged' sensation that supports without restricting movement.
• Pros: Outstanding quality and material performance. Exceptionally durable and long-lasting, making them a good long-term investment. Flattering, consistent fit that retains its shape. Stylish designs and a wide range of color options.
• Cons: High price point can be a barrier for many. Sales are infrequent, making it hard to find a discount.

This is the clear choice for dedicated athletes and those who prioritize superior performance, fit, and longevity in their activewear and are willing to invest in it.

Shop this product: shop.lululemon.com/c/women-leggings/

Old Navy Compression Pants vs. Lululemon Compression Pants Comparison

Price & Value

There's no contest here when it comes to the initial cost. Old Navy's pants come in at a fraction of the price of Lululemon's, often under $30. When you factor in near-constant sales, they become even more accessible. For anyone on a tight budget, Old Navy offers immediate value.

However, the value proposition for Lululemon is built on longevity. A pair of their leggings can last for many years of frequent use, while a less expensive pair might need to be replaced much sooner. If you look at cost-per-wear over several years, the investment in Lululemon can be justified, but the upfront cost remains high.

Quality & Materials

This is where Lululemon truly separates itself from the competition. Their proprietary fabrics like Nulu, Luon, and Everlux are engineered for specific activities, offering properties like exceptional softness, moisture control, and compressive support. They feel luxurious against the skin and maintain their shape, color, and integrity over time.

Old Navy uses a standard polyester/elastane blend. While comfortable and stretchy, these materials don't offer the same level of performance. They are less effective at managing sweat during intense exercise and are more prone to pilling or losing shape after repeated washing compared to Lululemon's high-tech textiles.

Fit & Sizing

Lululemon is known for its meticulous and consistent sizing. Their leggings are designed to contour the body, offering a structured, supportive fit that stays put during any activity, from yoga inversions to long runs. The high-rise waistbands are particularly popular for their comfort and secure feel.

Old Navy aims for a more general, comfortable fit that is true to size for the average shopper. While perfectly adequate for casual wear, the fit can be less precise. Some customers report inconsistencies in sizing between different designs, and the fabric may not offer the same "hugged" sensation or support found in a Lululemon pair.

Style & Aesthetics

Lululemon excels in creating sleek, modern activewear that doubles as fashionable athleisure. The brand offers a wide array of on-trend colors, patterns, and subtle details like reflective accents or unique seam placements that create a flattering silhouette.

Old Navy’s designs are more simple and functional. They primarily offer basic solids like black, gray, and navy, with some seasonal colors mixed in. The style is classic and practical, focusing more on versatility for everyday life than on making a fashion statement.

Which One Should You Choose?

The right choice comes down to your budget, performance needs, and how often you'll be wearing them.

Choose Old Navy if:

• Your budget is your most important consideration.
• You need comfortable pants for errands, lounging, or low-impact activities like walking.
• You're just starting your fitness journey and aren't ready to invest in premium gear.
• You appreciate the ability to easily purchase staple pieces during frequent sales.

Choose Lululemon if:

• Performance, fit, and durability are your main concerns.
• You practice yoga, run, or do high-intensity workouts regularly.
• You are willing to invest in premium activewear that will last for years.
• You value a sleek, flattering aesthetic and high-quality feel in your athletic clothes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the main difference between Old Navy and Lululemon compression pants?

The primary difference is the trade-off between price and performance. Old Navy is an affordable, casual option with basic materials, while Lululemon is a premium brand using advanced technical fabrics designed for high performance, a perfect fit, and long-term durability, all at a much higher price.

Are Old Navy compression pants good for working out?

They are suitable for light workouts like walking, stretching, or low-impact strength training. For more intense activities like running, HIIT, or hot yoga, they may lack the moisture-wicking capabilities and compressive support of higher-performance brands.

Is Lululemon worth the price?

For many fitness enthusiasts, yes. The high price tag reflects superior materials, a precision fit, and exceptional durability. If you wear activewear frequently and require reliable performance, the long-term value of a Lululemon product is often worth the initial investment.

How does sizing compare between Old Navy and Lululemon?

Old Navy uses standard lettered sizing (XS-XXL) and generally fits true to size, but can be inconsistent. Lululemon uses numerical sizing (0-14+) which allows for a more precise, body-contouring fit that is highly consistent across its product line.

Do Old Navy leggings pill?

Like many leggings made from standard polyester blends, Old Navy leggings can be prone to pilling over time with frequent wear and washing, particularly in high-friction areas. Washing them inside out and air drying can help prolong their life.

How long do Lululemon leggings last?

With proper care, Lululemon leggings are known to last for years, even with regular use. The brand's high-quality fabrics are engineered to resist stretching out, fading, and pilling better than most competitors.

Which brand is better for casual, everyday wear?

Both are great, but Old Navy is often the more practical choice for everyday wear due to its much lower price. You can wear them for errands and lounging without worrying about wear and tear on an expensive item.

Which brand has better style options?

Lululemon offers more fashion-forward and trend-focused styles, with a wider variety of unique colors, patterns, and flattering designs. Old Navy sticks to more basic and classic styles.