If you love the simple, comfortable, and eco-conscious vibe of Koala, you know the magic of a great mattress-in-a-box. Koala nailed the sweet spot between all-foam comfort and mid-range-plus pricing, making premium sleep accessible to everyone.
But the world of a great night's sleep is bigger than ever. For those who appreciate Koala's blend of support, convenience, and value, here are 19 amazing mattress brands that deliver a similar promise of ultimate comfort.
As one of the original disruptors in the mattress world, Casper is a crowd-pleaser known for its balanced foam and hybrid mattresses that blend softness with support. Prices for their popular models range from about $995 to $2,495, offering options like the classic Original Foam for a cradling feel or the Wave Hybrid for targeted support and extra bounce.
While Koala is praised for its signature all-foam build, Casper provides a wider variety of choices, including hybrid models with springs. If you love the direct-to-consumer experience but tend to sleep hot or prefer a bit more lift than an all-foam mattress provides, Casper's breathable and versatile options are worth a look.
Shop now at casper.com
Hailing from Germany, Emma Sleep focuses on the science of a good night's rest. Their mattresses are engineered for serious pressure relief and temperature control, featuring layers of memory and supportive foams that adapt to your body. Priced in a similar range to Koala, typically from $500–$1,200, Emma is known for being a dream for sleepers with back pain or who overheat at night.
Where Koala shines with its eco-friendly Aussie charm, Emma stands out with its dedication to sleep tech, incorporating advanced cooling gels and airflow channels. If you want a mattress specifically designed to solve sleep problems like back pain or night sweats, Emma’s R&D-backed approach is an excellent alternative.
Shop now at emma-sleep.com
Purple is anything but ordinary. It’s famous for its one-of-a-kind Purple Grid™ technology - a hyper-elastic polymer that flexes under pressure points while remaining supportive everywhere else. This creates an almost weightless feeling that's incredibly cooling and responsive. Prices range from about $799 to $2,199.
This is a major departure from Koala's all-foam embrace. If you dislike the "sinking in" sensation of memory foam and want something bouncy, responsive, and incredibly breathable, the innovative feel of the Purple Grid could be your perfect match.
Shop now at purple.com
Imagine sleeping on a perfectly plush cloud - that’s the experience Nectar aims to deliver. Their memory foam mattresses are known for their thick comfort layers, deep contouring, and excellent motion isolation, making them a top pick for couples. With prices around $699–$1,299, they offer incredible value.
Compared to Koala's balanced and slightly firmer foam, Nectar leans into a softer, more luxurious feeling that truly hugs your body. If you’re a side sleeper or someone who fantasizes about sinking into a deep, pressure-relieving mattress, Nectar is your dream come true.
Shop now at nectar.com
Tuft & Needle keeps things simple, stylish, and incredibly affordable. They offer high-quality foam mattresses that provide reliable comfort without the fuss, often priced from $495–$995. Their proprietary Adaptive® foam is designed to be supportive yet pliable, hitting a nice middle ground that suits most sleepers.
If you're drawn to Koala for its simplicity and direct-to-consumer value, Tuft & Needle takes that ethos even further. It's one of the best choices out there for quality on a budget, making it perfect for first apartments, guest rooms, or anyone who wants a fantastic mattress without sweating the price tag.
Shop now at tuftandneedle.com
Saatva brings old-school luxury to the modern mattress world. Specializing in high-end hybrid mattresses, they combine a durable innerspring system with plush comfort layers, delivering exceptional edge support and a more traditional feel. Prices range from around $1,099 to $2,499.
Unlike Koala's compressed bed-in-a-box model, Saatva offers free white-glove delivery and setup. It's the perfect brand for anyone who loves the idea of ordering online but wants a more substantial, C-suite kind of mattress with classic, springy support.
Shop now at saatva.com
You probably know Brooklinen for their internet-famous sheets, but their mattresses are just as incredible. They specialize in hybrid designs that give you a luxurious, hotel-bed feel right at home. With prices between $1,195–$1,695, they focus on premium, eco-conscious fabrics that are breathable and soft to the touch.
Compared to Koala's straightforward approach, Brooklinen offers a more refined, design-forward aesthetic. It’s an ideal choice for shoppers who want their bed to look as good as it feels and prioritize natural, high-quality materials.
Shop now at brooklinen.com
Leesa offers thoughtfully designed foam and hybrid mattresses known for comfort, quality, and community-mindedness. Ranging from $799–$1,699, their models consistently earn top marks for pressure relief and durability, providing a dependably great sleep experience.
Leesa's foam often feels a bit firmer and more responsive than Koala's, giving it a bit more bounce. For shoppers who want a high-quality all-foam or hybrid mattress that hits a perfect medium-firm sweet spot, Leesa is a fantastic and reliable alternative.
Shop now at leesa.com
Designed for athletes and anyone with an active lifestyle, Bear mattresses are built for peak performance and recovery. Priced from approximately $795 to $1,695, their beds incorporate cooling gels and specialized mineral-infused fabrics intended to improve circulation and help your muscles bounce back faster overnight.
Koala focuses on cozy, everyday comfort, while Bear is all about restorative sleep. If you're a hot sleeper, work out regularly, or wake up with aches and pains, a Bear mattress is engineered to help you feel your best.
Shop now at bearmattress.com
Avocado is the go-to for shoppers who want a truly green sleep experience. Their mattresses are handmade in California with certified organic materials like natural latex, wool, and cotton. This eco-luxury comes at a higher price point, ranging from about $1,299 to $2,599.
This is a big step up in sustainability from Koala's already-good eco-credentials. Instead of synthetic foam, Avocado uses natural latex for a bouncy, supportive, and incredibly durable sleep surface. It's the perfect choice for anyone committed to organic living.
Shop now at avocadogreenmattress.com
Can't decide if you need soft or firm? Helix Sleep solves that by customizing a mattress just for you. After a quick sleep quiz, they match you with a hybrid mattress model built for your specific sleep position and firmness preference. A personalized bed from Helix typically costs between $1,099 and $2,399.
Koala offers a beloved one-size-fits-most design, but Helix champions the idea that everyone's needs are different. This is the perfect solution for picky sleepers or couples with totally different comfort preferences.
Shop now at helixsleep.com
Layla's flagship mattress is a genius two-in-one solution: it’s flippable, with a soft side and a firm side. This versatility, combined with copper-infused memory foam for enhanced cooling, makes it unique. Priced around $749–$1,099, it offers fantastic flexibility.
Unlike Koala's single firmness, Layla lets you choose your comfort level at home just by flipping the mattress over. It’s an ideal option for people whose preferences change over time or those who just want the freedom to experiment and find what feels best.
Shop now at laylasleep.com
Puffy is famous for its signature "cloud-like" feel, which is engineered to be a haven for side sleepers and anyone needing maximum pressure relief. Ranging from $1,195 to $2,095, their ultra-soft memory foam mattresses offer a deep, comfortable hug and excellent motion absorption.
While Koala provides a more balanced support, Puffy fully commits to a plush, sinking-in experience. If you dream of being gently cradled by your mattress all night long, Puffy's cozy, cloud-like surface is exactly what you've been searching for.
Shop now at puffy.com
Rooted in California craftsmanship, Brentwood Home offers beautifully made eco-friendly hybrid and all-latex mattresses. Priced from $1,099 to $2,499, they blend natural materials like latex and recycled fibers with thoughtful designs to create a luxurious and sustainable sleep environment.
Like Avocado, Brentwood Home is a fantastic alternative to Koala's synthetic foam for buyers who want a more natural and resilient mattress. Their designs often feature beautiful, hand-tufted details that give them a premium, artisanal feel.
Shop now at brentwoodhome.com
Leveraging Saatva's commitment to luxury, this line focuses exclusively on mattresses made with the finest organic and natural materials. Using certified components like organic cotton, wool, and ethically sourced latex, these beds offer a premium, handcrafted feel starting at around $1,299.
This is for the person who loves Koala's eco-conscious spirit but wants to take it to the next level of luxury. A Saatva Organic mattress feels like a five-star hotel bed that just happens to be made of pure, natural goodness.
Shop now at saatva.com/organic
Eight Sleep is more than a mattress - it's a high-tech sleep system. Their smart beds feature built-in temperature regulation that can cool or warm each side of the bed independently, along with advanced sleep-tracking technology. This innovation comes with a price tag from $1,695 up to $2,695 or more.
Koala masters simple foam comfort, while Eight Sleep is all about optimizing your rest with data and technology. If you’re a Quantified Self enthusiast or someone who's constantly fighting over the thermostat, this mattress will revolutionize your sleep routine.
Shop now at eightsleep.com
Known for its famous knitted weighted blankets, Bearaby has brought its hug-like comfort to sleep products. Their approach to mattresses emphasizes deep pressure therapy and relaxation. While they don’t offer a traditional bed frame mattress currently, their innovative approach to soothing sleep (with products like their weighted blankets starting around $1,099 for a set including a frame) is worth noting for comfort seekers.
Koala is about foam-based comfort, whereas Bearaby's core philosophy is about creating a sense of calm through weight. If you're an anxious sleeper who loves the security of a heavy blanket, incorporating Bearaby into your sleep system can be a game-changer.
Shop now at bearaby.com
Nest Bedding is all about choice. They offer a huge range of hybrid and foam mattresses at nearly every price point, from budget-friendly ($699) to luxury ($2,199+). They champion organic and natural materials alongside innovative designs, like mattresses with interchangeable firmness layers.
If you like Koala's model but wish you had more customization options, Nest is your perfect destination. Whether you want a natural latex mattress or a classic foam bed, they cater to a wide scope of sleep preferences and values, making them one of the most versatile brands out there.
Shop now at nestbedding.com
At Apart Style, we're obsessed with curating the best in fashion, beauty, and jewelry to help you discover new brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, style, and uniqueness. When you make a purchase through our links, Apart Style may earn a commission - which helps support our small team, and allows us to continue bringing you the best in online style brands.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our full brand directory or check out our curated brand guides to find your new favorite thing.
