Hermès In the Loop vs. Picotin: Which one should you buy?

The Hermès In the Loop and Picotin both epitomize the quiet luxury of Hermès, but they cater to very different styles. The In the Loop is a modern and versatile option defined by its sleek silhouette and distinctive metal ring detail that allows for multiple carrying styles, whereas the Picotin is a timeless, unstructured bucket bag known for its minimalist elegance and more accessible price point.

Here’s everything you need to know to decide which of these coveted handbags is the right one for you.

Hermès In the Loop Bag

The Hermès In the Loop is a contemporary handbag that blends modern functionality with the brand’s signature craftsmanship. Its clean lines, sophisticated hardware, and versatile design make it a standout piece for the fashion-forward consumer who needs a bag that can transition effortlessly from day to night.

• What it is: A structured, modern handbag featuring a distinctive metal ring as its central design and functional element.
• Key features: Sleek aesthetic, secure closure, and versatile carrying options including handheld, shoulder, and crossbody.
• Price: Approximately $3,500 to $4,500, depending on the specific size and leather.
• Materials/Construction: Crafted from premium leathers like Swift, Togo, or Epsom, with meticulously finished, high-quality metal hardware that is central to its design.
• Sizing/Fit: Often found in medium sizes, around 25-30cm wide, making it perfectly suited for carrying daily essentials without being overly cumbersome.
• Pros: A secure top keeps belongings safe. Offers multiple ways to carry, adding to its versatility. The modern, sleek design feels fresh and distinctive.
• Cons: A more trend-aware design might feel less timeless to classic style purists. It comes at a higher price point than the Picotin.

This bag suits the modern individual who values high-fashion design, security, and the flexibility of multiple carrying styles.

Shop this product: hermes.com/us/en/product/in-the-loop-bag-

Hermès Picotin Bag

The Hermès Picotin is a classic, understated bucket tote that celebrates simplicity and the beauty of high-quality leather. Inspired by horse feed bags, its unstructured shape and minimalist design have made it an enduring favorite for those who appreciate effortless, everyday luxury.

• What it is: A lightweight, unlined bucket bag with an open-top silhouette, typically secured with a single leather strap and the iconic Kelly lock.
• Key features: Minimalist design, simple open-top access, sturdy construction, and available in a range of sizes.
• Price: Starts at around $2,600 for the smallest 18cm size and can exceed $4,000 for larger sizes or more exotic materials.
• Materials/Construction: Usually made from durable, grainy leathers like Clemence or Togo, which are known for their slouchy but resilient nature and resistance to scratches.
• Sizing/Fit: Available in several sizes, most commonly 18cm and 22cm. The 18 size is perfect for essentials, while the 22 gracefully accommodates more.
• Pros: Timeless design that never goes out of fashion. A more accessible entry point for new Hermès clients. Lightweight and easy to carry for daily wear.
• Cons: Open-top design offers less security for your belongings. Unstructured shape may not appeal to those who prefer more organized bags. Primarily a handheld or elbow-carry bag.

The Picotin is perfect for lovers of classic, minimalist style looking for a versatile and practical luxury tote.

Shop this product: hermes.com/us/en/product/picotin-18/

Hermès In the Loop vs. Picotin Comparison

Style & Aesthetic

The most significant difference lies in their overall style. The In the Loop is decidedly modern. Its clean, structured form with polished metal imparts a sense of contemporary sophistication - a bag that aligns with current trends while retaining a sense of luxury.

In contrast, the Picotin is the definition of timelessness. Its simple, unadorned silhouette exudes a casual elegance that feels effortless. It’s a bag that doesn't demand attention but is instantly recognizable to those in the know. The Picotin leans classic, while the In the Loop leans contemporary.

Functionality & Versatility

Functionally, the two bags serve very different needs. The In the Loop is built for secure, adaptable daily use. Its secure closure gives peace of mind, and the ability to wear it handheld, on the shoulder, or crossbody is a huge advantage for anyone who needs to be hands-free. This is a more "active" bag for commuting or busy days.

The Picotin is a much simpler tote. Its open top makes grabbing a wallet or phone incredibly easy, which is great for quick errands. However, this same feature offers less security in crowded environments. It’s almost exclusively a top-handle bag, carried in hand or the crook of the arm, making it suitable for a more relaxed pace of life.

Price & Value

The Picotin is generally the more affordable option, with the popular 18 size starting around $2,600. It is considered an "entry-level" piece in the world of Hermès handbags, making it a great choice for a newer collector. Due to its classic status, it holds its value exceptionally well on the resale market.

The In the Loop is positioned at a higher price bracket, typically beginning around $3,500. The cost reflects its more complex construction, additional hardware, and versatile design. While both bags are solid investments, the Picotin's lower entry price proves its enduring appeal as a foundational piece in a designer collection.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both bags are excellent representations of Hermès craftsmanship, but your choice will come down to personal style, daily needs, and budget.

Choose the Hermès In the Loop if:

• You prefer contemporary, fashion-forward designs over traditional classics.
• You need a secure bag that fully closes to protect your belongings.
• Versatility is key, and you want the option to wear your bag crossbody or on your shoulder.
• You appreciate distinctive hardware and a more structured silhouette.

Choose the Hermès Picotin if:

• You gravitate toward timeless, minimalist, and understated elegance.
• You are looking for a more accessible entry into owning an Hermès handbag.
• You prioritize a lightweight feel and easy access to your items for daily use.
• You prefer a slouchy, casual shape and mostly carry your bags by hand or on your arm.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between the In the Loop and the Picotin?

The main difference is style and function. The In the Loop is a modern, structured bag with a secure closure and multiple carrying options (shoulder, crossbody). The Picotin is a classic, timeless, and unstructured bucket tote with an open top meant for handheld use. The In the Loop is more fashion-forward and versatile, whereas the Picotin is praised for its minimalism and everyday ease of use.

Which Hermès bag is a better investment?

Both handbags hold their value very well because they are from Hermès. The Picotin, as a longstanding classic, has a proven track record of maintaining and often increasing its value over time. The In the Loop, being newer, still enjoys a very strong demand, but its long-term investment performance is less established compared to the Picotin.

Is the Hermès Picotin secure?

The Picotin has an open-top design secured only by a thin leather strap and a lock. While perfect for quick access, it is less secure than a bag with a full zipper or flap closure like the In the Loop. It is ideal for people who aren't in crowded environments. Many owners use purse organizers to provide more security and give it structure.

Can the In the Loop bag be worn crossbody?

Yes, one of the signature features of the In the Loop bag is its versatility. The strap is typically long enough to be worn comfortably on the shoulder or crossbody, making it an excellent choice for those who need a hands-free option.

Is the Picotin a popular bag?

The Picotin bag is known to retain its value on the resale market because of its timelessness and enduring popularity. It's often one of their more frequently sought-after bags. It's especially popular among people who prefer the quiet luxury trend and low-key designer items that won't make a scene.

Which leather is best for these bags?

For the Picotin, Clemence and Togo are very popular choices. Both are durable, scratch-resistant leathers that develop a beautiful slouch over time. The In the Loop is often seen in various leathers to highlight their design: Swift (smooth and fine-grained) or Togo for durability.

How difficult is it to buy an Hermès bag from the boutique?

It can be very difficult. Hermès often has extremely high demand and low inventory, so having a good relationship with a sales associate will give you a much better chance of acquiring your preferred style. It's often easier and faster to purchase them on the pre-owned market if you don't mind paying the extra premium price.

Is the Picotin bag heavy?

No, one of the lightest features of the Picotin is that it's an incredibly lightweight bag given it doesn't have much hardware and no lining. This makes it a good everyday carrier when you don’t want to deal with a large, heavy tote.