Hermès Rouge Casaque vs. Rouge Garance: What's the difference?

The Hermès Rouge Casaque and Rouge Garance are both iconic red lipsticks, but they serve two distinct looks. Rouge Casaque is a vibrant, warm red with a clear orange undertone that feels modern and energetic, while Rouge Garance is a timeless, cool-toned classic red with a subtle blue undertone for a more traditional and sophisticated finish.

Here's everything you need to know to decide which signature red is the right one for you.

Hermès Rouge Casaque

Rouge Casaque is a confident and lively red inspired by the riding jackets central to Hermès' equestrian heritage. Its warm, slightly orange-leaning hue makes a bold statement, offering a bright pop of color that feels both modern and sophisticated. This is the red you choose when you want to look energetic and stylish.

• What it is: A warm-toned, vibrant red lipstick with a comfortable semi-matte finish.
• Key features: Rich pigmentation, creamy application, hydrating formula, and long-lasting color. It comes in a luxurious and refillable color-blocked metal case.
• Price: Around $75
• Finish & Texture: The finish is primarily matte but with a slight luminosity that prevents it from looking flat or dry. The texture is creamy and glides on smoothly without pulling.
• Pros: Excellent for warm and neutral skin tones, its brightness makes teeth appear whiter, provides a modern twist on a classic red, comfortable formula for all-day wear.
• Cons: High price point, the strong orange undertone may not flatter very cool-toned skin, might be too bold for minimalists.

This shade is perfect for anyone seeking a vibrant, energetic red with a contemporary edge, especially those with warm complexions.

Shop this product: hermes.com/us/en/product/lipstick-rouge-casaque-101/

Hermès Rouge Garance

Rouge Garance draws its name from the historic French "garance" red dye, signifying tradition and richness. This shade is the quintessential classic red with a subtle blue undertone, making it universally flattering and deeply elegant. It's a truly timeless color that evokes glamour and refined taste, suitable for any occasion that calls for a touch of polish.

• What it is: A classic, cool-toned red lipstick with a hydrating satin finish.
• Key features: Smooth application, vibrant yet classic hue, moisturizing formula, and a polished look housed in the signature refillable case.
• Price: Around $75
• Finish & Texture: A soft satin finish that provides a healthy, subtle sheen. The texture is exceptionally smooth and creamy, feeling nourishing on the lips.
• Pros: Universally flattering on a wide variety of skin tones, a true classic red for any occasion, comfortable satin finish is hydrating, exudes timeless elegance.
• Cons: A luxury splurge, may feel too traditional for those who prefer bolder, trend-forward makeup looks.

It's an ideal choice for someone looking for a dependable, always-appropriate red that delivers sophistication and poise.

Shop this product: hermes.com/us/en/product/lipstick-rouge-garance-102/

Hermès Rouge Casaque vs. Rouge Garance Comparison

Shade & Undertone

The primary difference between these two shades lies in their undertone. Rouge Casaque has a distinct orange base, making it a warm and bright red. This gives it a lively, modern-leaning personality that grabs attention.

On the other hand, Rouge Garance is formulated with a cool, blue undertone. This composition makes it appear as a more classic, "true" red. The blue base adds depth and a certain elegance that is incredibly versatile and traditionally seen as flattering for brightening the complexion.

Finish & Texture

Beyond color, the finishes also set these two lipsticks apart. Rouge Casaque offers a semi-matte finish. This means it has a mostly shine-free appearance but doesn't feel drying like many traditional mattes, thanks to its creamy and hydrating formula. It provides a modern, velvety look on the lips.

Rouge Garance features a classic satin finish. This imparts a subtle, healthy-looking sheen that gives the illusion of fuller, more hydrated lips. The texture is exceptionally buttery and smooth, prioritizing comfort and a polished look over a completely matte effect.

Price & Value

Both Rouge Casaque and Rouge Garance are priced identically, reflecting their position within the Hermès beauty collection. The value for both products comes from the exceptionally high quality of the formula, the luxurious weight and design of the packaging, and the option for sustainability via refillable lipstick bullets. The decision between the two isn't about which is a better deal, but which color and finish best suits your personal needs.

Who Each One Works Best For

Your choice will largely depend on your skin's undertone and personal style. Rouge Casaque truly shines on individuals with warm or neutral skin tones. If your veins appear greenish and you look best in gold jewelry, this bright, warm red will beautifully complement your complexion. It’s perfect for someone with a bold, modern style who isn't afraid of a vibrant pop of color.

Rouge Garance is considered more universally flattering due to its blue undertones, which tend to look good on almost everyone, particularly those with cool or neutral skin tones. If your veins look blue and you gravitate toward silver jewelry, this shade will naturally suit you. It’s the superior choice for someone seeking a timeless, foolproof red for professional settings, formal events, or simply an elegant everyday lipstick.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both are exceptional lipsticks, but they cater to different preferences and complexions.

Choose Rouge Casaque if:

• You have a warm or neutral skin tone that is complemented by orange-based colors.
• You want a lipstick that makes a bright, confident, and energetic statement.
• You prefer a comfortable semi-matte finish without the typical dryness.
• Your style is modern, bold, and you love a vibrant pop of color.

Choose Rouge Garance if:

• You're looking for a classic, universally flattering red.
• You have a cool or neutral undertone that pairs well with blue-based reds.
• You prefer a hydrating satin finish with a hint of natural sheen.
• You need a sophisticated, go-to red versatile enough for a job interview or a formal gala.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the main difference between Rouge Casaque and Rouge Garance?

The core difference is the undertone. Rouge Casaque is a warm, orange-based vibrant red, while Rouge Garance is a cool, blue-based classic red. This also impacts their finish, Rouge Casaque is semi-matte, and Rouge Garance is satin.

Which Hermès red is better for warm skin tones?

With its noticeable orange undertones, Rouge Casaque is generally the more flattering and harmonious choice for warm skin tones.

Which Hermès red is better for cool skin tones?

The blue base in Rouge Garance makes it a fantastic fit for cool-toned complexions, as it brightens the skin without clashing.

Do these lipsticks have different finishes?

Yes. Rouge Casaque has a modern semi-matte finish, which is mostly shine-free but remains comfortable. Rouge Garance has a classic satin finish, which offers a subtle, luxurious sheen.

Are Hermès lipsticks worth the price?

For many beauty enthusiasts, the price is justified by the combination of a high-performance, comfortable formula, the luxurious feel of the packaging, and the environmental benefit of the refillable system. It is positioned as a piece of usable art rather than just a cosmetic product.

How long do Hermès lipsticks last on the lips?

Both shades offer good longevity due to their rich pigmentation. While they are not transfer-proof and will require reapplication after a meal, they wear comfortably for several hours without needing a touch-up.

Are the Hermès lipstick cases refillable?

Yes. A standout feature of the Hermès beauty line is its commitment to sustainability. Once you own the magnetic metal case, you can purchase lipstick refills in any shade, reducing waste.

Which shade is more versatile?

Rouge Garance is often considered more versatile. As a classic red, its timeless elegance makes it appropriate for nearly any setting - from professional meetings to glamorous evenings - and its cool undertone is widely flattering.