Let's be real, if you've ever found yourself scrolling through Nerdy Nuts' website at 10 PM trying to decide between Avalanche Toffee Peanut Butter and a limited-edition s'mores flavor, you're in good company. Their wild, dessert-inspired creations have completely changed the nut butter game, turning a simple spread into a crave-worthy treat.
But when you've tried them all or just want to expand your pantry with a few new options, where do you turn? For anyone who loves Nerdy Nuts' commitment to bold flavors and high-quality ingredients, here are 22 other brands worth scooping up.
Justin's is a pantry staple for a reason. While they're famous for their classic, smooth almond and peanut butters, they also offer fun twists like Vanilla Almond Butter and Honey Peanut Butter. Think of Justin's as a reliable, slightly less wild cousin to Nerdy Nuts, perfect for when you want a high-quality, delicious spread that’s grounded in natural flavor.
Shop now at justins.com
If you love the quality of Nerdy Nuts but sometimes crave something simpler, Artisana is for you. This brand specializes in raw, organic nut butters, focusing on the pure, unadulterated flavor of ingredients like cashews, coconuts, and walnuts. It's the go-to for smoothie bowls, baking, and moments when you want a clean, minimalist spread that lets the natural nut taste shine.
Shop now at artisanaorganics.com
Wild Friends strikes a great balance between Nerdy Nuts' playful creativity and a clean-eating mindset. With fun flavors like Maple + Pecan Peanut Butter and Lemon + Coconut Cashew Butter, they deliver on imaginative taste without skimping on the non-GMO, gluten-free ethos. Their fun, colorful packaging and bold flavors make them a natural next step for adventurous eaters.
Shop now at wildfriends.com
For a more grown-up, gourmet experience, check out Harold’s Nut Co. Their small-batch nut butters feature sophisticated flavor profiles like Maple Bacon and Cinnamon Roll. While Nerdy Nuts is fun and whimsical, Harold's feels more artisanal and indulgent, making it the perfect choice for flavor connoisseurs looking for a premium, thoughtfully crafted spread.
Shop now at haroldsnutco.com
Sometimes you just want a pure, delicious peanut butter with zero fuss. Crazy Richard’s is all about that, offering high-quality peanut and almond butters with one ingredient: nuts. They provide the perfect clean canvas for your own creations, so if you love Nerdy Nuts’ quality but want a break from the experimental flavors, this is your brand.
Shop now at crazyrichards.com
Specializing in blanched almonds for an incredibly smooth and silky texture, Barney Butter is an almond butter lover’s dream. They stick to refined, classic additions like Honey or Vanilla Bean. If you navigate toward Nerdy Nuts' creamy bases but prefer a more subtle flavor touch, Barney Butter delivers a perfect, non-gritty spoon every time.
Shop now at barneybutter.com
This popular UK brand offers a refreshingly tasty lineup of nut butters with an eye on sustainability. Pip & Nut gets creative with flavors like Salted Caramel or Chilli & Lime, which feel vibrant and inspired by global tastes. They share Nerdy Nuts’ adventurous spirit but with a focus on more straightforward, bright, and often savory flavor combinations.
Shop now at pipandnut.com
Noosh positions itself as a premium, foodie-forward nut butter brand. Known for their elegant packaging and small-batch production, they craft inventive flavors like Cocoa + Almond or Toasted Coconut. Noosh is a great fit if you love Nerdy Nuts’ creativity but are looking for a more refined, artisanal experience for your palate (and your pantry shelf).
Shop now at noosh.com
For anyone with a nut allergy, SunButter is the ultimate game-changer. Made from sunflower seeds, it offers a fantastic nut-free alternative packed with flavor. You can get classic creamy styles or venture into sweet territory with their Honey or Cinnamon varieties. It's the perfect way to satisfy that spreadable snack craving without the nuts.
Shop now at sunbutter.com
Teddie is an old-school classic that has been making top-tier peanut butter for decades. Known for its rich peanut flavor and slightly gritty, all-natural texture, it’s a nostalgic favorite. Teddie is the antithesis of Nerdy Nuts’ experimentalism, appealing to those who believe that a simple, perfectly made peanut butter is just as satisfying as a wild creation.
Shop now at teddie.com
Kuli Kuli brings a superfood twist to the nut butter world by infusing their spreads with moringa, a nutrient-dense green. This brand is for the wellness-focused consumer who prioritizes nutrition just as much as flavor. While Nerdy Nuts is a fun indulgence, Kuli Kuli delivers on healthful benefits and an ethical sourcing story.
Shop now at kulikuli.com
Wild Good is redefining spreads by focusing on functional, plant-based ingredients designed to boost your well-being. Look for unique blends like Turmeric + Cardamom or Lemon + Ginger. It’s a health-forward brand for those who love Nerdy Nuts’ innovation but want their snack to come with added benefits like enhanced energy or a better mood.
Shop now at wildgood.co
If you're looking for a simple, reliable, and affordable option, Nutty Buddy fits the bill. A brand under the Little Debbie umbrella, it focuses on the classic creamy peanut butter that's perfect for sandwiches and everyday snacking. It's the no-frills alternative for when you just want good, straightforward peanut butter.
Shop now at nuttybuddy.com
Ready to try something a little different? Soom specializes in premium tahini (sesame seed butter) that’s incredibly smooth, rich, and versatile. They offer pure sesame tahini as well as intriguing sweet versions like a dark chocolate sea salt flavor. It expands the definition of a "spread" and introduces a new kind of nutty, creamy flavor to your kitchen.
Shop now at soomfoods.com
Why choose just one nut when you can have a blend? NuttZo is famous for its multi-nut and seed butters, creating a rich, hearty, and texturally complex spread. They also offer bold flavors like Chocolate Power Fuel and Cinnamon Swirl. It captures Nerdy Nuts' exciting flavor ethos but with a crunchy, complex blend of seven different nuts and seeds.
Shop now at nuttzo.com
Prepare your tastebuds for an adventure with LocoLoco. This brand draws inspiration from global cuisines to create exotic and unforgettable flavors like Thai Coconut or Mexican Chocolate. If you're drawn to Nerdy Nuts' sheer creativity, you'll love how LocoLoco translates that adventurous spirit into spicy, savory, and internationally inspired spreads.
Shop now at locolocofoods.com
A true kindred spirit to Nerdy Nuts, The Peanut Butter & Co. has long been known for its playful and indulgent flavors. With options like White Chocolate Wonderful, The Bee's Knees (honey), and Cinnamon Raisin Swirl, they know exactly how to turn peanut butter into a dessert-like treat. This is the perfect brand for anyone who loves sweet, creamy, imaginative blends.
Shop now at peanutbutterco.com
Wildly Natural focuses on organic, minimally processed ingredients to create clean and simple nut butters. While you can find delicious classics like raw cashew butter, they also offer gentle flavors like Cinnamon Honey. It’s for the snacker who appreciates Nerdy Nuts' quality but prefers subtler, more natural sweetening and flavoring.
Shop now at wildlynaturalfoods.com
Embrace a little bit of luxury with Barefoot & Chocolate. This artisanal brand makes decadent, small-batch nut butters with indulgent ingredients like dark chocolate and sea salt. If you’re captivated by Nerdy Nuts’ most dessert-like creations, Barefoot & Chocolate offers a gourmet, luxurious alternative perfect for a special treat or gift.
Shop now at barefootandchocolate.com
Centered on superfoods and functional nutrition, Health Warrior crafts nut butters designed to fuel an active lifestyle. They incorporate ingredients like chia seeds and other nutrient-dense additions into their products. It’s an ideal choice for the fitness enthusiast who enjoys a flavorful snack but looks for added health and wellness benefits.
Shop now at healthwarrior.com
NutraSea is a wellness-focused brand offering omega-rich nut butters by adding high-quality ingredients like flaxseed and chia. While less about dessert fantasy flavors, their goal is to make your everyday snack even healthier. It’s a smart pick for anyone who loves Nerdy Nuts but is looking to pack more nutritional power into their spread.
Shop now at nutrasea.com
With its vibrant packaging and commitment to clean, allergen-friendly options, Spread the Love shares Nerdy Nuts’ joyful approach. They offer creative flavors like Chocolate Cherry or Banana Bread almond butter that are both delicious and inclusive. It’s the perfect brand for anyone needing allergy-conscious products without sacrificing fun or flavor.
Shop now at spreadthelove.com
At Apart Style, we're obsessed with curating the best in fashion, beauty, and jewelry to help you discover new brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, style, and uniqueness. When you make a purchase through our links, Apart Style may earn a commission - which helps support our small team, and allows us to continue bringing you the best in online style brands.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our full brand directory or check out our curated brand guides to find your new favorite thing.
