Everlane Day Glove Tan vs. Caramel: What's the difference?

The Everlane Day Glove in Tan and Caramel are two timeless neutrals, but they serve different style purposes. The 'Tan' is a light, warm beige that offers an understated, classic look for minimalist wardrobes, while the 'Caramel' is a richer, warmer brown that provides more depth and sophistication, standing out as a polished accent color.

Here is a complete look at both shades to help you decide which is the right one for your wardrobe.

Everlane Day Glove in Tan

The Day Glove in Tan is the quintessential light neutral flat, designed for those who favor a soft, clean aesthetic. Its light beige tone evokes a natural leather look that pairs effortlessly with a wide range of colors, making it a highly versatile choice for everyday wear.

• What it is: A sleek, form-fitting ballet flat made from soft leather, presented in a light, neutral beige color.
• Key features: Full-grain leather upper, cushioned insole, flexible sole, side vents for breathability, and a rubber outsole for grip.
• Price: Around $150–$200
• Aesthetic &, Color: A light, warm beige that looks clean and minimalist. It's an understated color that complements rather than competes with an outfit.
• Styling &, Versatility: Pairs exceptionally well with light-wash denim, white jeans, pastels, and linens. It's an ideal choice for spring, summer, and transitional seasons.
• Pros: Extremely versatile and timeless, molds to your foot for a custom fit, breathable design for all-day wear, easily complements light and monochrome palettes.
• Cons: As a lighter color, it is more prone to showing dirt, scuffs, and watermarks, requires more careful and frequent maintenance to keep it looking pristine.

This shoe is ideal for someone seeking a go-to everyday neutral that blends seamlessly into a minimalist or light-colored wardrobe.

Shop this product: www.everlane.com/collections/day-glove

Everlane Day Glove in Caramel

The Everlane Day Glove in Caramel offers a warmer and richer alternative to the classic nude flat. This deeper brown shade carries a sophisticated weight, making it a great accent piece that adds warmth and polish to both casual and professional looks.

• What it is: The same best-selling minimalist flat from Everlane, offered in a rich, warm brown leather.
• Key features: Molds-to-your-foot full-grain leather, cushioned interior, sleek low-profile silhouette, and rubber outsole.
• Price: Around $150–$200
• Aesthetic &, Color: A mid-tone brown with warm, golden undertones. The color is more saturated and noticeable than Tan, giving it a polished and slightly autumnal feel.
• Styling &, Versatility: Works beautifully with earth tones, jewel tones, dark-wash denim, and classic office wear. It provides a warm contrast to crisp whites and blues.
• Pros: The rich hue adds an element of sophistication, is more forgiving of minor scuffs and marks, transitions well into fall and winter wardrobes, and ages with a beautiful character.
• Cons: Can feel slightly less versatile for breezy summer outfits compared to Tan, may be too warm-toned for those with primarily cool-toned wardrobes.

This color is perfect for those who wear earthy or deep colors and want a sophisticated neutral that adds warmth and depth to an outfit.

Shop this product: www.everlane.com/collections/day-glove

Everlane Day Glove Tan vs. Caramel Comparison

Color Tone & Aesthetic

The most significant difference between the Tan and Caramel finishes is their visual temperature and depth. The Tan is a light, airy beige with a clean, minimalist feel. It functions as a true neutral that blends in, particularly with light-colored clothing. It creates a soft, approachable look that never feels overpowering.

In contrast, Caramel is a much warmer and deeper shade of brown. It makes more of a statement while still serving as a neutral. Its rich, golden undertones provide a polished and sophisticated feel, adding a touch of warmth that works especially well with autumnal palettes and more formal color schemes.

Versatility & Styling

Both colors are very versatile, but they excel in different areas. Tan is the ultimate chameleon for spring and summer. It pairs perfectly with white dresses, light-wash jeans, pastel tops, and linen trousers. Its light tone prevents it from feeling heavy, making it an ideal choice for warmer months and breezy, casual styles.

Caramel shines with darker and richer color palettes. It's a natural fit for fall fashion - think earth tones, olive green, burgundy, and dark denim. It also elevates office attire, providing a warm and professional contrast to navy suits or black trousers. While you can certainly wear Caramel in the summer, it offers less contrast with very light fabrics compared to Tan.

Wear, Aging & Maintenance

Both shoes are made from the same high-quality, full-grain leather that will soften and develop a patina over time. However, their colors affect how they show wear. The lighter Tan color will show dirt, scuffs, and water stains more visibly, requiring diligent cleaning and conditioning to maintain its appearance.

The darker Caramel color is more forgiving. Minor scuffs and small marks tend to blend into the leather's natural texture, making it a lower-maintenance option for daily city wear. Both shoe colors will age beautifully, but the Caramel will look less worn, for longer, with less effort.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both Everlane Day Glove options are excellent, but your choice depends on your personal style and existing wardrobe.

Choose the Day Glove in Tan if:

• Your wardrobe consists of light colors like whites, creams, pastels, and light-wash denim.
• You want a perfect, understated neutral for spring and summer.
• You prefer a minimalist aesthetic where your shoes blend in seamlessly.
• You are looking for a classic "nude" flat that you can wear with almost anything.

Choose the Day Glove in Caramel if:

• You frequently wear earth tones, jewel tones, or dark denim.
• You're seeking a shoe that adds warmth and richness to your outfits.
• Your style leans more polished, professional, or autumnal.
• You want a durable-looking neutral that is more forgiving to everyday scuffs and marks.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the main difference between Tan and Caramel Day Gloves?

The main difference is the color tone and styling aesthetic. Tan is a light, neutral beige that blends in for a minimalist look, ideal for spring/summer. Caramel is a richer, warmer brown that stands out more, adding polish and depth, especially good for fall/winter and earth-toned wardrobes.

Which color is more versatile?

This is subjective. The Tan is arguably more versatile for year-round wear across all light and bright color palettes. However, the Caramel is extremely versatile within wardrobes that favor earth tones, classic blues, and darker neutrals, and it moves from casual to business-casual settings with ease.

Do Everlane Day Gloves run true to size?

The Day Glove is known to have a snug, glove-like fit. Most customers find they run true to size, but the leather will stretch and mold to your foot with wear. If you are between sizes or have wider feet, you may consider going a half-size up for a more comfortable initial fit.

How do you care for the leather on the Day Gloves?

For both colors, it's recommended to use a high-quality leather cleaner for spots and a leather conditioner to keep the material soft and prevent cracking. Try to protect them from excessive water, as this can cause staining, particularly on the lighter Tan leather.

Does the Tan color stain easily?

As a light-colored leather, Tan is more susceptible to visible stains from dirt and water than Caramel. It's best to treat them with a leather protectant spray before wearing them out to help guard against accidental spills and marks.

Can the Caramel Day Glove be worn in the summer?

Yes, absolutely. While it has an autumnal feel, Caramel can look beautiful in the summer, especially as a warm contrast against a white summer dress or light blue jeans. It offers a more grounded, sophisticated look than a classic light neutral.

Which color ages better?

Both colors age beautifully by developing a natural patina that is unique to how you wear them. The Caramel will hide minor scuffs and marks more effectively over time, potentially looking "newer" for longer compared to the Tan, which will show its wear history more visibly.

Are the Everlane Day Gloves comfortable for walking?

Yes, the Day Glove is known for its exceptional comfort, especially once broken in. The shoe features a cushioned insole and flexible design designed for all-day wear, making it a great choice for commuting or days when you're on your feet a lot.