Hermès Constance vs. Kelly: Which one is better?

The Hermès Kelly and the Hermès Constance are two of the most sought-after handbags in the world, differing primarily in style and function. The Kelly is a timeless top-handle bag with a trapezoidal shape and a discreet turn-lock closure, offering classic elegance and versatility for formal or casual wear. In contrast, the Constance is a modern shoulder bag with a boxier shape defined by its bold 'H' clasp, providing a more contemporary, hands-free experience.

Here’s everything you need to know to decide which iconic Hermès bag is the right investment for you.

Hermès Constance

The Hermès Constance is a masterpiece of modern, minimalist design. Known for its clean lines, rectangular shape, and statement-making 'H' front clasp, the Constance is a sophisticated shoulder bag that blends high fashion with everyday functionality. It features an adjustable leather strap that allows it to be worn on the shoulder or, for some sizes and body types, as a crossbody bag.

• What it is: A structured shoulder bag featuring a prominent 'H' shaped clasp, flap closure, and an adjustable strap designed for shoulder or crossbody wear.
• Key features: Signature H-clasp, adjustable flat leather strap, simple and clean rectangular silhouette, available in various sizes and gusset options.
• Price: Generally starts from $9,000 to $12,000 for standard leather and increases significantly for exotic skins.
• Materials/Construction: Handcrafted by a single artisan using fine leathers like Epsom, Boxcalf, or Swift, as well as premium exotic skins.
• Sizing/Fit: Commonly found in sizes 18cm (Mini), 24cm, and the longer Elan. The adjustable strap makes it convenient for on-the-go, hands-free wear.
• Pros: Modern and chic aesthetic. The hands-free design is highly practical for daily use. Recognizable yet elegant branding with the 'H' clasp. Easy-to-access closure system.
• Cons: The striking 'H' hardware can feel too bold for some. Its flatter profile limits what it can carry compared to the Kelly. Finding one at a boutique can be incredibly difficult.

This bag is perfect for the fashion-forward individual who values minimalist design, brand identity, and the practicality of a hands-free shoulder bag.

Shop this product: hermes.com/us/en/women/bags-and-clutches

Hermès Kelly

An icon of timeless elegance, the Hermès Kelly bag is defined by its clean, trapezoidal silhouette, single top handle, and distinctive closure featuring two leather straps ('sangles'), a turn-lock, and a padlock. Originally named after Grace Kelly, this bag exudes sophistication and can seamlessly transition from business meetings to formal events. The included detachable shoulder strap adds a layer of versatility to its formal structure.

• What it is: A highly structured top-handle bag with a formal, trapezoidal shape, turn-lock closure system, and an optional shoulder strap.
• Key features: Single top handle, detachable shoulder strap, secure turn-lock and sangles closure, clochette with keys for the included padlock. Available in two styles: Sellier (rigid, with sharp edges) and Retourne (softer, with rounded edges).
• Price: Typically starts around $10,000 for basic leather models and can well exceed $50,000 for rare editions or exotic materials.
• Materials/Construction: Meticulously handcrafted from premium leathers like Togo, Epsom, and Clémence, along with a wide range of exotic skins like crocodile, lizard, and ostrich.
• Sizing/Fit: Comes in a variety of sizes, from the tiny Kelly 20 to the larger Kelly 35. It is usually carried by its top handle, in the crook of the arm, or on the shoulder.
• Pros: Extremely versatile form that works for nearly any occasion. Considered one of the best investment handbags and holds its value exceptionally well. Classic, understated, and eternally stylish.
• Cons: The sangles and turn-lock closure can be slow to open and close, making it less practical for quick access. The starting price point is higher than the Constance. Can be top-heavy depending on size and what you carry.

The Kelly is an ideal choice for someone seeking a supremely versatile, classic, and iconic bag that functions as both a statement piece and a sound financial investment.

Shop this product: hermes.com/us/en/women/bags-and-clutches

Hermès Constance vs. Hermès Kelly Comparison

Style & Aesthetic

The primary difference lies in their aesthetic. The Kelly bag offers a classic, poised elegance. Its structured top-handle design channels a polished, ladylike feel reminiscent of its namesake, Grace Kelly. It's the definition of understated luxury - perfect for formal gatherings, business settings, and sophisticated daily wear.

The Constance, on the other hand, projects a modern, fashion-forward attitude. Its boxy silhouette and impossible-to-miss 'H' clasp make a confident style statement. It feels younger and more relaxed, aligning perfectly with contemporary luxury trends where branding and ease-of-wear are key.

Versatility & Functionality

In terms of versatility, the Kelly arguably has the edge. With its combination of a top handle and a detachable shoulder strap, it can be styled as a formal handbag, carried on the crook of the arm, or worn on the shoulder for a more relaxed look. This adaptability makes it suitable for almost any event, from a gala to a grocery run. Its biggest functional drawback is its multi-step closure, which can be cumbersome.

The Constance is the champion of practical, hands-free luxury. As a dedicated shoulder or crossbody bag, it allows for complete freedom of movement, making it ideal for shopping, travel, or busy days out. The 'H' clasp is also significantly faster to open and close than the Kelly’s sangles, scoring points for everyday convenience.

Price & Investment Value

Both bags are considered premier "investment bags," meaning they often retain or even appreciate in value over time. The Hermès Kelly typically has a higher starting price than the Constance in comparable leather and size. On the resale market, both bags command remarkable prices, often selling for well above their original retail cost.

Due to its legendary status, the Kelly is perhaps the safer long-term investment, with decades of proven value appreciation. However, the rarity and high demand for the Constance, particularly in popular sizes and colors, also make it an exceptionally strong performer on the secondary market.

Who Each One Works Best For

Choosing between them truly comes down to your personal style and needs. The Kelly is for the classicist who values timeless design and maximal versatility. It's for someone who attends a range of events and wants one sublime bag that can do it all while symbolizing refined taste.

The Constance is for the modernist. It's for the person with a confident, contemporary style who prioritizes hands-free convenience and isn't afraid of a bold logo statement. If your lifestyle calls for a chic, on-the-go bag that stands out, the Constance is a perfect match.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both handcrafted bags are incredible pieces of artistry from Hermès, but they serve different lifestyles and style preferences.

Choose the Hermès Constance if:

• You prioritize a hands-free, on-the-go experience.
• Your personal style is modern, minimalist, and chic.
• You want a bag with a quick and easy-to-use closure.
• You appreciate recognizable luxury branding that makes a statement.

Choose the Hermès Kelly if:

• You need a versatile bag that can transition from day to evening and casual to formal.
• You prefer timeless, classic designs with a rich history.
• You value the elegant look of a top-handle bag.
• Your main goal is to acquire a premier investment piece with proven long-term value.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the main difference between the Hermès Kelly and Constance?

The chief difference is design and how the bag is worn. The Hermès Kelly is a classic top-handle bag with a detachable shoulder strap and a discreet turn-lock closure. The Hermès Constance is a modern shoulder bag defined by its large 'H' clasp and is designed for hands-free wear.

Which Hermès bag is more expensive?

Generally, the Kelly has a higher starting retail price than the Constance for a comparable size and standard leather. However, prices for both can vary dramatically based on the material, size, and hardware.

Which bag holds its value better?

Both are top-tier investment bags that hold their value exceptionally well. The Kelly has a longer history as a collector's item and is often seen as a benchmark for handbag investments. The Constance is also highly coveted and its rarity can drive its resale value just as high, if not higher in some cases.

Is the Kelly or Constance more practical for everyday use?

This depends on your definition of practical. The Constance is more practical for quick access and hands-free convenience. The Kelly is more practical in terms of versatility, as it can be styled for more occasions and often offers more interior space in comparable sizes.

Which one is harder to get in an Hermès boutique?

Both are considered "quota bags" and are notoriously difficult to purchase directly from an Hermès boutique. Which one is harder to obtain can depend on the specific boutique, your relationship with a Sales Associate, and current stock. For many, the Constance is perceived as being even rarer than a Kelly.

Which size is the most popular for each bag?

For the Kelly, the 25cm and 28cm sizes are currently the most popular, as they are versatile enough for both day and night. For the Constance, the Mini (18cm) and the 24cm are the most sought-after sizes.

Can the Hermès Constance be worn as a crossbody bag?

Yes, the Constance's adjustable strap often allows it to be worn as a crossbody, especially for the Mini 18 size. However, the fit will depend on the wearer’s height and proportions.

What does Sellier vs. Retourne mean for the Kelly bag?

These terms refer to the bag’s construction. "Sellier" means the stitching is on the outside, creating sharp, rigid edges and a very structured, formal look. "Retourne" means the bag was stitched and then turned inside out, resulting in softer, rounded edges and a more relaxed feel.