There's something special about jewelry that tells a story. That's why Bryan Anthony has become such a beloved brand for so many people. They create beautiful, modern pieces - from engraved rings to sentimental lockets - that celebrate life's most important moments without breaking the bank.
If you love how Bryan Anthony turns jewelry into meaningful keepsakes, you're in luck. There are plenty of other amazing brands that share that same focus on creating personal, heartfelt pieces. Here are 17 similar jewelry brands worth checking out.
Gorjana is the cool girl's destination for delicate, layered jewelry designed for everyday wear. Think lightweight gold chains, tiny studs, and power gemstone bracelets that are perfect for stacking. While they are known for their minimalist, boho-chic aesthetic, they also offer a great selection of engravable pieces and meaningful charms that feel personal.
Prices typically range from $30-$150, making Gorjana a slightly more affordable alternative to Bryan Anthony. It’s perfect if you're looking for that same sentimental feel but with a more casual, SoCal vibe.
Shop now at gorjana.com
Dogeared has been creating dainty, symbolic jewelry for years, focusing on positive messages and understated charms. Their pieces are designed to be daily reminders of love, strength, or balance, often presented on cards that explain their meaning. Their vibe is relaxed and spiritual, with everything from simple karma circles to tiny wishbone necklaces.
Like Bryan Anthony, the jewelry is meant to be meaningful, but Dogeared has a more laid-back, spiritual feel and an even more accessible price point, usually between $20-$100.
Shop now at dogeared.com
Mejuri brought "everyday fine jewelry" to the direct-to-consumer space, offering high-quality essentials without the traditional luxury markup. Best known for their minimalist gold hoops, stacking rings, and customizable initial pendants, their pieces are designed to be worn for years. Their aesthetic is sleek, modern, and undeniably chic.
Mejuri is a fantastic alternative if you love the personal touch of Bryan Anthony but prefer a more contemporary, minimalist style. Their prices for vermeil and 14k gold pieces generally fall between $50 and $300.
Shop now at mejuri.com
Originally known for men's jewelry, Miansai has expanded to create modern, meaningful pieces for everyone. Their collection includes everything from sleek cuff bracelets to personalized pendants, often with engravable options. The style is minimal yet impactful, crafted with high-quality metals like sterling silver and gold vermeil.
Priced between $50 and $200, Miansai is great for those who want heartfelt jewelry with a slightly more architectural and less delicate feel than Bryan Anthony.
Shop now at miansai.com
Kendra Scott is known for its bold colors, signature shapes, and an incredible Color Bar™ where you can design your own jewelry. They offer a huge range of customizable pieces, from initial necklaces to birthstone bracelets, making gift-giving easy and personal. The aesthetic is more vibrant and trend-focused than Bryan Anthony's understated style.
While still focused on meaningful, customizable pieces, Kendra Scott is for someone who wants to make more of a fashion statement. Prices are similar, generally ranging from $50-$200.
Shop now at kendrascott.com
Etsy is an endless source for personalized, handcrafted jewelry from independent makers around the world. You can find anything imaginable, from engraved bar necklaces with a specific date to rings set with the birthstones of your entire family. The beauty of Etsy is the ability to connect directly with an artisan to create a truly one-of-a-kind piece.
If you love the sentimentality of Bryan Anthony but want something completely bespoke, Etsy is your best bet. Price points vary from ultra-affordable to fine jewelry prices.
Shop now at etsy.com
Vitaly offers genderless jewelry with a cool, modern edge. Their designs are often architectural and symbolic, made from durable stainless steel. You'll find things like hinge rings, intricate pendants, and chain necklaces that feel both futuristic and timeless. While less focused on overtly sentimental engravings, their pieces carry a strong sense of purpose and design.
Vitaly is a great option for someone who appreciates meaningful accessories but prefers a bolder, less traditional aesthetic than Bryan Anthony.
Shop now at vitaly.com
Kate Spade’s jewelry line perfectly captures the brand’s playful, charming, and a little bit quirky spirit. It's filled with playful motifs, pops of color, and of course, plenty of personalization, like their ultra-popular initial pendants. It’s jewelry that doesn’t take itself too seriously and is meant to make you smile.
If you love the idea of personal jewelry but want something more fun and whimsical than Bryan Anthony’s elegant pieces, Kate Spade is a perfect choice, with most items priced between $50 and $150.
Shop now at katespade.com
For those looking for a fine jewelry option, Anna Sheffield creates stunning pieces designed to carry deep emotional significance. Known for her unique engagement rings and ceremonial jewelry, she also crafts beautiful necklaces and commitment bands that blend modern elegance with a bohemian spirit. Many pieces are customizable with engravings and unique gemstones.
Think of Anna Sheffield as the high-end, luxury counterpart to Bryan Anthony's emotional storytelling, with pieces typically starting around $300.
Shop now at annasheffield.com
Molly Clark Jewelry designs modern, minimal pieces meant to celebrate milestones and connections. The collection is full of timeless styles like initial tags, birthstone charms, and customized discs that are perfect for personalized gifting. The designs are understated and elegant, intended to be worn every single day.
Her approach is very similar to Bryan Anthony's focus on creating keepsakes, with a similar price range of about $50-$200 per piece.
Shop now at mollyclarkjewelry.com
Glamour Jewelry specializes in customizable, affordable fine jewelry with a timeless and sophisticated feel. They offer a wide selection of personalized name necklaces, birthstone rings, and engraved pendants that are perfect for celebrating special bonds. Their elegant aesthetic makes their pieces great for both daily wear and more formal occasions.
With prices usually in the $40-$150 range, this brand offers that same personal, sentimental value as Bryan Anthony with a slightly more classic design focus.
Shop now at glamourjewelry.com
Lagos is a luxury brand known for its signature Caviar bead design, creating bold jewelry that is both artistic and wearable. While on the higher end of the price spectrum, their collections often feature meaningful motifs, engravable sterling silver pieces, and zodiac charms that allow for personal expression. The quality and craftsmanship are exceptional.
If you want to invest in a piece of storyteller jewelry that makes a statement, Lagos is a fantastic upscale alternative to Bryan Anthony, with prices starting at $200.
Shop now at lagos.com
Known for its colorful string bracelets that support artisans worldwide, Pura Vida also offers a metal jewelry collection focused on positivity and self-expression. You'll find engraved bracelets, delicate charm anklets, and stackable rings that capture a casual, beach-inspired vibe. Their focus is on good vibes and personal talismans.
Pura Vida shares Bryan Anthony's focus on creating jewelry with an uplifting message, but with a super laid-back, boho feel and an affordable price tag, usually between $20 and $80.
Shop now at puravidabracelets.com
Sophie Monet creates stunning personalized jewelry with a sleek, modern, and soulful feel. Her collections include engraved rings, simple gold necklaces, and bracelets purpose-built for marking special moments. The designs feel contemporary and heartfelt, making them ideal keepsakes for a modern minimalist.
With prices ranging from $50-$150, Sophie Monet is directly comparable to Bryan Anthony in its commitment to elegant, personalized pieces that celebrate life and love.
Shop now at sophiemonet.com
Luv Aj is for the trend-setter who loves bold, statement-making jewelry. Famous for its chunky hoops, layered chains, and pave details, the brand captures a vibe that is equal parts Malibu cool and downtown edge. While most of their collection is trend-focused, they do offer charm necklaces and pavé initial pieces for a personalized touch.
Luv Aj is ideal for someone who wants the potential for personalization found at Bryan Anthony, but prefers a much more daring, fashion-forward style. Prices typically range from $50-$200.
Shop now at luvaj.com
Harper Rose makes beautiful, delicate personal jewelry that's perfect for everyday wear. The brand centers on customizable pieces like understated initial necklaces, darling charm bracelets, and simple birthstone rings. Their style is all about minimalist elegance, creating sentimental accessories that feel classic and never go out of style.
Very similar to Bryan Anthony's mission to create effortlessly special jewelry, Harper Rose is a great option in the $40-$150 price range for shoppers who love a dainty aesthetic.
Shop now at harperrose.com
Julia Morgan Jewelry offers handcrafted pieces designed with care and built around personalization. The collection features engravable charms, unique birthstone pieces, and symbolic items meant to be treasured. The style strikes a lovely balance between modern minimalism and an artistic, handcrafted feel that makes each item feel distinct.
With most pieces in the $50-$200 range, it’s a wonderful choice for shoppers seeking heartfelt jewelry with a bespoke touch, much like the special feeling of a Bryan Anthony gift.
Shop now at juliamorganjewelry.com
At Apart Style, we're obsessed with curating the best in fashion, beauty, and jewelry to help you discover new brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, style, and uniqueness. When you make a purchase through our links, Apart Style may earn a commission - which helps support our small team, and allows us to continue bringing you the best in online style brands.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our full brand directory or check out our curated brand guides to find your new favorite thing.
