Abercrombie Short vs. Extra Short: Which size is right for you?

The Abercrombie Short and Extra Short lengths differ primarily in coverage and style. The "Short" version offers a classic, mid-thigh length that provides balanced coverage for everyday wear, while the "Extra Short" cut sits much higher on the thigh for a trendy, intentionally revealing look that is more fashion-forward.

Here's everything you need to know to choose the right Abercrombie & Fitch short length for your style.

Abercrombie Short Length

The "Short" length is Abercrombie's standard, go-to option for a classic summer look. It's designed to provide a comfortable, versatile fit that hits around the mid-thigh, making it an easy choice for a wide variety of casual occasions without feeling overly conservative or revealing.

• What it is: A classic shorts length with a mid-thigh inseam, offering a balance of style and coverage.
• Key features: Versatile and suitable for most body types and casual situations, provides comfortable coverage, classic silhouette.
• Price: Tends to range from $40 - $70, depending on the specific style and material.
• Materials/Construction: Typically made from high-quality cotton blends with elastane for stretch, ensuring both durability and comfort.
• Sizing/Fit: Generally fits true to size with a comfortable, relaxed feel that isn't too tight or constricting.
• Pros: Highly versatile for everything from errands to casual lunches. Flattering on most body types. Comfortable coverage for easy movement. A timeless look that won't go out of style quickly.
• Cons: Might feel less trendy or daring for fashion-forward shoppers. May not provide the leg-lengthening effect of a shorter cut.

This length is perfect for anyone seeking a reliable, stylish, and comfortable short that works for nearly any casual activity.

Shop this product: abercrombie.com/us/womens-shorts

Abercrombie Extra Short Length

The "Extra Short" length is Abercrombie's answer to modern trends, offering a bold and daring silhouette. Sitting high on the thigh, this cut is designed to be intentionally revealing, creating a leg-lengthening effect that's popular for festivals, beach days, and hot weather styling.

• What it is: A high-thigh, fashion-forward shorts length designed for minimal coverage and a trendy aesthetic.
• Key features: Approximately 2-3 inches shorter than the standard "Short" length. Enhances the look of longer legs. Youthful and on-trend style.
• Price: Ranges from $40 - $70, often priced similarly to the "Short" length.
• Materials/Construction: Made from the same quality cotton and elastane blends as the brand's other shorts.
• Sizing/Fit: The fit can feel tighter or more snug due to the higher cut. Many shoppers recommend sizing up if they're between sizes or prefer a bit more room.
• Pros: Creates a modern, trendy look that can make legs appear longer. Great for hot climates or situations where minimal fabric is desired. Expresses a confident, youthful style.
• Cons: Offers very limited coverage, which is not suitable for all occasions or personal comfort levels. Prone to riding up during movement. Can be less versatile than the standard "Short" length.

This cut is ideal for the confident shopper who prioritizes a bold, on-trend look and is comfortable with a more revealing fit.

Shop this product: abercrombie.com/us/womens-shorts

Abercrombie Short vs. Extra Short Comparison

Coverage & Length

The most obvious difference is the inseam and overall coverage. The Short length is a classic mid-thigh cut that offers enough coverage for you to move, bend, and sit comfortably without feeling exposed. It's a versatile, safe choice for everyday wear.

The Extra Short length is significantly shorter, by about two to three inches. It hits high up on the thigh, just below the hip area, for a look that's all about showing leg. This minimal coverage is what defines its trendy style but also makes it less practical for certain activities or more conservative settings.

Fit & Comfort

Both lengths are made from the same comfortable, stretchy fabrics, so the material itself isn't a distinguishing factor. The "Short" length typically offers a true-to-size, relaxed fit that moves with you easily. You won't have to worry much about adjusting them throughout the day.

In contrast, the "Extra Short" length can feel limiting. While great for standing and walking, the short inseam means they are more likely to ride up and may feel revealing when lunging or sitting down. Many people choose to size up in this length - not for the waist, but to get a little extra fabric for better coverage and a less constricting feel on the thighs.

Style & Versatility

For sheer versatility, the "Short" length wins easily. It's appropriate for family barbecues, running errands, travel days, and lunch with friends. The classic cut pairs well with almost anything, from a simple t-shirt to a dressier blouse, making it a foundational piece in a summer wardrobe.

The "Extra Short" is a statement piece. It thrives in specific environments like music festivals, beach clubs, or casual summer date nights where a fashion-forward look is the goal. While less versatile for everyday life, it serves its purpose perfectly as a trendy item meant to be noticed. Styling them requires more consideration to avoid looking too casual or overly exposed.

Which One Should You Choose?

Both options deliver on Abercrombie's quality and comfort, but cater to different style preferences and lifestyles.

Choose the Short length if:

• You prioritize comfort and versatility for everyday wear.
• You want a classic, timeless short that you can wear for multiple seasons.
• You prefer not to worry about coverage when you sit or bend down.
• You're looking for an effortless, easy-to-style piece that works for most casual scenarios.

Choose the Extra Short length if:

• You love keeping up with the latest fashion trends and want a bold, youthful look.
• You want shorts that create the illusion of longer legs.
• You primarily wear shorts for hot weather outings, beach days, or festivals.
• You are comfortable with showing a lot of leg and prefer minimal fabric.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the main difference between Abercrombie Short and Extra Short?

The primary difference is length and coverage. The "Short" length has a standard inseam that hits mid-thigh for versatile everyday wear. The "Extra Short" has a much shorter inseam that sits high on the thigh for a trendier, more revealing fit.

How much shorter is the Extra Short length?

The "Extra Short" is approximately 2 to 3 inches shorter than the standard "Short" length, which makes a considerable difference in both look and coverage.

Should I size up for Abercrombie Extra Short shorts?

Many shoppers recommend sizing up in the Extra Short length if you are in-between sizes or desire a slightly looser fit on your thighs. This can provide a little more comfort and length and prevent them from feeling too tight.

Are the Short and Extra Short lengths the same price?

Yes, in most styles, both lengths have a similar price point. Any variation in price is typically due to the specific short style (e.g., denim vs. linen) rather than the inseam length itself.

Do Extra Short shorts ride up when you walk?

Due to their very short inseam, the "Extra Short" length is more prone to riding up than the standard "Short" length. This is worth noting, especially if this bothers you in other clothing items you regularly purchase.

Which length is more versatile for everyday wear?

The "Short" length is undoubtedly more versatile. With its classic cut and moderate coverage, this length is suitable for a broader array of locations, activities, and occasions, from running errands to a casual dinner out.

Which length might be more flattering for all figure types?

This depends on which areas of a person's body they want to draw attention to. The "Short" length provides a balanced, proportional fit. The "Extra Short" can create a visually longer look since it makes the legs appear longer. However, depending on the fit and personal preference, it can also draw attention higher on the thigh.

What is the difference between purchasing in-store and online? Are returns free either way if needed to change to a different size?

Many of Abercrombie's shorts fit differently on various body types. If possible, it is recommended to try these shorts on at a physical retail location. However, Abercrombie's shipping is quick and convenient, and if a different type or size is needed, their online portal provides an easy way to exchange your order for the size you prefer.