Madewell vs. All Saints Leather Jacket: Which one should you buy?

The Madewell leather jacket offers a timeless, classic style with buttery-soft leather and minimal hardware, positioning it as an approachable, versatile staple for everyday wear. In contrast, the All Saints leather jacket is a statement piece known for its edgy, rebellious aesthetic, featuring distressed finishes, slim fits, and signature metal hardware. The primary difference comes down to aesthetics and price: Madewell is classic and more affordable, while All Saints is fashion-forward and a bigger investment.

Here’s everything you need to know to decide which iconic leather jacket belongs in your closet.

Madewell Leather Jackets

Madewell's leather jackets are the embodiment of the brand's effortless, laid-back style. Designed as go-to wardrobe essentials, they feature clean lines, high-quality materials, and a fit that feels both comfortable and polished. They skip the heavy hardware and distressed details in favor of timeless silhouettes that work just as well over a floral dress as they do with jeans and a t-shirt.

• What it is: A collection of classic, minimalist leather jackets designed for versatility and timeless appeal.
• Key features: Buttery-soft leather, simple and minimal hardware, classic moto or bomber silhouettes, and a focus on comfortable fit.
• Price: $300 - $500
• Materials/Construction: Crafted from high-quality, often full-grain leather, with an emphasis on sustainable and responsible sourcing.
• Sizing/Fit: Tends to be true to standard US sizing, offering a fit that is structured but not overly restrictive. Typically designed for easy layering.
• Pros: Highly versatile for work, weekends, and evenings out. More affordable price point for genuine leather. Strong focus on sustainability. Timeless design that won't go out of style.
• Cons: Lacks the edgy, statement-making details of its competitors. The designs are classic but may feel too simple for those seeking a more distinctive look.

This jacket is for the person seeking a reliable, high-quality, and understated leather piece that can be worn for years across countless occasions.

Shop this product: https://www.madewell.com/womens/clothing/jackets/leather

All Saints Leather Jackets

An All Saints leather jacket is an icon in the world of fashion, representing a cool, urban, and modern edge. Known for their moody color palettes and rock-and-roll vibe, these jackets are designed to be statement pieces. They often feature asymmetrical zippers, distressed finishes, and form-fitting silhouettes that add an instant dose of attitude to any outfit.

• What it is: A range of edgy, premium leather jackets celebrated for their distinctive details and rebellious spirit.
• Key features: Signature asymmetrical zip closures, distressed and washed leathers, branded metal hardware, and slim-fitting silhouettes.
• Price: $500 - $1,200
• Materials/Construction: Made from premium leathers, such as lambskin and cowhide, often with unique distressed finishes designed to look better with age.
• Sizing/Fit: Known for a slim, close-to-the-body fit. While true to size, many shoppers prefer to size up for more room or for layering over sweaters.
• Pros: Immediately recognizable statement style. Exceptional craftsmanship and premium materials. Designs are fashion-forward and unique. The leather ages beautifully, developing unique character.
• Cons: Significantly higher price point. The slim fit might not be comfortable for all body types. The edgy aesthetic can be less versatile for professional or formal settings.

This jacket is for the fashion-forward individual who views their leather jacket as a core statement piece and is willing to invest in a distinctive, high-end design.

Shop this product: https://www.allsaints.com/women/leathers/

Madewell vs. All Saints Leather Jacket Comparison

Style & Aesthetic

The core difference between these two brands lies in their design philosophy. Madewell champions a timeless, American classic aesthetic. Their leather jackets are clean and understated, using minimal hardware to let the material and cut speak for themselves. This makes them incredibly versatile - a Madewell jacket fits in seamlessly at the office, a weekend brunch, or a casual dinner.

All Saints, on the other hand, is defined by its British-cool, rebellious vibe. Their jackets are intentionally edgy, featuring signature details like industrial zippers, quilted shoulder panels, and distressed finishes. An All Saints jacket is not just an outer layer, it’s the focal point of an outfit, designed to communicate a confident, fashion-forward attitude.

Quality & Materials

Both brands use high-quality leather, but they treat it very differently. Madewell opts for soft, supple leathers that feel comfortable from the first wear. The finish is typically smooth and consistent, intended to be a beautiful, lasting material that wears in gently over time.

All Saints specializes in leather with character. Many of their jackets feature intentionally distressed, washed, or vintage-inspired finishes that give the garment a worn-in look right off the rack. This leather is designed to age dramatically, developing more texture, creases, and personality with every wear, which is a major part of its appeal.

Fit & Sizing

Fit is another key differentiator. Madewell leather jackets generally follow standard US sizing and offer a more relaxed, comfortable fit suitable for layering. While they are tailored, they aren't designed to be skin-tight, prioritizing practicality and ease of movement.

In contrast, the classic All Saints leather jacket is known for its signature slim silhouette. The arms are often cut narrow and the body is meant to be close-fitting. Many shoppers choose to size up, especially if they plan to wear anything thicker than a t-shirt underneath. It's a structured, sharp fit that contributes to its edgy look.

Price & Value

Madewell offers what could be considered accessible luxury. Priced between $300 and $500, its jackets represent a solid value for genuine leather from a reputable brand with a focus on sustainable practices. For someone buying their first leather jacket or seeking a versatile staple, Madewell provides great quality for the price.

All Saints operates in a higher price bracket, with most jackets ranging from $500 to over $1,200. This price reflects its status as a premium fashion brand, the unique distressed finishes, and the statement design elements. It's an investment piece, and its value is found in its distinctive style and the character it develops over its long lifespan.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both brands produce excellent leather jackets, but they serve very different tastes and priorities.

Choose Madewell if:

• You want a timeless, versatile jacket you can wear almost anywhere.
• Your personal style is more classic, casual, and understated.
• You need a jacket that is comfortable and easy to layer over sweaters.
• Your budget is under $500, but you still want high-quality, genuine leather.
• Supporting brands with a strong focus on sustainability is important to you.

Choose All Saints if:

• You want your leather jacket to be a bold, edgy statement piece.
• You love distressed details, hardware, and a rock-and-roll aesthetic.
• You prefer a sharp, slim silhouette and don't mind a close fit.
• You are looking for an investment piece that will gain character with age.
• You are willing to spend more for a unique, fashion-forward design.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the main difference between a Madewell and All Saints leather jacket?

The main difference is the overall aesthetic. Madewell jackets are classic, minimalist, and versatile, featuring soft leather and simple designs. All Saints jackets are edgy, fashion-forward statement pieces known for distressed finishes, distinctive hardware, and a much sharper, slimmer fit.

Do All Saints jackets run small?

Yes, many people find that All Saints leather jackets run small, particularly in the arms and across the shoulders, due to their signature slim-fit design. It is common to size up, especially if you plan on layering it over anything thicker than a light shirt.

How do I know my size in a Madewell leather jacket?

Madewell jackets generally run true to standard US sizing. They are designed for a more comfortable, slightly relaxed fit to allow for layering. Your usual size in jackets or blazers should be a good starting point.

Are All Saints jackets worth the money?

For those who love the edgy, rebellious aesthetic and appreciate high-quality materials designed to age well, an All Saints jacket is often considered a worthwhile investment. The price reflects not just the leather quality but the unique design vision and brand prestige.

Which jacket is more versatile?

The Madewell leather jacket is undoubtedly more versatile. Its classic design and minimal hardware allow it to be dressed up or down easily and worn for a wider range of occasions, including more professional settings.

Which brand is better for a first leather jacket?

For most people, Madewell is a better choice for a first leather jacket. Its timeless style, versatility, and more accessible price point make it a safer, more practical investment that you can wear for years.

Do Madewell or All Saints jackets go on sale?

Yes, both brands have sales. Madewell frequently includes its leather jackets in seasonal promotions or end-of-season sales. All Saints also has sale periods, but their most iconic leather jacket styles are often excluded or sell out quickly, so you may have to wait for the right moment.

How do I care for my leather jacket?

For both brands, it's recommended to spot clean with a damp cloth for minor spills. For a deeper clean, take it to a professional leather cleaner. Condition the leather annually with a high-quality leather conditioner to keep it soft and prevent it from drying out or cracking.