There are some brands that just *get* it when it comes to timeless boots, and Frye is definitely at the top of that list. Known for its incredible leather quality and American heritage vibe, a pair of Frye boots is pretty much an investment you'll have for decades. They’re the kind of boots that only look better with age.
If you love Frye's blend of rugged craftsmanship and classic style but are looking to broaden your footwear horizons, you're in luck. We've rounded up 20 other amazing boot brands that deliver that same timeless leather appeal you can't get enough of.
If you appreciate Frye's American-made heritage, you'll feel right at home with Red Wing. This brand is the real deal when it comes to rugged, workwear-inspired boots built to withstand anything. The style is a bit more utilitarian and less fashion-forward than some of Frye’s designs, but the commitment to quality and premium leather is exactly the same. Think of them as Frye's tougher, more outdoorsy cousin.
Shop now at redwingheritage.com
Famous for their iconic desert boots, Clarks Originals offers a more casual and minimalist take on leather footwear. With prices generally in the $100-$200 range, they're a more accessible option for everyday wear. While Frye’s boots are often more structured and rugged, Clarks brings a softer, understated vibe that still feels classic and timeless. They’re a go-to for comfort without sacrificing heritage style.
Shop now at clarksusa.com
Thursday Boot Company has made a name for itself by delivering high-quality, long-lasting leather boots for around $200. Their aesthetic is a perfect blend of modern minimalism and classic ruggedness. Compared to Frye, Thursday’s silhouettes are often a bit sleeker and more streamlined, striking a great balance between durable construction and everyday, city-friendly style.
Shop now at thursdayboots.com
For a more contemporary, fashion-forward leather boot, check out Vagabond. This brand combines sleek Scandinavian minimalism with a touch of edge. Their boots are less about a rugged, vintage look and more focused on trendy-yet-timeless silhouettes like chunky Chelseas and platform styles. If you love Frye’s quality but want a boot that feels more of-the-moment, Vagabond is a perfect fit.
Shop now at vagabondshoes.com
Mephisto puts comfort at the forefront without sacrificing premium, European-made quality. Their leather boots are less rugged than Frye’s and have a more refined, polished look, focusing on ergonomic support that you can wear all day long. If an investment in comfort is just as important to you as timeless style, Mephisto is a great brand to explore.
Shop now at mephisto.com
Hailing from Australia, Blundstone is iconic for its durable, pull-on Chelsea boots. They share Frye’s emphasis on longevity and timeless design but with a more casual, everyday ease. Their boots are practical, weather-resistant, and incredibly versatile, making them a go-to for anyone who loves the rugged leather look but wants something they can slip on and off effortlessly.
Shop now at blundstone.com
Another beloved Australian brand, R.M. Williams offers a luxurious take on handcrafted Chelsea boots. Their aesthetic is sleek, polished, and endlessly classic, taking the timeless silhouette to a new level of sophistication. While their price point is higher (around $500-$700), the impeccable craftsmanship and single-piece leather construction make them a worthy investment, similar to Frye.
Shop now at rmwilliams.com
Loake channels traditional British craftsmanship into its elegant leather boots. Their styles, like classic brogues and refined Chelsea boots, have a similar vintage-inspired feel to Frye's but with a more formal, polished finish. It's a great option if you're looking for a timeless boot that leans a bit more dressy and sophisticated.
Shop now at loake.co.uk
Known for their iconic "yellow boots," Timberland is a master of tough, outdoor-ready footwear. The TimberlandPRO line leans even further into durability and workwear performance. While both brands champion toughness, TimberlandPRO is more focused on function and utility compared to Frye’s fashion-centric approach, making them ideal for those who need a boot that works as hard as they do.
Shop now at timberland.com
Vince Camuto strikes a balance between modern trends and classic leather craftsmanship. Their boots offer a sleeker, more fashion-forward feel than Frye's heritage styles and come in a wide range of silhouettes perfect for both day and night. If you’re looking for high-quality leather boots that feel a little more playful and trendy, this is your brand.
Shop now at vincecamuto.com
For a dose of Parisian chic, A.P.C. is the answer. The brand is known for its minimalist, clean lines and understated elegance. Their leather boots are far less rugged than Frye's, offering a refined and effortless style that pairs perfectly with everything from jeans to dresses. They are the definition of cool, quiet luxury.
Shop now at apc-us.com
Magnanni is a Spanish luxury brand that excels in handcrafted, polished leather dress boots. This is your go-to if you’re seeking a high-end, sophisticated alternative to Frye's more casual and rustic aesthetic. Their boots boast an elegant European flair that’s perfect for dressing up.
Shop now at magnanni.com
If you like Clarks but are looking for something a bit more elevated, the Clarks Artisan line is for you. This collection offers premium versions of their classic styles, blending trusted comfort with more sophisticated details and materials. They’re still less rugged than Frye but deliver fantastic quality for everyday wear.
Shop now at clarksusa.com
When the weather turns, Sorel is the expert in stylish, weatherproof boots. They share Frye's commitment to quality leather and durability but with a focus on function, especially for cold and wet climates. Expect waterproof construction and cozy linings, making them the perfect pick for a stylish boot that can handle any element.
Shop now at sorel.com
Crockett & Jones is a testament to British shoemaking excellence, creating premium leather boots with impeccable craftsmanship. Their designs are traditional, polished, and built to last a lifetime, putting them in the investment-quality tier. They offer a more formal and refined counterpoint to Frye’s rugged American style.
Shop now at crockettandjones.com
Pikolinos of Spain brings an artisanal, boho-chic vibe to their handcrafted leather boots. They are known for comfort and unique, relaxed designs that often feature rich colors and thoughtful detailing. If you find Frye's style a bit too rustic, Pikolinos offers a softer, more laid-back aesthetic that’s perfect for casual wear.
Shop now at pikolinos.com
Looking for the Frye vibe without the Frye price tag? Cosmopolitan Leather Co. is a great find. Specializing in affordable, vintage-inspired leather boots, they offer durable styles that echo Frye's classic silhouettes. They're a fantastic choice for budget-conscious shoppers who don’t want to sacrifice that timeless look.
Shop now at cosmopolitanleatherco.com
On the ultimate luxury end of the spectrum, Brunello Cucinelli represents the pinnacle of Italian craftsmanship. Their leather boots are exceptionally refined, handcrafted from the finest materials for a polished and ridiculously elegant look. While Frye is rooted in rugged American heritage, Brunello Cucinelli offers timeless European sophistication.
Shop now at brunellocucinelli.com
Sandro delivers chic, Parisian-inspired leather boots with a modern, edgy twist. The vibe is fashion-forward and effortlessly cool, often featuring details like harnesses and sleek silhouettes. They offer the same high-quality leather you expect but with a City of Light aesthetic that contrasts Frye's American West feel.
Shop now at sandro-paris.com
H by Hudson focuses on sleek, contemporary leather boots with a clean, minimalist design ethos. Their styles are less rugged and more refined than Frye's, perfect for achieving a modern and polished look. The brand is a great option for those who want versatile, high-quality leather boots that feel clean and current.
Shop now at hbyhudson.com
At Apart Style, we're obsessed with curating the best in fashion, beauty, and jewelry to help you discover new brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, style, and uniqueness. When you make a purchase through our links, Apart Style may earn a commission - which helps support our small team, and allows us to continue bringing you the best in online style brands.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our full brand directory or check out our curated brand guides to find your new favorite thing.
