If you're a fan of classic, well-made footwear, you're probably very familiar with Johnston & Murphy. The brand has mastered the art of creating timeless dress shoes, loafers, and boots that perfectly balance high-quality craftsmanship, enduring comfort, and an accessible price point.
For those looking to expand their shoe collection beyond Johnston & Murphy's polished styles, plenty of other brands offer a similar commitment to quality and classic design. From heritage American icons to luxe Italian artisans, here are 22 brands like Johnston & Murphy that are worth checking out.
Think of Allen Edmonds as the next step up in classic American shoemaking. They are renowned for their premium, handcrafted dress shoes that are built to last thanks to high-grade leathers and durable Goodyear welt construction. This means they can be easily repaired and resoled, making them a true investment piece for any wardrobe.
In terms of style, they share Johnston & Murphy's commitment to timeless design, but with a more luxurious touch and higher quality materials. Prices reflect this, typically ranging from $300 to $600, but if you're looking for a shoe that you'll have for decades, Allen Edmonds is hard to beat.
Shop now at www.allenedmonds.com
Cole Haan expertly blends traditional footwear design with modern technology to create shoes that are incredibly comfortable and stylish. The brand is known for infusing its oxfords and loafers with innovative features like proprietary cushioned insoles and feather-light, flexible soles. They’re a go-to for anyone who spends a lot of time on their feet but isn't willing to compromise on a polished look.
Like Johnston & Murphy, they offer versatile shoes for the modern professional, but Cole Haan leans more into a contemporary, fashion-forward aesthetic. With a similar price point of $150-$250, it's the perfect choice for someone wanting classic style with a sneaker-like feel.
Shop now at www.colehaan.com
A heritage British brand, Clarks is a global name in comfortable and practical footwear. While famous for their iconic Desert Boot, they also offer a fantastic range of elegant oxfords and dress shoes that deliver on both quality and style. Clarks is often a bit more affordable than Johnston & Murphy, with prices generally sitting in the $100-$200 range.
Both brands prioritize durability and high-quality construction, but Clarks often has a slightly more relaxed, casual vibe. If you're looking for dependable, stylish footwear that effortlessly bridges the gap between formal and comfortable-casual, Clarks is an excellent option.
Shop now at www.clarksusa.com
Florsheim is another longstanding American brand that serves up a wide selection of classic dress shoes, oxfords, and loafers. Their core focus is on comfort-driven designs and traditional silhouettes that never go out of style. It’s a fantastic brand for building a reliable, professional shoe collection without breaking the bank.
Florsheim is very similar to Johnston & Murphy in its classic style, but usually at a more accessible price point, hovering between $100 and $200. It's a great choice for anyone who values time-tested style and all-day comfort for the office.
Shop now at www.florsheim.com
For a touch of European elegance, look no further than Magnanni. This Spanish luxury brand is celebrated for its sleek, handcrafted dress shoes and loafers. Featuring incredibly soft leathers, refined stitching, and sophisticated silhouettes, Magnanni shoes have a distinct artisanal feel.
Compared to Johnston & Murphy's traditional American style, Magnanni brings a more modern, European sensibility. This is a higher-end brand, with prices often in the $400 to $700 range, making them ideal for special occasions or for anyone wanting to add a piece of refined luxury to their collection.
Shop now at www.magnanni.com
Mezlan is another family-owned Spanish brand that creates luxurious, handcrafted footwear that blends tradition with bold, contemporary style. Their loafers and dress shoes often feature unique textures, premium leathers like exotic skins, and exquisite attention to detail.
Like Magnanni, Mezlan sits firmly in the luxury category with prices frequently above $400. While they share Johnston & Murphy's appreciation for classic silhouettes, Mezlan's designs are often more fashion-forward and distinctive, catering to style-conscious shoppers who appreciate high-quality craftsmanship.
Shop now at www.mezlan.com
Hugo Boss is known for sleek, modern tailoring, and its footwear collection is no exception. Designed for the fashion-conscious professional, their dress shoes and loafers feature clean, minimalist lines and high-quality materials. It's a go-to for a polished, contemporary look.
Where Johnston & Murphy’s aesthetic is solidly traditional, Hugo Boss feels more minimalist and on-trend. Their prices are surprisingly comparable, falling between $150 and $300, making them a great choice for adding a dash of modern style to your office or formal event wardrobe.
Shop now at www.hugoboss.com
Step into the world of elite Italian craftsmanship with Santoni. This luxury brand is celebrated for its elegant, artisanal shoes, handcrafted with meticulous attention to detail from the finest leathers available. Their beautifully finished oxfords and loafers are true statement pieces.
This is a significant step up in price, with shoes often starting above $700. While Johnston & Murphy focuses on dependable, classic style, Santoni emphasizes artistry, rich colors, and exclusivity, making its shoes perfect for devoted collectors and major occasions.
Shop now at www.santoni.com
With a heritage dating back to 1876, G.H. Bass & Co. is an American institution, famously credited with creating the world's first penny loafer. The brand provides quality, comfortable dress shoes, loafers, and boots with a classic, slightly preppy sensibility.
Like Johnston & Murphy, Bass embodies a timeless American style, but it generally does so at a more budget-friendly price point, with most shoes ranging from $80 to $150. This makes Bass an excellent place to find reliable and stylish footwear for everyday professional life.
Shop now at www.bass.com
Kenneth Cole New York has been providing stylish, contemporary footwear for the urban professional for decades. The brand offers sleek dress shoes, boots, and loafers designed with a modern mindset. They excel at creating versatile shoes that work for both the office and a night out.
Their style has a more fashion-forward edge than Johnston & Murphy's traditional offerings but still retains a classic foundation. With prices typically in the $100 to $200 range, it’s a great brand for modern professionals seeking affordable style.
Shop now at www.kennethcole.com
Bruno Magli is an Italian luxury brand known for pure elegance and refined craftsmanship. Their collection of formal shoes and loafers is crafted from high-quality leathers, resulting in exceptionally sleek and sophisticated designs that are perfect for dressy occasions.
With prices generally starting above $400, Bruno Magli is a luxury alternative to Johnston & Murphy, closer to brands like Magnanni and Santoni. If you value timeless Italian design and superior craftsmanship, this is a brand worth the investment.
Shop now at www.brunomagli.com
Frye is another American heritage brand best known for its rugged and incredibly durable leather boots. However, their collection also includes dress boots, loafers, and casual shoes with a cool, vintage-inspired aesthetic. Quality and longevity are at the core of everything they create.
While Johnston & Murphy's focus is on polished, professional footwear, Frye caters to a more casual and rugged style. Both brands prioritize quality materials, so if you want a classic shoe with a more laid-back attitude, Frye is an excellent pick, with prices between $200 and $400.
Shop now at www.frye.com
Ecco blends minimalist Scandinavian design with innovative comfort technology to produce exceptionally functional footwear. Their dress shoes and loafers are famous for being lightweight, durable, and comfortable right out of the box.
Much like Johnston & Murphy, Ecco puts a huge emphasis on quality and comfort. However, Ecco's style leans more toward modern minimalism and everyday wear, making them a great option for someone who wants a versatile shoe that can be dressed up or down. Prices typically sit in the $100-$200 range.
Shop now at www.ecco.com
Hailing from London, Ted Baker offers stylish and contemporary footwear with a playful-yet-refined attitude. Their collections often feature unique details, subtle patterns, and pops of color that set them apart from more traditional brands. They're perfect for smart-casual situations where you want to show a bit of personality.
Falling in a similar $150-$250 price range, Ted Baker provides another great alternative to Johnston & Murphy, but with more trend-driven, fashion-forward elements mixed into its classic designs.
Shop now at www.tedbaker.com
Vionic puts foot health first. The brand specializes in comfort-focused footwear designed with podiatrist-approved orthotics built right into every shoe, including their polished dress shoes and loafers. If you need extra support without resorting to clunky orthopedic styles, Vionic is a game-changer.
While Johnston & Murphy is known for its comfortable yet stylish fit, Vionic makes biomechanics and support its number one priority. With most styles priced between $80 and $150, they're a fantastic, budget-friendly option for all-day wear.
Shop now at www.vionicshoes.com
To Boot New York offers high-end, Italian-crafted footwear with a modern and sophisticated aesthetic. Designed in New York City, their collections of oxfords, boots, and loafers are made for the man with discerning taste, using fine leathers and sleek construction methods.
Sharing Johnston & Murphy's dedication to quality, To Boot New York leans further into the luxury market, with prices often between $400 and $700. It's a great choice when dressing for important business meetings or upscale events.
Shop now at toboot.com
Sebago is synonymous with classic New England style, best known for its iconic boat shoes and preppy loafers. They offer a range of casual dress shoes that champion durability, comfort, and timeless American design that's perfect for a business casual environment or weekend adventures.
Compared to Johnston & Murphy’s more formal offerings, Sebago strikes a more casual, relaxed tone. If your style leans a bit preppy or you need a shoe for smart weekend looks, Sebago is an ideal fit, usually priced between $100 and $200.
Shop now at www.sebago-usa.com
Heschung is a French artisanal brand specializing in high-quality, handcrafted leather shoes built with both Norwegian and Goodyear welting techniques for incredible durability. They are admired for their classic designs, long-lasting quality, and use of sustainable materials.
In a league with luxury brands like Santoni, Heschung focuses on time-honored European craftsmanship with prices often exceeding $500. They appeal to shoppers looking for an exceptionally well-made, eco-conscious investment piece.
Shop now at heschung.com
A German brand with a long history, Lloyd is known for producing high-quality dress shoes where exceptional fit and comfort are just as important as classic style. Their aesthetic is sleek, refined, and often features a distinct European touch.
Lloyd's commitment to craftsmanship and timeless styles will feel familiar to fans of Johnston & Murphy. Their prices are also quite comparable, sitting around the $200-$400 range, making them a solid choice for professional footwear that stands out.
Shop now at www.lloyd.com
From the heart of England's shoemaking district, Barker has been handcrafting durable leather footwear since 1880. Celebrated for their classic oxfords, brogues, and boots, their shoes combine traditional British style with modern comfort technologies for a perfect fit.
Barker shares Johnston & Murphy's focus on timeless designs and excellent quality, but with a distinctly European approach to craftsmanship. Expect to find them in the $300 to $600 price range, making them a great luxury-leaning alternative.
Shop now at barkershoes.com
This esteemed Italian shoemaker creates footwear that is a work of art. Santoni is a luxury brand renowned for its exceptional artisanal craftsmanship, sleek designs, and beautiful hand-coloring on premium leathers. Their shoes are built for life's most formal and important moments.
With prices often exceeding $700, they are a high-end luxury alternative to Johnston & Murphy's more traditional styles. Santoni appeals to those seeking truly top-tier, statement-making footwear that will be admired for years to come.
Shop now at www.santoni.com
Meermin might be the best-kept secret in high-quality footwear. This Spanish brand has a direct-to-consumer model that allows them to offer handcrafted, Goodyear-welted shoes at an incredibly accessible price point, typically between $200 and $300.
They offer quality and construction that rivals much more expensive brands, making them an amazing value. If you love the classic, durable style of Johnston & Murphy but want to get the absolute most for your money, Meermin is the perfect brand to explore.
Shop now at meermin.com
At Apart Style, we're obsessed with curating the best in fashion, beauty, and jewelry to help you discover new brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, style, and uniqueness. When you make a purchase through our links, Apart Style may earn a commission - which helps support our small team, and allows us to continue bringing you the best in online style brands.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our full brand directory or check out our curated brand guides to find your new favorite thing.
