Everlane 40 Hour Flat vs. Day Glove: Which one should you buy?

The Everlane 40 Hour Flat is a minimalist, round-toe slip-on designed for pure, all-day casual comfort, while the Day Glove offers a more polished, sophisticated look with its pointed toe and structured loafer style. Though both are crafted by Everlane from premium leather, their aesthetics and ideal use cases are quite distinct - one is your go-to weekend and relaxed office shoe, and the other is your refined staple for professional settings.

Here’s everything you need to know to choose the right Everlane flat for your wardrobe.

Everlane 40 Hour Flat

The 40 Hour Flat is designed to feel like you're wearing nothing at all, prioritizing supreme comfort in a simple, effortless slip-on design. Its signature features are a soft, unstructured feel and a classic rounded toe, making it an easy-to-style flat for daily wear, errands, and casual work environments where comfort is the top priority.

• What it is: A minimalist, slip-on flat with a rounded toe, cushioned insole, and flexible rubber sole, crafted for extended wear.
• Key features: Unstructured and lightweight build, cushioned insole for all-day support, flexible construction that moves with your foot.
• Price: Around $135
• Materials/Construction: Made from soft, full-grain leather that is durable, breathable, and designed to gently mold to your foot over time.
• Sizing/Fit: Fits true to size with a slightly relaxed, roomy fit that can comfortably accommodate wider feet.
• Pros: Exceptional all-day comfort right out of the box. Highly versatile for casual and relaxed office outfits. Lightweight and easy to pack for travel. Great for those with wider feet.
• Cons: The unstructured design offers less formal polish. The highly casual look may not be suitable for all professional settings. Minimal arch support for those who need it.

This shoe is perfect for anyone seeking a durable, comfortable, and versatile flat for everyday life, from commutes and errands to relaxed weekends.

Shop this product: https://www.everlane.com/products/40-hour-flat

Everlane Day Glove

The Everlane Day Glove is a modern take on the classic loafer, blending sophisticated style with the comfort of a flat you can wear all day long. Its defining features are the sleek, body-hugging fit, a slightly pointed toe that elongates the leg, and clean lines that provide a polished, put-together look for work and beyond.

• What it is: A sleek, form-fitting flat inspired by traditional loafers, featuring a pointed toe and cushioned insole.
• Key features: Glove-like fit designed to mold to your foot, chic pointed-toe silhouette, back pull tab, side vents for breathability, cushioned insole.
• Price: Around $150
• Materials/Construction: Crafted from buttery-soft Nappa leather that is both supple and resilient, set on a durable leather sole with a rubber out-patch for traction.
• Sizing/Fit: Fits true to size but has a characteristically snug, "glove-like" feel. Its pointed-toe design makes it slightly narrower, so those with very wide feet might consider sizing up a half size.
• Pros: Polished and sophisticated design elevates any outfit. Moves seamlessly from the office to evening outings. Molds to your foot for a custom-like fit. Versatile enough for both professional and refined casual wear.
• Cons: A bit more expensive than the 40 Hour Flat. The snug fit and pointed toe may not be comfortable for wider feet. May require a brief break-in period to feel perfect.

The Day Glove is the ultimate choice for those who need a comfortable yet elevated flat for professional environments or more polished occasions.

Shop this product: https://www.everlane.com/products/day-glove

Everlane 40 Hour Flat vs. Day Glove Comparison

Style & Aesthetic

The most immediate difference between the two shoes is their style. The 40 Hour Flat has a distinctively casual, laid-back aesthetic with its soft structure and rounded toe. It pairs perfectly with jeans, trousers, and casual dresses for a comfortable, understated look.

In contrast, the Day Glove delivers a far more polished and refined vibe. Its pointed toe and sleek, structured silhouette give it a professional edge that works well with tailored suits, work pants, and dressier skirts. While it can be dressed down, its primary strength is in creating a sophisticated, purposeful look.

Fit & Sizing

Fit is a major differentiator. The 40 Hour Flat offers a more relaxed and accommodating fit. Its rounder, wider toe box makes it an excellent choice for people with wider feet or those who prefer a little extra room from day one.

The Day Glove is designed to fit snugly - just like a glove. It hugs the foot for a secure, custom feel. However, because of its pointed toe and narrower profile, it can feel tight on wider feet. Many shoppers with wider feet find sizing up a half size provides the perfect fit, whereas those with narrow-to-average feet typically stick to their regular size.

Price & Value

Both flats represent a solid investment in quality leather footwear. The 40 Hour Flat comes in at approximately $135, making it a slightly more budget-friendly option for an everyday leather shoe. Its value lies in its exceptional comfort and daily-wear durability.

The Day Glove is priced a little higher at around $150, which reflects its more complex construction and refined Nappa leather. Its value comes from its versatility as a polished work shoe that doubles for dressier occasions, potentially replacing multiple other pairs of shoes.

Best Uses & Versatility

Your lifestyle and daily needs will likely determine your best choice. The Everlane 40 Hour Flat is the undisputed champion of daily comfort. It's the shoe you'll reach for on long travel days, a busy day of errands, or in a creative, casual office setting. It's a true workhorse for everyday life.

The Day Glove is more versatile in a professional context. It’s perfect for business casual and even some formal office settings, client meetings, conferences, or any event where you need to look put-together without sacrificing comfort. It bridges the gap between a casual flat and a more formal heel beautifully.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both flats are excellent choices within the Everlane lineup, but they serve different primary purposes.

Choose the 40 Hour Flat if:

• You prioritize all-day walking comfort above all else.
• Your personal style tends to be more casual, relaxed, and minimalist.
• You need a go-to shoe for travel, running errands, and relaxed office days.
• You have wider feet and value a more accommodating fit in the toe box.

Choose the Day Glove if:

• You need a polished, sophisticated flat suitable for a professional workplace.
• Your wardrobe is built around tailored pieces, and you need a shoe to match.
• You're looking for one versatile flat that can take you from workday to dinner out.
• You have average or narrower feet and appreciate a sleek, foot-hugging fit.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the main difference between the Everlane 40 Hour Flat and the Day Glove?

The main difference is style and fit. The 40 Hour Flat has a relaxed, rounded-toe design for casual comfort, while the Day Glove features a sleek, pointed-toe design for a more polished, professional look.

Which Everlane flat is more comfortable?

Both are praised for their comfort. However, the 40 Hour Flat is built with immediate, laid-back comfort in mind, thanks to its soft structure and wider fit. The Day Glove offers structured comfort, molding to your foot over time for a personalized feel that is still very suitable for all-day wear.

Are Everlane flats true to size?

Yes, both styles generally fit true to size. The 40 Hour Flat has a more relaxed fit from the start, while the Day Glove has a snug, glove-like fit that feels narrower due to its pointed toe.

Should I size up for the Everlane Day Glove?

If you have average-to-narrow feet, you should stick with your true size for the intended snug fit. If you have wider feet or are between sizes, consider going up a half size to ensure sufficient room in the toe area.

Which shoe is better for work?

This depends on your office dress code. The Day Glove is the better choice for most corporate, business casual, or formal settings due to its polished appearance. The 40 Hour Flat is a great option for more creative or casual office environments.

Do these shoes require a break-in period?

The 40 Hour Flat feels comfortable and broken-in almost immediately. The Day Glove, being more structured, may require a few wears for the leather to soften and mold perfectly to the shape of your foot.

Is the Everlane 40 Hour Flat good for walking?

Yes, it's an excellent shoe for walking. Its flexible rubber sole, cushioned insole, and lightweight design make it ideal for commuting, travel days, or spending a lot of time on your feet.

How do you care for leather Everlane flats?

To care for both shoes, wipe them clean with a soft, damp cloth. You can use a leather conditioner periodically to keep the leather moisturized and prevent cracking. Avoid prolonged exposure to water.