Balenciaga First vs. City: Which one should you buy?

The Balenciaga First and City bags both come from the same celebrated design ethos of Balenciaga, but they cater to very different styles. The First is a modern handbag defined by a structured, boxy silhouette and a clean, minimalist aesthetic. In contrast, the iconic City bag features a slouchy, relaxed shape with signature studded hardware and a more rugged, streetwear-inspired look.

Here’s everything you need to know about these two standout bags to decide which one is right for you.

Balenciaga First

The Balenciaga First is a contemporary take on the brand's classic designs, reimagined with a rigid, geometric structure and clean lines. It appeals to those who favor a modern, architectural aesthetic over the relaxed feel of its predecessors. Its defined shape and minimalist hardware make it a sophisticated choice that works well for both professional and evening settings.

• What it is: A modern, structured luxury bag with a distinctive rounded top handle and a compact, boxy silhouette.
• Key features: Smooth or grained leather craftsmanship, a sleek profile, embossed logo, and a detachable shoulder strap for versatility.
• Price: Ranges from $2,200 to $2,500.
• Materials/Construction: Crafted from high-quality leather with meticulous stitching, designed to maintain its structured shape over time.
• Sizing/Fit: A compact design measuring approximately 7 x 5 x 3 inches, perfect for carrying essentials like a phone, wallet, keys, and lipstick.
• Pros: Chic and modern design, versatile enough for day-to-night wear, maintains its shape well, and offers a more understated look.
• Cons: Carries significantly less than the City, higher price point, the minimalist design may lack the edgy hardware some associate with Balenciaga.

This bag is the perfect choice for someone who appreciates clean, architectural lines and needs a polished bag that can transition from the office to an evening out.

Shop this product: balenciaga.com/en-us/handbags/first-bag

Balenciaga City

An icon since the early 2000s, the Balenciaga City is the quintessential luxury streetwear bag, celebrated for its relaxed, slouchy silhouette and motorcycle-inspired hardware. Its intentionally distressed leather, prominent studs, and tassel zipper pulls create a rugged yet effortlessly cool look. The City bag is a functional workhorse that has remained a favorite among trendsetters for its practicality and rebellious attitude.

• What it is: An iconic, slouchy satchel with a relaxed silhouette, known for its studded detailing and tassel zipper pulls.
• Key features: Soft, supple leather body, signature hardware, multiple interior compartments, and both a top handle and shoulder strap.
• Price: Ranges from $1,950 to $2,300.
• Materials/Construction: Typically made from distressed or soft-finish leather that is designed to slouch and develop a unique patina over time.
• Sizing/Fit: The small version is approximately 10 x 8 x 3 inches, offering ample space for daily essentials and more.
• Pros: Recognizable and iconic design, highly practical for everyday use, comfortable to carry, and ages beautifully.
• Cons: The slouchy style can appear informal, the busy hardware isn't for minimalists, and the distressed look may not suit all tastes.

This bag suits a streetwear enthusiast who wants an edgy, instantly recognizable accessory with plenty of space for daily essentials.

Shop this product: balenciaga.com/en-us/handbags/city-bag

Balenciaga First vs. City Comparison

Style & Aesthetic

The primary difference between the First and the City is their overall vibe. The First is the picture of modern minimalism, its geometric, structured silhouette and clean hardware give it a sophisticated, polished feel. It's chic, sharp, and can easily be dressed up for formal occasions.

The City, on the other hand, embodies a relaxed, rebellious spirit. Its slouchy shape, signature studs, and distressed leather give it an edgy, bohemian look rooted in 2000s street style. While still a luxury item, its aesthetic is inherently more casual and laid-back.

Size & Capacity

Functionality is a key differentiator here. The Balenciaga First is a compact bag, measuring around 7 by 5 inches. It's designed to hold just the essentials - your phone, a small wallet, keys, and a few makeup items. Its small size makes it elegant but limits its use as a primary daily bag for those who carry more.

The Balenciaga City is much more generous with space. Even the small version, at 10 by 8 inches, can comfortably fit a wallet, phone, sunglasses case, small water bottle, and other daily necessities. This makes the City the more practical choice for everyday wear, errands, or even travel.

Materials & Construction

Both bags showcase Balenciaga's high-quality craftsmanship, but the materials cater to different aesthetics. The First typically uses smooth or finely grained leather stretched over a rigid frame to maintain its architectural shape. It's built for structure and precision.

The City is famous for its soft, often distressed lambskin or goatskin, which allows the bag to develop its signature slouch. This leather is chosen specifically because it patinas and softens beautifully over time, giving each bag a unique character as it ages.

Price & Value

The Balenciaga First usually carries a slightly higher price tag, retailing between $2,200 and $2,500. Its value lies in its modern design and structured form, positioning it as a sleek, contemporary statement piece.

The City is generally priced between $1,950 and $2,300, making it a slightly more accessible entry point. Its value comes from its iconic status, everyday practicality, and durable construction that’s meant to be used and loved for years.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both the First and the City are excellent bags, but they are designed for different lifestyles and aesthetic preferences.

Choose the Balenciaga First if:

• You prefer structured handbags with clean, architectural lines.
• You want a versatile bag that can easily transition from daytime meetings to nighttime events.
• Your style is modern, minimalist, and sophisticated.
• You typically only carry your absolute essentials.

Choose the Balenciaga City if:

• You love an edgy, iconic streetwear aesthetic.
• You need a practical bag with ample space for daily use.
• You appreciate a relaxed, slouchy silhouette and signature hardware.
• Your style is more casual, bohemian, or has a rebellious streak.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the main difference between the Balenciaga First and City?

The biggest difference is their silhouette and aesthetic. The First is a structured, minimalist, and modern bag with a boxy shape. The City is a slouchy, relaxed bag known for its iconic motorcycle-inspired hardware and edgy, casual vibe.

Which Balenciaga bag is more classic?

The City is arguably the more iconic of the two, representing a key era in early 2000s fashion that remains hugely influential. However, the First bag's clean lines give it a more timeless, classic shape that will not feel tied to a specific decade.

Which bag holds more?

The Balenciaga City holds significantly more. Its larger dimensions and slouchy design allow it to expand and accommodate daily essentials, making it the more practical choice for an everyday bag.

Is the Balenciaga City back still in style?

Yes, the Balenciaga City is considered an enduring icon. Trends from the 2000s have seen a major resurgence, and the City bag remains a popular choice for those who appreciate its unique blend of luxury and grit.

Which bag is a better investment?

Both bags hold their value reasonably well for luxury goods. The City's iconic status gives it proven lasting power in the resale market. The First's classic shape may appeal to a broader audience over time, less dependent on trends. Ultimately, investment potential depends on the specific color, material, and market demand.

Can the Balenciaga First be worn as a crossbody?

Yes, the Balenciaga First comes with a detachable and adjustable strap, allowing it to be worn over the shoulder or as a crossbody bag for hands-free convenience.

How do you care for the Balenciaga City's leather?

The distressed leather of the City bag is designed to age and develop character. To maintain its condition, it's best to handle it with clean hands, store it in its dust bag, and occasionally use a high-quality leather conditioner to keep the material supple.

Which is better for work, the First or the City?

The Balenciaga First, with its structured shape and minimalist aesthetic, is generally a better choice for a professional work environment. The City's relaxed, edgy design may be too casual for more conservative workplaces.